4 ms·
In what possible way would Chrome make money as a standalone company without utterly alienating its userbase? Chrome is subsidized by the rest of Google.
by JoshTriplett 7y ago
In what possible way would Chrome make money as a standalone company without utterly alienating its userbase?
Chrome is subsidized by the rest of Google.
- sfotm 7y agoOnly in the same way that Gmail and Android are "subsidized" by Google. They're sources of data and play directly into how they generate revenue. I agree that without those motivations it would be hard to fund these projects without them going paid or taking donations, but I take issue with calling them "subsidized".
- cm2187 7y agoBy doing like firefox, making money out of making google the default search engine. Which means their unique source of revenue (and client) would be google. Full circle...
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> By doing like firefox, making money out of making google the default search engine. Which means their unique source of revenue (and client) would be google. Full circle... However, a Chrome-with-Google-revenue would be far more independent of Google than Chrome-the-Google-Subsidiary. Mozilla/Firefox has shown that it's still possible to advance privacy even within such an arrangement. Also, its far from clear who would have the most power in such an arrangement. Without a popular browser of its own, Google will be forced to pay the browser vendors to stay the default, unless it wants to give a search engine competitor a chance to unseat it.
- whatshisface 7y agoIt only seems like Mozilla is independent because they are the most independent - a truly independent browser would probably do something shocking, like bundling adblock.
- CharlesColeman 7y agoIndependence comes in degrees, and I'm not convinced a "truly independent" browser would by truly better for consumers. It'd need a revenue model, and its not clear to me what that would be besides bundling with a paid product or displaying banner and text ads. Essentially Mozilla is selling ads, but only to one advertiser (Google) which is easy to disable.
- whatshisface 7y agoLinux doesn't have a revenue model... Although, doesn't Linus work for Google? There's also Blender. I'm sure we could think of a long list of others.
- abdullahkhalids 7y agoA good chunk of linux and related development is done by programmers being paid by some for-profit company in whose interest is it either to have those chunks developed or who want to keep their employees happy by letting them do open source contributions. Without this invisible injection of funds, linux development would slow down significantly and it might not remain competitive. Browsers are a lot less modular than operating systems and they operate in a different market (eg. contributing to their development doesn't help the bottom line of any company particularly), so Firefox doesn't get a lot of paid for third-party developer time. Hence, Mozilla makes unfortunate compromises.
- dredmorbius 7y agoTorvalds is employed by the Linux Foundation.
- antisthenes 7y agoWait, hold on. Why does a browser need a revenue model? Why can't a browser just be a piece of software that's "finished", with the occasional security patch? Chrome is incredibly overcomplex because it attempts to be more than just a browser, and it is part of Google's strategy. A regular browser doesn't have to be an OS in itself.
- 43920 7y agoGoogle (or another search engine) would pay Chrome to be included as the default search engine, the same way that Firefox exists now.
- stingraycharles 7y agoWould this not defeat the purpose of splitting them up? Are they then not equally likely to behave in a way that favors Google?
- vageli 7y ago> Would this not defeat the purpose of splitting them up? Are they then not equally likely to behave in a way that favors Google? Would you characterize Mozilla as behaving in ways that favor Google?
- ForHackernews 7y agoCharge money to any OEM that wants to ship with Chrome: i.e. every single non-Apple manufacturer of phones, tablets or computers.