5 ms·
> they reached agreements to buy federal greenhouse gas credits from Tesla. In other words it's not much of a statement about Tesla, it's just a credit system
by wongarsu 7y ago
> they reached agreements to buy federal greenhouse gas credits from Tesla.
In other words it's not much of a statement about Tesla, it's just a credit system working as intended. Tesla has credits left over because they don't sell ICE cars, GM predicts that if the next president is Democrat they might need more credits so they buy now while they are cheap.
- thenaturalist 7y agoGiven that Tesla can supply those credits owing to its role as the first car producer to massively push EV over ICE technology and hence not produce common costs (CO2 emissions), this is a statement about Tesla and its position in the car industry in my book. It's not a technological breakthrough, but in a world where common costs will be more factored into the balance sheets of those who create them, the fact that Tesla can be on the sell side of this and the trend to further quantify those costs might position them well.
- yostrovs 7y agoIt's not a technological achievement. It's a political one, as the middle class gets to subsidize the autopilot of the upper class, while the upper class gets to feel smug as though it's saving the world.
- codedokode 7y agoOr you can look from the other side: people who buy cars that pollute air pay for the development of better cars.
- benj111 7y agoThe whole point is it's not a subsidy, it's properly assigning costs. Up until now ICE manufacturers and users havent being paying for the full costs of that technology, everyone has been subsidising them, this is designed to cancel that subsidy out.
- reitzensteinm 7y agoIt's better assigning costs, but still bad. A carbon tax is really the only way that works. Society subsidized $10k on a Tesla purchase for someone to commute to work, but offered no incentive to take public transport, carpool or work remotely. It's a shame that it's such a hard sell politically.
- benj111 7y agoTrue, but don't let good be the enemy of perfect. For a potential car buyer, this is a good incentive to steer them towards better choices. Btw, it isn't society subsidising Tesla, its GM and Fiat Crysler customers. Or are you talking about tax credits? Perhaps? But on the other hand they were still paying more than what an equivalent ICE car would cost, so it isn't a free ride for them either. In the end society hopefully gets a sustainable EV industry, at a lower cost than if the government had done it themselves, isn't that what we should be comparing it against?
- xienze 7y ago> Btw, it isn't society subsidising Tesla It isn't? Who paid for that $7500 tax credit?
- magwa101 7y agoTech always starts at the high end, then comes down to everyone. R&D has to be subsidized some how, this is the common cycle. With wars over oil, pollution, environmental destruction it seems like we've all been subsidizing our desire for cheap energy for sometime. Credits appear to be a lot more efficient to me.
- jrochkind1 7y agoIf it _worked_ to reduce our overall carbon emissions, I wouldn't see this as a problem. As right now the pain of future generations is "subsidizing" our cheap energy and technology -- and as the shit hits the fan, I guarantee the rich will still be the most insulated from the pain by their wealth. We got to find some way to deal with climate change and our destruction of the environment, and any way is going to make energy and tech more expensive for everyone. Because it is cheaper to not worry about the devastation we are wreaking."externalized costs". I just don't think it really works, it's just financial games in which the rich, as usual, profit the most. The owners of GM and Fiat Chrysler as much as the owners of Tesla.
- mrfredward 7y agoIf you can afford a brand new SUV, you can afford to pay the costs of your pollution.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoIt's an expedient choice. A more efficient mechanism would be to use a carbon tax to fully capture the externalities of energy use so that the market makes decisions with full information. But $10 or $20 per gallon gas would lead to riots in the streets.
- jlj 7y agoI'd ride my bike everywhere at that price.
- b1daly 7y agoThe middle class enjoy the benefits of subsidies to the oil industry already. They are also getting cheaper prices due to the political resistance of including the costs of atmospheric carbon dioxide to the planet. If the middle class would be willing to pay a carbon tax, then the current system would be needed.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoI believe you meant to say "then the current system wouldn't be needed".
- jiveturkey 7y agoWhat you meant to say is that finally, politics has achieved something. The externalities of ICE are finally being paid for by the users of ICE.
- notaki 7y agoThe middle class can buy Model 3s and get the tax credit as well. And the top 25% paid 85.97% of total income tax in 2016. So I think you have it backwards.
- bunderbunder 7y agoAnd possibly an illustration for the public of how the system was intended to work. I'm not sure everyone quite understands that one big difference between a cap-and-trade type system and a simple excise tax is that an excise tax puts constant downward pressure on pollution, while the cap-and-trade type system only encourages the industry to reduce their externalities to whatever level the government picked as a target.
- gmac 7y agoBut if the government picked a tax rate, they'd likely do it with a forecast in mind of what externality would remain, so it only makes a difference in as far as there's uncertainty, and then only until the next round of permit quantities is picked.
- new_realist 7y agoIf Tesla were serious about advancing sustainable transport, they wouldn't sell credits to polluters. By enabling others to pollute that much more, it undoes much of the benefit from buying a Tesla.
- ceejayoz 7y ago"We can go bankrupt, or we can let our polluting competitors fund our R&D. Which should we choose?" "Oh, definitely the bankruptcy."
- jagannathtech 7y agoIt's amazing how many here are so disconnected from reality.... (ps. the id of the person you are replying to :D )
- istjohn 7y agoThis is true. It is a subtle problem with carbon offsets that is hard to understand intuitively even if it's logically straightforward. It makes being a truly "Green" consumer difficult when a "Green" producer can turn around and sell carbon offsets or the like based on the product you purchased.
- DeonPenny 7y agoThats under the assumption that without Tesla they'd make electric cars which is a bad assumption because they are building their biggest competitor which is their worse nightmare. A more likely idea would be that without tesla they'd just pay the taxes or lobby for them to be lower citing the fact that they can't hit the goal like they have been in other places like the EU.
- zaroth 7y agoThere’s uncertainty at the Federal level, but at the State level, the CA ZEV credits program (which has also been adopted by 9 other states representing in total ~30% of new car sales) will be the tail that wags the dog; ”Manufacturers are required to produce a number of ZEVs and plug-in hybrids each year, based on the total number of cars sold in California by the manufacturer. Manufacturers with higher overall sales of all vehicles are required to make more ZEVs. Requirements are in terms of percent credits, ranging from 4.5% in 2018 to 22% by 2025” https://www.arb.ca.gov/msprog/zevprog/factsheets/zev_regulation_factsheet_082418.pdf https://www.arb.ca.gov/msprog/zevprog/factsheets/zev_regulat... About 75% of GMs current credit balance comes from TZEV vehicles, but TZEVs are phased out and an increasingly large share of credits must be BEV going forward; https://cdn.motor1.com/images/mgl/VZ44G/s1/carb-zev-percentage-by-year.jpg https://cdn.motor1.com/images/mgl/VZ44G/s1/carb-zev-percenta...