5 ms·
I wonder who asked the Tiananmen question to the minister from the audience in Singapore. That guy has some backbone, I like it. They should be challenged on th
by dmix 7y ago
I wonder who asked the Tiananmen question to the minister from the audience in Singapore. That guy has some backbone, I like it. They should be challenged on the topic of their political repression more. And not just the typical American channels which Beijing finds easy to dismiss as western propaganda.
It's a pretty simple equation. Why would any state have to spend so much explicit effort on making no one mention it, if there was nothing really wrong with it?
It will forever be the giant elephant in the room, regardless of how big and successful China makes itself. Few westerners really understanding how completely thorough and effective it was. The near universal obedience seen among the population would seem very foreign to most people in the west. Which is in itself an interesting cultural question.
- Barrin92 7y ago>I wonder who asked the Tiananmen question to the minister from the audience in Singapore. That guy has some backbone, I like it. They should be challenged on the topic of their political repression more. And not just the typical American channels which Beijing finds easy to dismiss as western propaganda. In contrast to the man in the audience Singapore was one of the first countries to normalise relationships with China, and in his biography From third world to First, Lee Kuan Yew actually seems somewhat supportive of it because he contrasts China's handling of the situation with the collapse of the Soviet Union. And realistically a country like Singapore is always going to be best positioned by keeping its relationships to opposing forces like the USA and China ambiguous. Committing to one side will draw a reaction from the other, and for smaller countries that's devastating. The space for most freedom and autonomy for a country like Singapore is right in the middle, in a competition between two large nations, choosing sides is a bad move.
- state-sponsored 7y agoNot to worry, 30 years is still on the young side of a cover up. At or around the 50 year mark, you'll start to see things loosen up (if 50 year-olds did the deeds, 50 years later they'd be 100), as most of the adults clenching their death grip on the yoke of popular discussion will start dying off. Once no one with skin in the game remains alive to defend the bad decisions, less effort will be invested in denial. Kind of like the way bad science works. It takes a while for a graduating class to grow into their credentials and take a giant shit on the more hated principles that their predeccesors tortured them with. That is, of course, unless blood relatives of the ones with blood on their hands are still floating around throughout the power structurers. In authoritarian regimes, personnel churn is slower, and dynastic succession can prolong even craptacular totalitarianism like Juche. With a singular leader, deposing the face of authority can unravel a movement like Baathism, with Saddam Hussein, but you have to take out the Udays and the Qusays too. China is bigger though, and power is more distributed and has been handed off to descendents, so it's more durable than any simple dictatorship. A process of changing the guard will have to play out across several terms until the retired personnel actually die, and grandma and grandpa's "legacies" are looked back on with bored indifference.
- eternalban 7y agoThe question and answer are likely planned. CCP wanted that answer out. It will reach its intended audience: upcoming generation of party leadership; young and affluent non-CCP Chinese; nationalist Chinese; law and order Chinese. I think that substantial and important subset will be satisfied with the answer. The rest are busy chasing virtual butterflies glued to their "smart assistant" (a feature, not a bug) just like their counterparts over here. And the fact of its being discussed rather diminishes that propaganda card. > It's a pretty simple equation. Why would any state have to spend so much explicit effort on making no one mention it, if there was nothing really wrong with it? > elephant in the room You mean like two modern skyscraper crumbling into dust in a handful of seconds which one must not mention in respectable society unless repeating the "party line"? Like those two elephants? Should we discuss the official fact finding efforts for additional black humor, and then revisit the "universal obedience" phenomena? > The near universal obedience seen among the population would seem very foreign to most people in the west. Which is in itself an interesting cultural question. Laughable and racist. (See "conspiracy theory" for disambiguation.)
- GhostVII 7y ago> You mean like two modern skyscraper crumbling into dust in a handful of seconds which one must not mention in respectable society unless repeating the "party line"? Are you suggesting that the US government suppresses discussion of 9/11, similar to China and Tiananmen? That's a strange opinion, I've heard lots of discussion about 9/11, there is even a museum about it.
- cyphar 7y ago> And not just the typical American channels which Beijing finds easy to dismiss as western propaganda. [...] The near universal obedience seen among the population would seem very foreign to most people in the west. You say that, but mainstream western media is very rarely really critical of the government and especially the core policies of the government (which are the same regardless of whose government it happens to be). Yeah, mainstream media will take some potshots (which is an improvement over China) but very rarely will there be an actual critique of establishment politics. Almost no mainstream media was critical of the Iraq war and the lie that Saddam had WMDs. No mainstream media is critical of the currently 5 illegal wars (not approved by Congress thus being illegal under the US constitution, nor an act of defense thus being illegal under the Nuremberg Convention) being waged by the US. No mainstream media was critical of the Syrian gas attack (used as justification to bomb Syria with America's "majestic" weapons) which may have been false, given the recent leak of an internal OPCW document detailing evidence that the gas canisters could not have been dropped from a helicopter and the attempts to cover it up[1] -- which was so ignored by mainstream media that I can't even find an article mentioning it. No mainstream media is critical of US interventionism nor modern US imperialism. No mainstream media is critical of the current narrative being pushed by the government about Venezuela or Iran. And that's just the war narrative! [1]: https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/douma-syria-opcw-chemical-weapons-chlorine-gas-video-conspiracy-theory-russia-a8927116.html https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/douma-syria-opcw-chemic...
- khuey 7y agoI wouldn't take Robert Fisk at face value here without some detailed citations of primary sources after he signed onto the "jet fuel can't melt steel beams" 9/11 conspiracy theory.
- cyphar 7y agoAs I mentioned above -- I don't like that the only article I could find of any repute which mentioned the leaked OPCW report was the Independent (the other option was InfoWars). And yes, about half of the article does appear to be at least slightly bullshit. But the leaked report was so ignored by mainstream media there isn't even a mention of it in an opinion piece in more reputable papers like the Guardian. Aaron Mate did a piece on this[1], who is definitely a more reputable journalist (though not mainstream). I also just found that (of all people) Tucker Carlson mentioned this on his show[2]. Then again, I have many other issues with Tucker Carlson. [1]: https://thegrayzone.com/2019/05/25/opcw-syria-gas-attack-staged-theodore-postol/ https://thegrayzone.com/2019/05/25/opcw-syria-gas-attack-sta... [2]: https://www.activistpost.com/2019/05/were-being-played-tucker-carlson-features-leaked-syria-chemical-attack-memo.html https://www.activistpost.com/2019/05/were-being-played-tucke...