4 ms·
> I chose my words carefully I understand. I chose my words very carefully too when I said, "That assumption is precisely the problem." The reason we have du
by lisper 7y ago
> I chose my words carefully
I understand. I chose my words very carefully too when I said, "That assumption is precisely the problem."
The reason we have due process is not because society gets off on legal rituals, it's because a person can in fact be innocent despite the existence of overwhelming evidence to the contrary. As soon as you say, "Let's assume guilt," you've tossed due process out the window. "Innocent until proven guilty" is not just a catchy slogan. It's the bedrock of due process of law.
The answer to your question, "How is he being treated differently than what you would expect this hypothetical person should be treated?" is precisely that: you are hypothesizing his guilt before it has been proven. That is how he is being treated differently than I would hope and expect.
- colechristensen 7y agoYou are missing the point. I am trying to set aside determination of guilt and talk about due process, which it seems is very hard to do. Let's assume we are uninterested in Assange's guilt and only interested in due process. How is he being treated unfairly w.r.t. due process? (either illegally or if the laws are unjust, immorally)
- lisper 7y agoThe problem in Assange's case is that it is very hard to separate the charges being brought against him from the fact that he did something that is almost certainly legal but which the U.S. government would like very much to punish him for. The fact of the matter is that you can make someone's life miserable by bringing trumped-up charges against them, and this is especially easy to do if you're a powerful person. And if you're powerful enough then you can most likely do this with impunity. The possibility that this is happening to Assange needs to be taken very seriously. So no, there is no overt indication that Assange is being treated any differently from any other accused rapist. But anyone who is content to leave it at that has blinders on.
- Retra 7y agoPerhaps if somone named names and provided evidence of misconduct, they could take those blinders off under a pretense of actually seeing something?
- colechristensen 7y agoI keep asking and you keep failing to answer How is he being mistreated specifically.
- lisper 7y agoI don't know that he is being mistreated. I am saying that the possibility that he is being railroaded needs to be taken seriously [1]. That's all. And yes, I'm aware that his actions helped the current administration, and it therefore doesn't make sense that they would railroad him. But this would not be the first time that this administration threw a former ally under the bus. [1] https://www.newyorker.com/news/our-columnists/charging-julian-assange-under-the-espionage-act-is-an-attack-on-the-first-amendment https://www.newyorker.com/news/our-columnists/charging-julia...
- colechristensen 7y ago>hypothesizing his guilt before it has been proven >That is how he is being treated differently than I would hope and expect. You have problems with the assumption of guilt? Ok (setting aside how you know what people think), what actions are being taken as a result which are inappropriate? If you have problems with due process it can't just be with what people assume, it has to be with their decisions and actions? Put aside their assumptions and talk about actions. What is being done that violates due process? Assume everyone executing the process is an angel at heart, what actions are wrong and why? It has so far eluded me to get someone who thinks Assange is innocent to explain how he is being mistreated.
- effie 7y agoI don't claim he is innocent but the argument is well known: he is a journalist who had no obligations to the U.S. government regarding what they want to maintain a secret, so going after him for exposing some information is mistreating him and by implication an attack on independent journalism. U.S. government had a breach of security and ethics, but instead of quietly fixing that they target journalists.
- colechristensen 7y agoYou think that he is innocent and/or was outside US jurisdiction to the extent that indicting him and the following due process is immoral?
- effie 7y agoI don't know that. If there is a reason to believe he commited a crime that harmed the U.S.A., then the U.S. government going after him for that crime is to be expected. But the widespread concern here is that the government is going after him so devotedly not solely because of that harm, but because they seek to gain back face and intimidate other journalists. There are other possible ulterior motives. I don't have enough information to decide one way or another, but given what we know, the concern is reasonable.
- 7y ago