5 ms·
The facts in this UK diplomatic cable are disputed, but it has some terrifying details: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/UK_cable_on_Tiananmen_Square_Massacre htt
by rwmj 7y ago
The facts in this UK diplomatic cable are disputed, but it has some terrifying details:
https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/UK_cable_on_Tiananmen_Square_Massacre https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/UK_cable_on_Tiananmen_Square_...
- m-i-l 7y agoOne of the things I hadn't fully appreciated, until reading the link, was how divided even the perpetrators were. Firstly, there are indications that not all the armies worked together, e.g. "Beijing [Military Region] commander had refused to supply outside armies with food, water or barracks", and the suggestion that different armies may have had allegiance to different factions in the State Council, e.g. "we cannot substantiate reports that six military regions (not Beijing) support Li Peng". And secondly, if the information is correct, it seems the atrocities were committed by the 27 Army who were just one of at least 8 other armies present. Furthermore there are even multiple references to troops from other armies being victims of the 27 Army, e.g. "27 Army APCs [Armored Personnel Carriers] opened fire on the crowd (both civilians and soldiers) ... APCs ran over troops and civilians", "27 Army ordered to spare noone and shot wounded SMR [Shenyang Military Region] soldiers". And even within the 27 Army itself "27 Army officer shot dead by own troops apparently because he faltered". Sounds quite chaotic.
- scarmig 7y agoThe protesters were also beset by factionalism. One issue the government had was that it didn't have a reliable partner in negotiations: different student groups had a diverse range of goals, from anti-corruption measures, to more socialism, to more capitalism, to freedom of speech, to democracy, to better housing standards, to lower tuition. And there was a constant tension between moderate and hardline student groups. Imagine if Occupy Wall Street was 100,000 strong and had occupied Times Square, and the city of New York was trying to negotiate with them to meet their demands.
- fasthandle 7y agoTerrifying indeed. No comment other than for others to please read this.
- onetimemanytime 7y agoWhat did they do to the bodies? But then, since the Party is/was in power the burial sites would be off limits and cleaned many times over. I wonder what would have happened to China at that time had the Government fallen? Civil war, many smaller states...? They have no history of democracy
- mieseratte 7y agoThey detail it in the linked cable, but it involves incinerating mutilated remains.
- onetimemanytime 7y ago>>APCS THEN RAN OVER BODIES TIME AND TIME AGAIN TO MAKE QUOTE PIE UNQUOTE AND REMAINS COLLECTED BY BULLDOZER. REMAINS INCINERATED AND THEN HOSED DOWN DRAINS. Considering the task at hand, pretty smart. Just burn them so not much remains. Weeks, months and years later, no evidence at all.
- lobotryas 7y agoRead the cable. They (allegedly), pulverized the bodies into a “pie” by repeatedly running them over with APCs, then washed them down drains and disinfected.
- amorphic 7y agoIn an ABC (Australia) news story this week a journalist who was involved back in 1989 recounted that families were only allowed to collect the bodies of victims from hospitals and morgues if they agreed to sign a document confirming that the victim had died under "accidental circumstances". This was one means by which the official bodycount was understated.
- mieseratte 7y agoThat is an incredible read. I knew Tiananmen was bad, but I didn’t realize it was that bad. The part about body disposal is nothing short of terrifying.
- mrguyorama 7y agoCuriosity; Who disputes them other than China? And with what evidence?
- tepidandroid 7y agoThe top voted comment from basically the same thread in 2017 [1] does a good job of presenting a point of contention in a relatively neutral fashion: from the /u/aleyan: > The figure was given in a secret diplomatic cable from then British ambassador to China, Alan Donald. > Mr Donald's telegram is from 5 June, and he says his source was someone who "was passing on information given him by a close friend who is currently a member of the State Council". Here we have a telegram by a guy (British Ambassador) who heard from a guy (unknown) who heard from a guy (unknown State Council) facts about the events of the day prior (massacre was on June 4th). Where did the unknown State Council official get his estimates from; were those official or just something he heard and repeated (and when did he get them)? Initial estimates of disasters are often quite wrong; here they were produced in game of telephone in a day or less; and they are not collaborated by any evidence we have now. I rank the quality of new evidence as low. Rumors repeated in old official telegrams are still rumors. I expected BBC to have reported more critically. Alan Donald is still alive; BBC could have asked him if he received any updates to that first number that he trusted more. I also have to fault BBC for it's phrasing around Donald's source. At first reading it sounded like Donald's source is an unnamed member of the State Council who is a close friend of the Ambassador. After reading BBC's sentence a carefully however; it sounds like the Donald's source is a person who is a friend of an unnamed member of the State Council. This ambiguous sentence is deceptive. EDIT: I see vote count moving up and down on this comment making me think it is controversial. If you disagree with my doubts on the veracity of this story, write a comment. Maybe I missed something. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15993956 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15993956
- CharlesColeman 7y agoThe solution to this problem is for the PRC to open up their state archives and allow thorough on-the-ground historical investigation of these events.