4 ms·
Seriously though, I have done a bunch of “wikipedia research” on how flight evolved. It’s all a bunch of “just so” stories and theories, which struggle to prove
by EGreg 7y ago
Seriously though, I have done a bunch of “wikipedia research” on how flight evolved. It’s all a bunch of “just so” stories and theories, which struggle to prove any evolutionary advantage to intermediate forms that can’t achieve flight or even gliding.
I think the evolution of flight is one of the clearest examples that the standard theories of evolution purely by mutation and natural selection are still lacking explanatory power. I understand that the theory of Common Descent has ample evidence but let’s not conflate that with the other theories (about HOW genetic drift happens in macroevolution) and turn “evolution” into a religion in our quest to replace creationist accounts. It is a catch-all umbrella term to describe many theories, from “punctuated equilibria” to the “modern synthesis”, which still are in their infancy as the luminiferous aether or phlogiston as physical theories.
I find there is too much suppression of dissenting views in evolutionary and climate science, for my taste. I am talking about universities and publishers taking concerted political action against what is perceived as going against the current establishment.
A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it. - Max Planck
In many circles, publishing anything critical on scientific grounds is like publicly criticizing capitalism in USA or Islam in Saudi Arabia. A lot of time you get instant downvotes and hostile responses from laypeople.
If you’re curious what I’m talking about, here is probably one of the better treatments of the mathematics behind current theories, for example:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/1880582244/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_r.M9CbRRG16AF https://www.amazon.com/dp/1880582244/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_r....
- pif 7y ago> I find there is too much suppression of dissenting views in evolutionary and climate science, I think idiots are not ignored enough in our current society. Science is about what can be observed. Theories are only useful as long as they predict right results. Opionions are irrelevant.
- EGreg 7y agoExactly. Theories are only useful as long as they predict right results. That’s what separates, say, the theory of common descent, from the current crop of theories about HOW flight evolved. They have ZERO predictive power. They are closer to “just-so” stories. Such theories should be rightly called unscientific compared to theories that have far more falsifiability and predictive power. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability
- philbarr 7y agoAre you suggesting that creationism is a valid theory?
- foldr 7y agoThere's nothing in EGreg's comments to indicate that. I don't think accusing people of being creationists when they say something mildly critical of some branch of evolutionary biology is conducive to a good discussion.
- philbarr 7y agoIn their initial comment they write: ...and turn “evolution” into a religion in our quest to replace creationist accounts.
- war1025 7y agoHe means it in a sense of turning it into a new creation story that is above reproach instead of treating it as a working theory that needs to be continually investigated and refined.
- philbarr 7y agoPossibly, or possibly he's finding reasons to rebuff evolution so that the only remaining answer is intelligent design. But neither of us know that, so that's why I asked.
- tylerjwilk00 7y agoHere is an intermediate form theory I just came up with as I read your comment. FALL SURVIVAL THEORY OF WING EVOLUTION Any tree dwelling creature is at risk of falling and dying. Creatures that can better survive a fall (proto-wings, etc) have an improved chance of propagating this trait to off-spring. Furthermore, if they can better survive a fall they can risk higher climbs. The higher climbs make them better able to avoid predators and hunt prey further increasing selection pressure on fall survival and would dovetail nicely into gliding mutations. From there it is not a far jump to flying [pun intended]. No theory about the deep deep past can ever be certain. We weren't there to watch it happen.
- EGreg 7y agoThat just illustrates my point. The ability to come up with THEORIES is not the same thing as validating SCIENTIFIC theories which are falsifiable. Just because it’s easy to come up with a theory off the cuff means there is a lot more work to do in actually explaining how something happened. Phlogiston and Luminiferous Ether were two theories in physics that actually had WAY MORE evidence for them than these, but turned out to be wrong. What separates a mere theory from a scientifically validated theory is falsifiability and experiment: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability
- tylerjwilk00 7y agoSo your solution to difficulty is simply that we should give up trying? No Thanks. Theories are a prerequisite to scientific experiment.
- foldr 7y agoThat's a bizarre reading of EGreg's comment. If the best theories that we have at present in some domain are weak, then we should acknowledge that. Doing so obviously doesn't prevent people from trying to develop better theories. On the contrary, it should spur them on.
- 7y ago
- 1e-9 7y agoI think it is quite plausible that feathers originally developed for thermoregulation. If they started as simple filaments that could be raised and lowered to adjust radiative surface area, it seems that thermoregulatory advantages alone could have driven a series of small evolutionary improvements towards flat, light-weight feather-like structures. Seeing a bird able to massively fluff up its feathers or pull them in tight against its body is like seeing a person instantly go from wearing a puffy down coat for winter to a sleek body suit for summer exercise. From there, I can imagine how these flat, controllable surfaces could be used by small animals to eventually control rapid descent from trees to escape prey and then eventually evolving to flight.
- EGreg 7y agoWe can certainly explore that theory, but what can you suggest as falsifiability criteria? Flight evolved several times, presumably, including in insects and in mammals without feathers: https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/vertebrates/flight/bats.html https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/vertebrates/flight/bats.html Notice: We can infer that bats gradually evolved true flight from a gliding arboreal ancestor, possibly using the gliding membrane as a sort of "net" while the flight stroke evolved. We can infer this because we beg the question, i.e. the only way evolution can happen is random mutation and natural selection. And so, we postulate the theory as true fact and then we get the result that it must have happened some way that is consistent with the theory. I am just generally remarking on the fact that all that seems to be required in today's scientific environment is to describe what could have happened with some arboreal ancestor gaining, say, webbed wing-like arms for some reason, and then over thousands and millions of generations for some reason, before the webbed arms could help them glide, they were accepted instead of shunned by their mates for their mutation, and the mutant population survived and genetically drifted in that direction, until finally they could glide... and then fly.
- 1e-9 7y agoI suggest no falsifiable criteria at this time and I likely never will. I merely point out intellectually interesting plausibility. If you restrict all of your consideration to only those things you already know how to prove or disprove, I think you severely limit ultimate discovery. Sure, you want to strive for determining truth, but I think it starts with curiosity, brainstorming, and inspiration. By the way, even snakes have figured out how to fly, or at least glide pretty well (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flying_snakes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flying_snakes).
- Scarblac 7y agoThe theory of gravity doesn't try to explain where every apple that ever fell from a tree landed exactly.
- foldr 7y agoNo, and part of the reason that it can't is that the apple is subject to forces other than gravitational forces.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoIsn't DNA comparison between species supposed to get some idea of what came first? Shouldn't we be able to answer Which Came First, feathers or flight?
- ncmncm 7y agoIt's a dumb question, really. What would they use to fly with, before the feathers -- pixie dust? There is a legitimate question: what did they use feathers for, before they used them to fly with? Because nobody ever grew feathers just because they wanted to fly real bad. All kids try it. Doesn't work. It turns out feathers are really, really useful for all kinds of things, if you look. So, "what else are feathers for?" doesn't narrow down much how it led to flying. We know how squirrels, frogs, fish, even tree snakes get lots of reproductive fitness by catching air. Best bet is, it was something similar. Nailing down the exact process will take a hell of a lot of fossils. Then we can start on pterosaurs and bats which don't, you know, use feathers.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAgain, DNA should give some answers. About the relative timing of precursors to feathers for instance. Or ancilliary genes/proteins to feather production - are they used for anything else? All this could point to feathers-before-flight. Not such a dumb question?
- matt_kantor 7y agoUnfortunately DNA doesn't last that long. We'd need samples from something like ~200 million years ago, but DNA only survives about 1 million year even under the best conditions. EDIT: Unless you were talking about comparing DNA from living species. The closest living relative to birds is crocodilians, but they're pretty distant from one another and might not be useful for the kind of analysis you suggested.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoYes this type of analysis is usually done on existing branches of life. With some evidence in the fossil record of when those forms diverged, a before-and-after picture can be formed?
- jsight 7y agoI don't have much to add to this, but I am amazed that basically every comment that you've made in this thread is downvoted, while almost none of the others are. It isn't necessarily that you are right or wrong, but your thoughts are interesting and well presented and yet they have managed to prick some intrinsically negative emotional response. Human nature... sigh.
- ncmncm 7y agoNo, it's just that we have seen this dance plenty of times before. None of it is ever original. It's all cribbed from the same tired script: "phlogiston" this, "ether" that. Ultimately it always leads to, "but how can you know, really know?" The intent is always the same, too: Not to evoke subtle insights, or to open up new vistas of thought; but to gather in the pigeons who crave really knowing, and fatten them up on deception. Concealing subtext doesn't mean there's no subtext. BS presented well is still BS. There is far more to know than science has ever even looked at. Not because it's not interesting, useful, or earthshaking, but just because science is hard, and we've been at it for less than 1000 years. There is plenty that science's best efforts had wrong and improved upon, and plenty that's still wrong. Not because we're blinkered and pigheaded (although everyone is) but because it takes time, and we don't each have much, while jokers like this, congratulating themselves on their cleverness despite never having had a single original idea, waste it. Do I sound disgusted? Yes, I said I have seen this before.
- EGreg 7y agoYeah, I’m sure you have seen or heard before noises that rational people made about your unscientific theories, and then... wilfully ignored them! Phlogiston? Ether? Pssht. They were obviously wrong, but my theory is right cause... well cause if not, you’re a creationist! Why else can you POSSIBLY say that my theory is unfalsifiable? I mean, sure, it is, but hey... your expectations are too high. In this area of science, falsifiability is just too much to ask for. Hey dudes! Guess why men fall asleep after an orgasm? It’s so the woman could get away, in the past! It must be true cause: 1) Evolution can only happen by random mutation and natural selection that increases fitness 2) I just need to describe a possible story about how the trait is an adaptation that gave some ability to survive better, sorta 3) And I win! Profit. The game has simple rules. Dude that game is not science. Accept it. Ad hominems won’t get you out of this embarassing situation of calling non-scientific stuff science. And frankly I can day the same about multiverse theories, they are a copout. Anything, including fine tuning of any constants, is explainable by postulating an infinite number of possible universes. To me this is just like another religion. You just want to claim it’s science. But it is NOT SCIENCE. And your disgust is just an attempt to avoid logic and use feelings and bullying to make people agree with you. Same old story. You accuse people of being creationists, as if that somehow makes your theory more valid. Well the shoe is on the other foot. What you have motivating you is that you are against theism. You’d rather believe any unfalsifiable theory as long as it doesn’t involve something Daniel Dennett calls a “skyhook”. Because psychologically you prefer simple things leading to more complex things. That matches your intuition. Well, classical physics matches our intuition too but it can’t explain quantum phenomena. So we challenge our intuitions. Multiverse theories and a bunch of just-so stories that beg the question are cute. But what’s not cute is the rabid religious fervor that makes you LIE and say they are just as scientific as the theory of common descent or special relativity. They are not. And your emotional tantrums and bullying are disgusting to others.