5 ms·
I like to think of mental illness like myopia. Many people used to be blind, but then we figured out the technology, it got cheap, and now 60% of adults wear gl
by mensetmanusman 7y ago
I like to think of mental illness like myopia. Many people used to be blind, but then we figured out the technology, it got cheap, and now 60% of adults wear glasses.
As there is an incentive to classify mental illness for insurance, occupation, and drug development reasons, there is going to be 60% of people on ‘mental illness’ treatment, because we have an ‘ideal human’ (20/20 analogy) that we are trying to reproduce.
As the ideal changes (e.g. homosexuality was thought of in the past as non-ideal, so it was a mental illness, now these things have changed in many parts of the world, so those parts of the world do not classify it as such anymore.), the treatment options/norms change.
tl;dr, it is entirely possible due to biology that eventually ~60% of us will have some classification of mental illness that we will be treated for.
- stevewodil 7y agoThis is quite an interesting perspective, and as someone that has been struggling with depression lately I found this kind of comforting in a weird way. Thank you for sharing this!
- umvi 7y agoThis seems a little... sketchy. Who gets to define what the "ideal human" is? If the ideal can change, doesn't that make classifying mental illness completely subjective? If so, doesn't that mean you can essentially declassify your own mental illness if you can normalize it via political and social vectors?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 50656E6973 7y ago>Who gets to define what the "ideal human" is? Psychiatrists/the authors of the DSM. >If the ideal can change, doesn't that make classifying mental illness completely subjective? Yes, it is completely subjective: "psychiatric diagnosis still relies exclusively on fallible subjective judgments rather than objective biological tests" -Allen Frances, Chairman of DSM-IV https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allen_Frances https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allen_Frances
- graeme 7y agoPretty sure myopia rates increased quite a bit in the 20th and 21st centuries. Scientists now think myopia is heavily related to sunlight exposure in youth: don't get enough bright hours, get myopia. 3 is the recommended minimum for outdoors time.
- alexandercrohde 7y agoI've spent a few hours looking into myopia. You're correct that it's been increasing and is still increasing, it's increased so quickly genetics can't explain it, and the sunlight hypothesis is new to me. Some areas in Asia have >80% myopia rates. (As an ally myself, I also think it's worth pointing out that Gen-Z having a 7% LGBTQ rate theoretically could also have an environmental cause. There is evidence of a biological basis for transexualism.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Near-sightedness#Asia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Near-sightedness#Asia
- Qwertystop 7y agoPersonally I think the increase in LGBTQ people would most likely be caused by increasing public acceptance and/or awareness - if you're going to be ostracized by everyone you know it's a lot harder to come out, and if you think feeling however you do is bizarre/unprecedented/obscene you similarly won't tell people. Plenty of anecdotes out there of people who didn't think they were gay/bi/trans/etc because they didn't think of it as a thing-you-could-be; you see things like "oh, I thought everyone thought girls were hot" (or equivalent). As acceptance and awareness grow, the bar gets lower -- fifty years ago it'd take a lot of dysphoria to justify trying to transition; now it's still not simple but it's a lot easier, and so more people who are comparatively less dysphoric are willing to take that particular plunge, and more of them know it's a doable thing.
- devereaux 7y agoOne of my eyes has myopia. The other one is fine. Did I play out too much as a pirate with an eyepatch? Joke aside, the disease has many causes, and there is some genetic predisposition. It is too easy to blame it on the modern environment.
- anoncake 7y agoI don't think myopia is a good analogy. When it comes to vision, the target is well-defined. Better vision is, well, better. Myopia is unambiguously a defect and (AFAIK) has no advantages. Curing someone of myopia wouldn't change the person. Neither do glasses, they're an external tool -- not part of the organism. Mental illness is different. A person isn't their eyes but arguably, they are their mind. Treating a personality disorder, in particular, obviously has to change the patient's personality. It is also not necessarily just a defect. Sometimes it's a pattern of behaviors that is perfectly appropriate for certain situations -- but very bad in the current ones. Whereas bad vision is never good.