5 ms·
I write this as someone who considers himself a liberal in the American political sense. As I see it, there is a serious tension in the way we think about sexua
by throwaway-3891 7y ago
I write this as someone who considers himself a liberal in the American political sense. As I see it, there is a serious tension in the way we think about sexual assault. We assert two things: 1. women very rarely make false claims of sexual assault, so we should believe their claims, and 2. higher rates of criminal convictions and incarceration among black people are largely explained by institutional racism, rather than truly higher criminality among black people. These things conflict in the apparent over-representation of black (and minority in general) students in campus sexual assault accusations [1].
Hard numbers don't seem very common here, but that article contains qualitative testimony: "In 2015, in The New Yorker, Jeannie Suk Gersen, a Harvard Law School professor, wrote that in general, the administrators and faculty members she’d spoken with who 'routinely work on sexual-misconduct cases' said that 'most of the complaints they see are against minorities.'"
That article offers also one pretty shocking statistic: "In the 2013–14 academic year, 4.2 percent of Colgate’s students were black. According to the university’s records, in that year black male students were accused of 50 percent of the sexual violations reported to the university, and they made up 40 percent of the students formally adjudicated. During the three academic years from 2012–13 to 2014–15, black students were accused of 25 percent of the sexual misconduct reported to the university, and made up 21 percent of the students referred for formal hearings."
As a result, I struggle to reconcile points 1 and 2 above. My best guess -- and it's similar to what that article hypothesizes -- is that encounters that already exist in some grey area of drunkenness and consent are more likely to be viewed as assault when the man is "other", i.e. black or minority. But this seems awful.
[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/09/the-question-of-race-in-campus-sexual-assault-cases/539361/ https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/09/the-qu...
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>encounters that already exist in some grey area of drunkenness and consent are more likely to be viewed as assault when the man is "other", i.e. black or minority. But this seems awful. I agree with you but I'd like like to point out that this is just saying "it's not creepy when attractive people do it" but adding another couple dimensions (race and similiar) to "attractive" which is, as you said, awful. I can't think of any circumstances in which a double standard like that, especially one predicated on circumstances that are in large part outside one's control (hitting the gym won't make you 6'4", clearly being a star athlete didn't help this guy) is acceptable.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoFWIW, my alma mater actually had a Title IX trial where one of the university employees who voted to expel a student said (paraphrasing slightly) "she's too pretty and smart for him, how could it have been consensual?".
- BurningFrog 7y ago> 1. women very rarely make false claims of sexual assault, so we should believe their claims This is a big fundamental mistake. Women are just as capable as men of lying. The principle of "innocent until proven guilty" was established over centuries of very hard won experience of why this imperfect principle works better than all the others that have been tried. How sad that the left of 2019 has forgotten this history and now needs to relearn it.
- SmokeGS 7y agoPoliticizing domestic/civil legal issues is historically a failure and has huge blowback.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoObviously the reason that #1 exists is because the systems meant to help victims of crime treated sexual assault victims as liars and people somehow deserving of their victimization, hence an overreaction. However regarding statement Women are just as capable of lying as men, I suppose this is true but I also wonder if there aren't particular crimes that have different levels of lying about than others, and different types of lies. For example a companies office gets burglarized, an expensive ring was in the office but was not stolen. I would expect this to be a temptation to lie and say it was stolen, because it gives a benefit and who does it hurt, the insurance company whom everyone hates or the burglars who you would like to hurt at the moment. The question to me is what is the rate of lying that people would want to do about about sexual assault. My gut feeling is not that much, but of course it's a charged subject so I bet nobody is really researching it and able to tell us what the rate actually is. on edit: clarifying that the word overreaction is used under the supposition that the application of #1 if it results in a false statement being believed then that is an 'overreaction'
- BurningFrog 7y agoHow accusations are handled of course also influence the rate of lying. If an accusation is investigated thoroughly with evidence examined and carefully weighed, there are serious costs to making a false accusation (also, unfortunately to a truthful one). If an accusation is just accepted at face value and the accused is automatically shipped away to whatever punishment is mandated, making a false accusation is much more attractive. So the idea that "since women never lie about rape we can stop investigating rape accusations" is a bit like the anti-vax idea that "since measles is rare, vaccinating is pointless".
- austhrow743 7y agoOne aspect of that grey area is when persistence becomes sexual assault /rape. Potentially there's a cultural aspect at play where more aggressively pursuing women is more common /expected in other ethnic groups.
- whack 7y agoYou raise an interesting point, but I don't think making any sort of generalization is the answer here. There are good and bad people of every gender/race. Hence why every incident needs to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. With regard to the original article, it appears to be a singularly bad ruling on MSU's part. The official guideline given was to "adopt a looser standard of guilt known as more likely than not." Reading through the case details, all the evidence points towards Mumphery being innocent - I certainly don't think it meets the "more likely than not" standard. If anything deserves critique here, it is MSU's handling of this case, not the broader guideline recommended by the Education Department.
- JohnBooty 7y agoFeels like we're on a pendulum. For most of human history most rapes went utterly unpunished unless there were signs of a physical struggle, since it's usually utterly impossible to prove what happened in a bedroom between two people. Now we're swinging the other way in some cases and ruining peoples' lives based on a mere statement from another person. In some cases this delivers justice where there wouldn't have been any in previous times. In other cases an innocent person gets their life ruined.
- solidsnack9000 7y agoFor most of human history most rapes went utterly unpunished unless there were signs of a physical struggle, since it's usually utterly impossible to prove what happened in a bedroom between two people. Human history is very long and we know very little about most of it. Consider that the bedroom as a place for two people is a fairly recent development: https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/communal-sleeping-history-sharing-bed https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/communal-sleeping-hist... Claims like the above suggest that fifty thousand years of sexual assault is finally being brought to an end by 1900s social movements. It's the narrative that emboldened people to interpret Title IX so broadly in the first place, but it's not possible to support it.
- JohnBooty 7y agoHuman history is very long and we know very little about most of it. Yes. I said that. We don't know how many rapes or other crimes occurred. Because we know little about them. Because they were generally not reported nor recorded. There's very little doubt they were happening though, yes? Claims like the above suggest that fifty thousand years of sexual assault is finally being brought to an end by 1900s social movements. No, that's not being suggested here. That is a strawman you just presented.
- solidsnack9000 7y agoHow do we know that rapes went unpunished or were not reported, for most of human history? One sure sign would be adaptations in women that are clearly for resisting or mitigating rape (like mallard ducks have) but there don't seem to be any such adaptations.