6 ms·
Not MS? They're all kinda up to the same shenanigans really
by Havoc 7y ago
Not MS?
They're all kinda up to the same shenanigans really
- Apocryphon 7y agoDouble jeopardy?
- anbop 7y agoIn case this isn't a joke, double jeopardy in the United States applies only to criminal cases, and two antitrust cases against one company need not necessarily be the same offense.
- manfredo 7y agoDoes Microsoft really have any monopolies? They have a big OS market share, but operating systems have become less and less relevant as mobile computing grows. Same deal with office. Bing is nowhere near the market share as google. Azure competes with AWS and others. Xbox competes with Sony and Nintendo. Microsoft store competes with Steam. IE and edge are also being beaten by Chrome. I think the argument that Microsoft has a monopoly is much less feasible. One acquaintance of mine that works at MS humorously remarked on the irony of situation along these lines, "Back in the day Microsoft was the Big Bad. But now we're not big in social media, we're not big in advertising or search. All these other companies are taking the heat now - not for our lack of trying to get into these spaces, though (laughs)."
- stcredzero 7y agoDoes Microsoft really have any monopolies? What's the difference between a monopoly/almost-monopoly and a really deep "moat?" "...All these other companies are taking the heat now - not for our lack of trying to get into these spaces, though (laughs)." We're #2. We try harder.
- Havoc 7y ago>Same deal with office. Excel? I'm in the finance world and I can say with confidence that they've got 100% market share. We use google sheet too. Every day even....for tracking everyone's QuizOfTheDay scores. Great track but not even close to Excel replacement.
- partiallypro 7y agoThat means Microsoft has a better product, that doesn't mean it's a monopoly.
- paxys 7y agoThose two aren't mutually exclusive
- partiallypro 7y agoYou're correct, but in this case it's clear Microsoft doesn't have a monopoly on spreadsheets. They just make the best software. They aren't bashing vendors over the head with Excel, etc. IMO the case for Apple or Microsoft being monopolistic is pretty weak compared to Google, Facebook and perhaps Amazon. Apple has a problem because it's such a walled garden. Microsoft generally doesn't have any of the problems the FAANG (sans Netflix) companies have. This, currently on the front page...sure doesn't sound like Excel is a monopoly https://foundationinc.co/lab/the-saas-opportunity-of-unbundling-excel/ https://foundationinc.co/lab/the-saas-opportunity-of-unbundl...
- the_watcher 7y agoWhat's the difference between this and Google's "monopoly" on search, which is again based on a superior product (You could argue the same about Facebook, but at least in the search case, there's no network effects tying people to using Google).
- myoon 7y agoThis isn't comprehensive, but no one has really talked about Excel being unfairly leveraged to prevent the entry of competitors, gain an unfair advantage in unrelated markets, or exploit its consumers. Now Google may not have done any of the above with search, but it's likely possible to argue that they have unfairly promoted their own products over others, or "unfairly" chose to not list certain websites.
- WalterBright 7y agoMSFT is getting hammered along with the rest, though.
- jefe_ 7y agoNot to say there aren't things they could probably be investigated for, but in the cases of search, cloud computing, and mobile Microsoft has actually been the 'underdog' competitor. They successfully gained inroads to cloud computing thanks to Azure, but Bing has never had the search market share of Google, and mobile offerings were never Android or iOS. Microsoft as the 'victim' of anti-competitive behavior would have been inconceivable 20 years ago, but technology changes that quickly and if you miss the boat you can find yourself in a very tricky spot.
- Havoc 7y agoAzure is like the 2nd biggest cloud. Underdog...I think not. I mentioned them mostly since it seems odd excluding them more than specific actions they took. Google is going to get wrecked on anti-trust somewhere though that's for sure. My money is on mobile or browser.
- partiallypro 7y agoAzure is still incredibly small compared to AWS, and it has plenty of competition. No one is attacking Amazon for having AWS on Antitrust grounds anyhow. It certainly is a cash cow they use to corner other markets, but it by itself is not problematic.
- cameronbrown 7y agoWell, there's plenty of healthy competition between cloud providers. AWS doesn't have the stranglehold on the industry like they do in retail, where you have no choice but to be on Amazon.
- mc32 7y agoIf anything, their efforts in search and cloud compute delayed or muted the case for monopolistic behavior by others as they can point to MS and say, see, they are competing against us successfully, we’re not the big bad monopolists some claim us to be.
- Apocryphon 7y agoHow ironic that they once bailed out Apple to use as their own lightning rod.
- tzs 7y agoThey invested $150 million in non-voting stock from Apple, at a time when Apple had $1.2 billion in cash reserves. As part of that Microsoft agreed to support Office on Mac for five year, and Apple agreed to drop their long running lawsuit against Microsoft alleging Microsoft copies the look and feel of Windows. Apple's business was struggling a bit at the time, but with those cash reserves they were a long way from needing bailing out.
- tomnipotent 7y agoCan you provide even a single current example? Or just jumping on the MS-bashing bandwagon 'cause it's fun? Apple, Facebook, and Google all have current practices that are questionable. Pointing fingers are companies that have already paid their dues is just useless noise.
- duality 7y agoIs regulation really "one and done"? MS got fined (repeatedly) around 2000 so they're done with regulation? They at least have shady sales tactics.
- tomnipotent 7y agoTwenty years ago. Please try again. I hope you're constantly held accountable for things you did decades ago.
- duality 7y agoGoing to prison doesn't exempt you from the law from the rest of your life.
- tomnipotent 7y agoNo, but it cleans your slate of the crime you committed because you've paid your dues. We don't charge people - or businesses - twice with the same crime.