4 ms·
This is probably an unpopular opinion amongst liberals like myself, but I personally think the idea that the "average joe" is going to be able to change their l
by tombert 7y ago
This is probably an unpopular opinion amongst liberals like myself, but I personally think the idea that the "average joe" is going to be able to change their lifestyle and solve climate-change to be somewhat of a pipe-dream. If you want to live in an ecologically more-sustainable way (using renewable energy, becoming a vegetarian, avoiding disposables, etc), that's great! I honestly encourage that, and it's probably a good thing, I won't try and stop you.
However, I think it's unreasonable to expect everyone to do that on their own. For every person doing an ecologically responsible thing (taking trains instead of planes, taking public transit instead of driving, etc), there is just such a huge magnitude of people doing the "wrong" thing to cancel it out, largely because that (from a short-term-pragmatic-standpoint, the "wrong" thing is better) or at least cheaper. If you value your time at all, flying across the country is cheaper, meat is readibly available and inexpensive (and typically taste good), and driving to work is substantially easier than biking.
I don't know anything about ecology so I'll admit that I might regret writing this entire comment in a year, but it seems to me that the only way we're going to make a dent in climate change is to a) create technology that provides an experience that is competitive with the dirty version of something (electric cars could be a good example), or b) to start artificially taxing things that are really hurting the environment. If we started charging an extra dollar-per-gallon tax on gasoline, it would probably discourage people from driving as much, and put more economic incentive on point a).
I can commend someone not flying to conferences anymore, but I am afraid to say that I dont have the same self-discipline.
- magduf 7y agoIf you want people to make ecological choices, you have to do it at higher levels instead of expecting individuals to change their lifestyles. So instead of continuing to widen roads, we need to build more trains, and change municipal development processes so that cities are made denser. Instead of having short-hop air travel, we need to fund high-speed rail. And yes, taxing things to change consumption patterns is a big part of this. Slap a big tax on gasoline/diesel and jet fuel and use that to fund HSR, for instance.
- grayed-down 7y agoThen get yourself elected to a national level office and get to work. Usually an idealist's first set of budget or appropriation meetings is enough to cure them. It sure worked for me.
- jdietrich 7y agoThe average American produced 16.5 tonnes of CO2e in 2014. The average Briton produced 6.5 tonnes. British people do not live in medieval squalor, nor do they all live in bedsits in central London and travel everywhere by tube. The only thing stopping American politicians from vastly reducing CO2 emissions is the will of the electorate. The top-down political solution actually comes from the bottom-up - by persuading people to vote for candidates who support decarbonisation. You only have one president, but he was chosen for office by 62,979,636 voters. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_di...
- grayed-down 7y agoHow would America vastly reduce CO2 emissions to achieve parity with the UK? Who do we hurt first?
- magduf 7y agoWell we could start by not building in the suburbs any more, and instead building more densely (this is done with zoning regulations), and raising fuel taxes as well.
- grayed-down 7y agoUrban/Suburban infill development is a terrific idea. It's being accomplished at a far faster clip than a lot of people realize, but there could be better incentives at the federal level (US). Fuel taxes are pretty high already. Increasing them will hurt a lot of people very badly.
- moosey 7y agoIn this time where it appears that the vast majority of civilization is paying almost no attention to climate change, one of the best tools that a person has in their arsenal is to reduce their own pollution, because it aids in building the necessary political will to do _something_. If we don't, you know that those who politically oppose us will simply call us hypocrites: Russia doesn't use careful logic, and even though pointing out hypocrisy a logical fallacy, most leaders, both government and business, will continue to use it, because maintaining power always feels like the right way forward. Basically we have to practice conspicuous ethics because there will always be someone saying it's useless behind you, even people who understand that climate change is real. And even then, it might be a wash. We have to hope for a global "oh-shit" moment in the next few years if we are to have any hope of handling climate change. It doesn't mean that I won't be conspicuous and hope to help create like-minded individuals.
- cuillevel3 7y agoI agree, you can't (just) appeal to morality. You have to change the system (responsibly) to influence decision making. Otherwise it's just the prison dilemma game and tragedy of the commons.
- balthasar 7y agoNeoliberal capitalism offers no solution to mass waste or climate change.
- tombert 7y agoNot by itself, no. I think we can add stricter government regulations to help, however, especially if we actually enforced them.
- balthasar 7y agoThe ruling class would never allow it.
- tombert 7y agoThis is demonstrably untrue. Catalytic converters were protected somewhat by the "ruling class", now they're standard in every car. That's an example that took me about 1/10th of a second to think of, but there are lots of them. I'm hardly this big advocate for a capitalism, but your statements seem a bit reductionist.
- frankbreetz 7y ago>For every person doing an ecologically responsible thing (taking trains instead of planes, taking public transit instead of driving, etc), there is just such a huge magnitude of people doing the "wrong" thing to cancel it out, largely because that (from a short-term-pragmatic-standpoint, the "wrong" thing is better) or at least cheaper. If you value your time at all, flying across the country is cheaper, meat is readily available and inexpensive (and typically taste good), and driving to work is substantially easier than biking. It only takes a small percentage of the population to make a systematic change[0], I hope for humanity we are reaching a tipping point on this. People living their life in the correct way is spreading awareness and they are putting their money where their mouth is. These people and the youth climate strike may be our last chance. Also, the environment is the number one issue for the democratic party in the 2020 election. But, I do agree eventually these people making these changes will have to drive government agendas and the real mass changes will have to happen that way. [0]http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20190513-it-only-takes-35-of-people-to-change-the-world http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20190513-it-only-takes-35-of...
- tombert 7y agoI should backpedal a bit and reemphasize; please do not stop doing good things for the environment by any means. The more sustainably you can live your life, especially if you can demonstrate a way to do it fairly easily, the more of a proof-of-concept you become, which can help put pressures on governments. I mean, I don't own a car, am mostly vegetarian (I eat fish occasionally), and take public transit nearly everywhere, so it's not like I don't try and do my part (though I do fly a lot, so that probably cancels out all my savings). Part of the problem with writing comments like this is that I do think some of the the issues causing climate-change to become a problem are due to a specific political party, and HN typically gets a bit flag-heavy whenever you start getting into overt politics.
- kami8845 7y agoThe data from the article you provided talks about violent and non-violent protests and the numbers required for it. If 11,445,000 people were to storm the White House I imagine that would indeed have quite the effect. I don't see how it's related to not flying planes or not eating meat to effect climate change.