3 ms·
There is space for improvement. I tried the neo-layout for a while which is optimized for German and it certainly feels good. However: 1. you have a hard time
by atoav 7y ago
There is space for improvement. I tried the neo-layout for a while which is optimized for German and it certainly feels good. However:
1. you have a hard time with every single set of default shortcuts there is
2. as soon as you switch languages it falls apart
3. as soon as you are using someone elses Computer it falls apart
I started to use the English layout with some custom mappings (for Umlauts) entirely and never looked back. The gap towards the default German one is not too big to slow you down too much, yet programming doesn’t feel like a total pain.
- bscphil 7y agoAs a Dvorak user, I'm already paying these penalties, so switching to another layout wouldn't be that big a deal. On another note, I'm rather skeptical of Colemak and other layouts that overly resemble Qwerty. It seems almost certain that they're sacrificing some degree of improvement for similarity to the layout most people are already familiar with. That's the main reason I learned and continue to use Dvorak.
- simias 7y agoI'm also a long time Dvorak user and I looked into other layouts and while some of them seemed interesting or even superior to Dvorak the difference is probably too small to justify learning a new layout. Even the Colemak FAQ says as much: https://colemak.com/FAQ#Is_it_worth_switching_from_Dvorak_to_Colemak.3F https://colemak.com/FAQ#Is_it_worth_switching_from_Dvorak_to... >I'm rather skeptical of Colemak and other layouts that overly resemble Qwerty. It seems almost certain that they're sacrificing some degree of improvement for similarity to the layout You might be wrong about that, see http://mkweb.bcgsc.ca/carpalx/?popular_alternatives http://mkweb.bcgsc.ca/carpalx/?popular_alternatives for a rather in-depth analysis of keyboard layouts. Some QWERTY-like layouts manage to score overall better, although the difference is not huge. Personally these days I'm more interesting in experimenting with different keyboard shapes rather than tweaking the layout some more. I'm currently playing with OpenSCAD to create a custom 3D printed split ortholinear keyboard in the spirit of the Dactyl.
- fsiefken 7y agoI use a Dvorak layout with the I and U reversed as in Dutch and English the I is used more frequent. I could change and optimize more but then I compatibility would be less (remapping is not always easy). I can fallback to qwerty if needed. Ad 3: I use Karabiner-Elements on MacOS en Autohotkey on Windows to easily switch. I sometimes write German, but I don't bother with the umlauts, I suffix with e... not sure if a German reader finds that annoying.
- atoav 7y agoI think German readers are used to read oe and ae and ue instead of ö, ä, ü etc. Decreases parsability slighty because you might not be used to the visual pattern of the whole word, but unless you are writing a book, nobody will bother. Germans themselves would write it that way if the font has no umlauts or they are stuck with ASCII for other reasons. I mapped right alt + a to ä, right alt + s to ß etc, which works quite well. The thing I like best is right alt + number for superscript number, because you can quickly make footnotes in any text that way. What I liked about the neo layout is the concept of having different “layers”, for mathematical notations, greek letters etc. and this only shows how little thought actually went into most official layouts..
- fsiefken 7y agoThat's a great tip, it's obvious but I didn't think of that as I only incidentally write German. Layers are nice, but they can also be implemented in Dvorak.