3 ms·
"It is illegal for instance to criticize a court decision." this can't be for real. when did France become so conservative?
by kmlx 7y ago
"It is illegal for instance to criticize a court decision."
this can't be for real.
when did France become so conservative?
- nraynaud 7y agoClovis baptism? You have to understand that France has some other traits that are way more progressive than in the US: crossing the street is not a crime, you won't be arrested for drinking in the street, women work more than in the US, and they get married less, birth control and abortions are covered by insurance. The balance is different than in the US, but people have a longer life expectancy with a way lower GDP/capita, so something is seriously right.
- krstf13 7y agoThis can’t be for real and isn’t. It is illegal to try to criticise a court decision in a way that is designed to impede the justice system and/or to interfere with the independence of the judiciary.
- cm2187 7y agoI am not a lawyer but as far as I am aware it is illegal to say publicly for instance that a court decision was politically motivated. You might argue that it would undermine the justice system but this is 100% in lack of accountability territory.
- krstf13 7y agoYou can say publicly that a court decision was politically motivated. What matters is how it is said and somewhat by whom (a member of the government might be held to higher standards).
- x220 7y ago>What matters is how it is said and somewhat by whom That means you can't say it. You might be able to say it, depending on who you upset.
- seszett 7y agoIt's not true. They're talking about a law from 1958 (under a conservative president, like almost all of them until 1981) that makes it illegal to criticise a court decision in order to undermine the legitimacy of justice. It's okay to criticise a court decision if you just don't agree with it, but not to say "see this judgments? it shows all judges are corrupted".
- x220 7y agoSo who decides if criticism undermines the legitimacy of justice? The same judges that are being criticized?