3 ms·
You have a very well formatted post with excellent footnotes, which makes me inclined to trust it. Yet the author of the piece, Nate Silver, is widely regarded
by nkurz 16y ago
You have a very well formatted post with excellent footnotes, which makes me inclined to trust it. Yet the author of the piece, Nate Silver, is widely regarded as a professional statistician (with a solid degree in economics) and likely has a strong understanding of these issues. I'm predisposed to trust Silver over an unknown source from the internet because of my prior experience with his writings and the respect which others accord him. Therefore, despite the plausibility of your criticism, I still side with Silver.
p.s. My silly self-referential post aside, I think that neither my assessment nor Silver's is an example of the conjunction fallacy.