3 ms·
Zuckerberg already said what will kill Facebook, but he didn't phrase it as such: verticals. There are several social aspects of our lives that are very poorl
by malandrew 16y ago
Zuckerberg already said what will kill Facebook, but he didn't phrase it as such:
verticals.
There are several social aspects of our lives that are very poorly served by Facebook and that's where verticals will come in.
Verticals won't necessarily kill Facebook, but they have the potential to chip away at the centralization of data inside of the Facebook social graph itself.
Under this scenario Facebook would still act as an aggregator, but then again the barrier to entry for competing aggregators of social network verticals would fall substantially and allow innovation and specialization.
I know of at least one stealth startup working on such a vertical, but I can't mention who just quite yet. From the ideas I've heard, the potential is definitely there in the idea to corner one aspect of a users life that Facebook couldn't possibly match due to the high level of abstraction FB needs to maintain as a generic social networking site.
I think verticals could also erode Google as well. Quora is going after one aspect of knowledge. Wikipedia as well.
If I were to create a search engine today, I'd go after one vertical. For example, a search engine focused entirely on helping you find code would be immensely valuable. Sites like Github and Freshmeat have search, but the search isn't specialized to add any value over what Google already offers. In fact, in many cases sites with specialized knowledge about one vertical choose to use Google's search for its own site instead of building a new search from scratch that better serves the need of that vertical.
Examples of verticals where I see value in creating a specialized social network or search engine:
-- Nightlife
-- Code/Programming
-- Educational resources.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- bad_user 16y agoProblem with verticals is that people lose interest fast. Nightlife? Sure, but once you have a favorite club or 2 where you hang out with friends regularly, you don't need a website to tell where to go anymore. Educational resources? You mean like lots of scanned books that you can search? What will make Google irrelevant is a better search engine: just the other day I remembered a piece of article I first read a couple of years ago. It's somewhere out there but I can't find it because of all the junk and all I remember are a couple of words and a number. In 2002 when I first used Google's search, I had been using Altavista previously. The results from Google were so good compared to Altavista that it wasn't even funny. If the same would happen today, Google would be in big trouble. Also Facebook is already irrelevant to me. I log in from time to time, responding to a friendship request, but these days I only view it as a tool with which I could spam my acquaintances in case I need it :)
- jdp23 16y ago> Problem with verticals is that people lose interest fast. That's a pretty funny comment here on HN -- a vertical
- malandrew 16y agoTo drive the point further. This is a vertical that has a LOT of unexplored potential. The truth is that people spend most of their time in verticals. Statistics focus on the aggregate amount of time the average American spends on Facebook, 7 hours per month. But the truth is that what is most interesting is the 20-40 hours a month someone spends on the verticals that matter most to them. For us it's nerd/tech stuff, so we hang out here for hours on end. The number of hours I spend on here blows the amount of time I spend on Facebook away. The same goes for Quora. For companies that make money from advertising, the highest click-through-rates come from the most engaged audiences and highly targeted advertising. The truth is that no one has perfected many verticals. StackOverflow is one of the the best examples of startups that have done an excellent job in a vertical, but there is still much more potential there too. Regarding search verticals, the search algorithms for code are going to look really really different when compared to those for natural language that Google is after. Imagine a code search engine where I can save preferences for the languages I want to search in. This engine then indexes lots of different places like Github, Gitorious, Freshmeat, SourceForge, etc. If you are part of the community that cares about code, you all of a sudden stop going to Google as the default for all code searches. Of course, Google could then become a portal to your search, but at that point the the barriers to entry for other companies to aggregate vertical search engines becomes much lower and Google's dominance is no longer guaranteed.
- bad_user 16y agohttp://www.google.com/codesearch http://www.google.com/codesearch