4 ms·
The fact that I can't purchase any software for my iPhone without Apple taking a 30% cut absolutely harms me as a consumer. It naturally leads to higher prices.
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
The fact that I can't purchase any software for my iPhone without Apple taking a 30% cut absolutely harms me as a consumer. It naturally leads to higher prices.
- cpuguy83 7y agoI think you would have a hard time proving this, because software prices are much (much) cheaper than they were pre-app store.
- wavefunction 7y agoThat assertion seems harder to prove than the assertion that a 30% built-in cost leads to higher prices.
- cpuguy83 7y agoHow is it harder to prove? It's completely provable and even a huge complaint of developers of the platform. Everyone expects free/0.99 apps and it costs way more to produce and support them. Apps, before we had an app store, were absolutely more expensive than this. Which apps are expensive? Not to defend Apple here, but when the store was introduced people didn't mind the 30% hit because: 1. Credit card processing wasn't as easy as it is today, and the store takes care of all that 2. Store hands distribution and listing Before the app store we actually had to go to a physical store to buy software. Sure some you could buy online but really not all that much (comparatively) and discoverability was basically "hope someone with a big blog or CNET review it". Of course now it is difficult to be discovered because there's tons and tons of other things out there. CC processing is not difficult and there are companies like Stripe that you can go through... etc.
- pmart123 7y ago15% when the subscription is over a year and the 30% cut only applies to digital goods so Uber, Lyft and food delivery, for instance, are exempt. My guess is these fees will continue to drop naturally over time, but they probably haven't dropped fast enough.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoOther than government intervention, what incentive does Apple have to lower their fees, particularly as they intend for "services" to be an increased money maker going forward? Perhaps more importantly, why should consumers be subject to Apple's good will? If consumers were able to acquire software from other sources, the market would naturally determine how much of a cut Apple actually deserves.
- kortilla 7y agoWhen people buy a different phone, obviously. If iPhones are so much more expensive that it’s harming you as a consumer, why don’t you switch to one of the many android options?
- gwd 7y agoThis is nonsense. You can just buy a different phone -- there are dozens of companies out there. Apple's "tax" allows them to pay for software without selling my data. At the moment, I have a choice: 1) Buy software funded by spying on me (any Android phone) 2) Buy software funded by selling to me (and iPhone). If they're forced to "open up" their platform, then their revenue stream becomes more difficult, and I don't have choice any more. If you want to have all your software funded by letting people spy on you, then go for it. But don't take away my choice.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> Apple's "tax" allows them to pay for software without selling my data. It does? macOS seems to do well enough on the privacy front. I don't think Apple's App Store, or its 30% cut, needs to disappear, but consumers should have the option of running software from outside the store too. That's adding choice, not taking it away.
- gwd 7y ago> It does? macOS seems to do well enough on the privacy front. And my laptop is a lot more expensive than my phone. Look, you're presumably complaining because you either own, or want to own, an iPhone, in spite of there being dozens of other phones with similar features, and hundreds more with different features. The feature / price point combination of those phones are in part a result of the App Store policies. Changing that cut will change the feature / price point: they'd have to charge more, or give you less, or find alternate sources of revenue (i.e., start spying on you). Now, maybe their business model would work fine without having to resort to ads or raise the prices too much. But maybe it won't. The only way to find out would be to risk destroying it. Which is completely unnecessary, given that there are so many alternatives. If you don't like their policies, don't buy their phone. If Spotify doesn't like paying a 30% cut, they don't have to make an iPhone app. There are lots of other options out there.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> And my laptop is a lot more expensive than my phone. It's not for many people. An iPhone X starts at $1,000. > The feature / price point combination of those phones are in part a result of the App Store policies. Changing that cut will change the feature / price point: they'd have to charge more, or give you less, or find alternate sources of revenue (i.e., start spying on you). Apple is a ridiculously profitable company. They quite literally have more money than they know what to do with, as evidenced by their enormous bank account. I'm happy Apple has been so successful, but I also think a portion of their inordinate profitability has come from anticompetitive practices, namely how locked down the app store is. They don't have a right to that particular revenue stream.