5 ms·
Murders and disappearances of Indigenous women called a 'Canadian genocide'
- undersuit 7y agoI'd like to bring attention to the size of this issue. It's not Indigenous women in Canada, it's all of America. https://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/mmiw/ https://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/mmiw/ https://www.daily-times.com/story/news/local/navajo-nation/2019/04/02/new-mexico-law-missing-murdered-indigenous-women-task-force/3345261002/ https://www.daily-times.com/story/news/local/navajo-nation/2... https://www.telesurenglish.net/news/Almost-500-Guatemalan-Women-Still-Missing-Despite-New-Law-20170417-0027.html https://www.telesurenglish.net/news/Almost-500-Guatemalan-Wo... https://www.sovereign-bodies.org/mmiw-database https://www.sovereign-bodies.org/mmiw-database
- vivekd 7y agoI could have topd them how to prevent more murdered or missing aborigional woman and it would have cost a lot less than $ 92 million 1. Take some of that 92 million to run a bus service along the highway of tears and similar areas where lots of female hitch hikers go missing- or even just not arrest private entities who dont have state permission from running their bis service. 2. Create acess points and resources for indigenous women who want to find work on cities. 3. Actually give native people their tribal land instead of doing this thing where government cotrols sale and use of the land and natives have "fake ownership" where they get to live there. Either that or just be honest and admit youre not giving them the land and compensate with money. 4. Make native governments actual governments that people might actually care enough to vote for rather than puppet governments that have to have every decision approved by the corrupt Indian Affairs branch of government. https://www.vice.com/en_ca/article/ava4kk/canadas-first-nations-reserves-have-a-faulty-system-of-government https://www.vice.com/en_ca/article/ava4kk/canadas-first-nati... You got that government of Canada? You want to stop the murser of Canadian indigenous women all you have to do is stop facilitaing their deaths and creating circumstances where their deaths are inevitable. You dont have to spend 92 million on beurocratic reports that go nowhere. What do we get for our 92 million $ report. We get crap like make native languages official languages like French. What does that mean - school kids learn every single native language on school like we do French? Every government agency has to have someone who speaks every one of the various native languages? The 92 million dollar report is fulled with quaint, unrealistic solutions that don't solve the problem. How is that going to stop these women from dying. What native communities need to do is stop playing ball declare war and start stockpiling munitions. They need to fight back violently against the opressive tyrannical structure that has led to so many deaths in their communities. Only then do we have any hope of change. Because until they start shooting our government is going to keep this ridiculous structure that keeps natives imprisoned
- sonnyblarney 7y ago"What native communities need to do is stop playing ball declare war and start stockpiling munitions. " The aboriginal women dying, are doing so at the hands of aboriginal men unfortunately. While historical social structures are obviously relevant, the $100M political show actually tried to move away form what the government already knows (i.e. intra familial violence) so as to somehow point the blame at external causes, which is shameful. We should have invested the $100M in practical programs to help communities move on. From Gov. Canada's own web site concerning victimization surveys [1] have a gander: "Research reveals that Aboriginal women experience dramatically higher rates of violent victimization than non-Aboriginal women do (Proulx and Perrault 2000; Hylton 2002; Brzozowski et al. 2006). Violence within the domestic context is the most pervasive form of victimization experienced by Aboriginal women. Nearly one-quarter (24%) of Aboriginal women in Canada reported having been assaulted by a current or former spouse, compared to 7% of non-Aboriginal women (Brzozowski et al. 2006). Results from other studies suggest that this figure may be as high as 90% in some Aboriginal communities (Ontario Native Women’s Association 2007). The literature shows that Aboriginal women consistently report a rate of partner violence much higher than their non-Aboriginal counterparts, even after controlling for relevant social variables. For instance, while living common law is associated with a 13 percent greater risk of victimization for non-Aboriginal women, the associated risk for Aboriginal women is 217 percent higher (Brownridge 2008). Sexual assault against women is particularly prevalent in Northern Canada where there is a much higher proportion of Aboriginal people in each of the territories than in the provinces. In 2002, the rate of sexual assault in Nunavut was 96.1 for every 10,000 people compared to the overall rate in Canada of 7.8 in every 10,000 people (Levan 2001). Aboriginal women have also been found to be greatly over-represented as sex trade workers compared to non-Aboriginal women (Oxman-Martinez et al. 2005; Royal Canadian Mounted Police 2006). In one study of the Vancouver sex trade, 52 of 101 women interviewed were Aboriginal (Farley et al. 2005). The overwhelming majority of these women reported both a history of childhood sexual abuse by multiple perpetrators and a history of rape and other assaults while working as prostitutes." [1] https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/cj-jp/victim/rd3-rr3/p3.html https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/cj-jp/victim/rd3-rr3/p3....
- vivekd 7y ago
- jbob2000 7y agoI’m not understanding why it’s a genocide. It’s not one entity performing these killings and it’s not organized; lots of indigenous women are just in shitty situations, that doesn’t make it a genocide. We’re talking about ~100 deaths a year here, that’s the equivalent of gang violence in some run down American cities and we don’t call that a genocide.
- sonnyblarney 7y ago"I’m not understanding why it’s a genocide" The term is entirely politicized unfortunately. It's a word used to put the 'blame' so to speak on external entities, effectively the Canadian government, historically. Given that the vast majority of the violence is perpetuated within the community itself, and the nature of the crimes ... of course it doesn't remotely fit the term 'genocide'. Obviously historical factors are relevant, but the situation is being weaponized for political reasons. Even call out the governments officials maligned use of the term will get you in trouble, as the previous governments MP for Aboriginal affairs faced pillorying after he did the same, literally today. The real tragedy is that $100M can go a long way to helping communities move forward and address root causes, as opposed to being used in international political fights over words and ideology.
- jbob2000 7y agoYeah, I feared it was a politicized term. I guess my real thought here is, what is the end goal? So you call it a genocide and give a lump sum of money to the indigenous populations. Now what? The government already admits guilt time and time again for the indigenous problems. We already fund and subsidize their way of life. What else do they want? How many more ways do they want us to skin this cat?
- sonnyblarney 7y agoThere is no 'end goal' because nobody is in charge. It's a various group of political entities. Many people of the current political regime probably would not agree with the term 'genocide' but they're not going to speak out against it for fear of retribution. My wild guess is that whoever's in charge wants to use the word to make a point. I'll bet there was pushback from certain quarters, but they got their way. Certainly there would have been many pushing for the use of the term. The outcome will be totally ambiguous - it will provide political cover for more spending on reserves, but it doesn't have to mean anything specific. As a Canadian, I'll bet that the vast majority of Canadians are perfectly fine with big investment on reserves, so long as it's fruitful. The hockey programs seem to be working well in Quebec for example, with some hiccups. But sending very expensive gear up to Iqaluit in perpetuity may not bode very well. That's a tricky one. There are remote aboriginal communities a zillion miles from anywhere - no roads - nothing. There is no economic activity. That's a tough problem to solve. But there are low hanging fruit we could work on.
- duxup 7y agoGenocide is supposed to mean something a bit different than the terrible things that this article describes. I really object to its usage here, the situation is terrible but genocide is something else.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe actual report: https://www.mmiwg-ffada.ca/final-report/ https://www.mmiwg-ffada.ca/final-report/
- a0-prw 7y agoWho does the raping and killing ? Is there any reliable data on that ? If it is predominantly people of European descent I will buy "genocide", otherwise, it's "just" another indigenous culture falling apart from being exposed to European culture. Oh, sorry ... we can't look at the "race" of the perpetrators, because that would be racial profiling.