2 ms·
15th century England had no ritual or requirements in order to lawfully murder another human being? 15th century England, which had had the beginnings of Engli
by SketchySeaBeast 7y ago
15th century England had no ritual or requirements in order to lawfully murder another human being? 15th century England, which had had the beginnings of English Common Law for 2 centuries, had no laws against murder? The Magna Carta wielding English had no laws against murder?
In the Magna Carta:
"39. No freemen shall be taken or imprisoned or disseised or exiled or in any way destroyed, nor will we go upon him nor send upon him, except by the lawful judgment of his peers or by the law of the land."
- sandworm101 7y agoSociety, not country. Among the landed aristocracy violence was expected. Sons were trained as warriors for the inevitable family conflicts. >> no laws against murder Murder is a crime, an unlawful killing. A law forbidding something already defined as a crime is circular. A great many killings, those in combat, were not illegal and therefore not murder. So while murder was illegal killing was not, at least not always. And at the highest levels those who won the war, those best at killing, decided who would be punished, if anyone. The legal definitions were beside the point.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoYou're describing lawful combat, which had rules. For instance - you'd never see a nobleman kill a noblewoman without recourse. I'm talking the taking of another human's life without reason or justification - just a wanton disregard for human life and no need to rationalize the death.
- tialaramex 7y agoAlthough to be fair not all Englishmen in the 15th century would be freemen. When Magna Carta was signed, there will have been a large number of villeins and other serfs. A serf is recognised in law as a person and so you can't _own_ them, indeed they can own other things. Villeins are serfs that come with land. Like you'll own a bunch of farm land, and there will be fifty people who you don't own, but they aren't allowed to leave without permission. They farm stuff, you feed them, it's... well it's not very nice, but it isn't chattel slavery, people would have voluntarily become villeins because it meant food security when famines were a possibility. Anyway, by the 15th century there are fewer villeins, it just doesn't make as much sense as a plague has wiped a bunch of people out, making labour very valuable - but until the 1500s there are at least some left in England. But I'm pretty sure that killing serfs was not considered OK. I dunno if they'd have executed you for it, and that period wasn't really into prisons, but I'm pretty sure they wouldn't have gone "OK, that seems fine, nothing to see".
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoOh yeah, the Magna Carta was certainly focused on the upper class (as the person I was responding to was as well), but it shows a respect for life and property - may that get muddied by class issues? I'm sure it did, but people they recognized as being full people (I'm simplifying the relationship a bit) were afforded the right to live.