4 ms·
So... this is a bad policy, but let's not hyperbolize. The fourth amendment is still a thing, and it protects non-citizens and citizens alike. The demand here
by ajross 7y ago
So... this is a bad policy, but let's not hyperbolize.
The fourth amendment is still a thing, and it protects non-citizens and citizens alike.
The demand here isn't for your social media history, it's for your account IDs. If they want your (non-public) posts, they still have to get a warrant from a judge and show cause, just like they do now.
The feature they're demanding is to know who you are, so they know where to target that warrant request. And that's arguably bad, and a slippery slope.
BUT IT IS ABSOLUTELY NOT LIKE THE PRC'S SOCIAL CREDIT SYSTEM. Stop it.
- astazangasta 7y agoHyperbole is politically useful when you are sliding down a slippery slope. It anticipates a worse future, which is a useful brake for myopic people in the present who can't see what we are sliding into.
- ajross 7y agoMaybe so, but traditionally HN has been not very accomodating of shameless spin like that. If you want to make the case for that slope and how policy will evolve, then make it. But spinning "who are you on facebook" into "we'll track everything you do online" is just wrong.
- sverige 7y agoUnless we're talking about FAANG, in which case it is "providing the best possible online experience."
- StavrosK 7y ago> The fourth amendment is still a thing, and it protects non-citizens and citizens alike. Even in airports? > BUT IT IS ABSOLUTELY NOT LIKE THE PRC'S SOCIAL CREDIT SYSTEM. Stop it. Agreed, not yet.
- 50656E6973 7y agoThe fourth amendment is not "a thing" if you're anywhere near (within 100 miles) of the border. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception
- ajross 7y agoFacebook's datacenters aren't on the border though, so I don't see how that's relevant. That's a bad policy, but it hinges on the fact that people entering the country are right at the edge of the "jurisdiction" requirement of the equal protection clause. Look, I get that people are angry about everything in the civil liberties space, but not every policy is the end of the world. Argue about specifics, not good guys & bad guys.
- gruez 7y agoRead the article again. >it was held that the Border Patrol's routine stopping of a vehicle at a permanent checkpoint located on a major highway away from the Mexican border for brief questioning of the vehicle's occupants is consistent with the Fourth Amendment >However, searches of automobiles without a warrant by roving patrols have been deemed unconstitutional Yes, the 100mile exception exists. No, you don't lose all 4th amendment rights.
- 50656E6973 7y agoRead the fourth amendment again. What practical protection does it provide if the requirement for a warrant/probable cause are deemed null and void? Claiming that is "consistent with the Fourth Amendment" is just mental gymnastics, like saying a corporation is a literal person.
- gruez 7y ago>What practical protection does it provide if the requirement for a warrant/probable cause are deemed null and void? I'm not defending the 100 mile exception. I'm only clarifying that the extent of the infringement (as far as courts have ruled) is limited to permanent checkpoints. In the context of the parent comments however, I don't think the 4th amendment is relevant. The demand is for your account identifiers. Unless you have it written down on a piece of paper or an unecrypted device, it's the 5th amendment protecting you. Should you give them your account identifiers, it's going to be a stretch for them to use the border search exception to compel facebook (or any other service) to give up their records on you.
- sandwall 7y agoThis is an important distinction. By conflating the two systems, it makes the severe case (PRC) closer to a normalized method (US Policy; same as corporate HR). It's all a slippery slope.
- w0utert 7y ago>> The demand here isn't for your social media history, it's for your account IDs. If they want your (non-public) posts, they still have to get a warrant from a judge and show cause, just like they do now. So what does this mean for people who want to publish their thoughts under a pseudonym? Or people who (like me) don’t have any meaningful social media presence (no Facebook, for example). Does that make them suspect, liable for more elaborate screening, easier to deny them access, etc? How far back do you have to supply your details? What if I forget to mention some account I used 10 years ago, can that be seen as failure to comply, and can it be held against me? I can see many other ways something like this could be abused to harass innocent people. In that sense, I can see where the comparison with the social credit system is coming from.
- dontbenebby 7y agoOh no worries, they'll just demand to see the contents of your password manager to see if you missed any accounts :/
- dontbenebby 7y ago> The fourth amendment is still a thing, and it protects non-citizens and citizens alike. That's not entirely correct, despite your emphatic all caps assertions. Under under Section 702 of the FISA Amendments Act of 2008[1], they can wait for a non-US person to depart the US, then use the full powers of the NSA to access the harvested communications under the username(s) collected at the border. The level of "cause" needed for FISA warrant is very thin, and only 0.3% of FISA warrants are rejected[3]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FISA_Amendments_Act_of_2008 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FISA_Amendments_Act_of_2008 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program) [3] https://www.motherjones.com/crime-justice/2013/06/fisa-court-nsa-spying-opinion-reject-request/ https://www.motherjones.com/crime-justice/2013/06/fisa-court...
- ajross 7y agoSo first, FISA warrants aren't remotely relevant to the policy at hand of wanting routine social media identifiers. Second: FISA is one court, the government can't commit mass surveillance along the lines of a social credit system using FISA warrants even if it wanted to. You literally think those three (I think it's three) judges are going to pen hundreds of millions of signatures on physical pieces of paper? Once again, you and the other aggrieved posters in this subthread want to turn this particular issue into a proxy for warrantless surveillance, or border searches, or immigration abuses. And it's not. It's a requirement to get your facebook ID. Not every policy is the end of the world, and if you want the uninformed masses to take your (and my!) civil liberties worries seriously, you need to present arguments that make sense and aren't irrelevant digressions.
- salawat 7y agoSo, you've viewed the FISA warranting process? You can say for sure that their process exists as one sheet per person/username? These documents are not available for public audit, so I find the faith you demonstrate to be questionable. You know for a fact that there is no concentrated effort to slurp up as much information as possible to provide a political/intelligence bargaining chip with other state's intelligence services? You are right about one thing ; it isn't as bad as the PRC's social credit system: yet. However, it is there as a foundation for one, and even what we have was considered unprecedented and the stuff of crackpots before evidence of the existence of these types of systems was made bare before all by Snowden. Also, the 4th Amendment you insist provides so much protection? It doesn't apply under current case law. As soon as you share your information with a third party, 4th Amendment stops applying as there is no expectation of privacy; except in the few and far between carveouts of medical records or legal communique with an attorney. I don't personally buy that reasoning (Third Party Doctrine) but the courts do; act accordingly.
- ridaj 7y ago> The fourth amendment is still a thing, and it protects non-citizens and citizens alike. This sounds like someone who has never lived in the US as a visa holder. If you are living in the US on a visa or even on a green card, CBP agents have a shocking amount of discretion to detain. There are many other areas of the immigration system where the standard of due process is significantly different from what many Americans think their country stands for, but regarding the Fourth Amendment specifically: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception
- ajross 7y ago> If you are living in the US on a visa or even on a green card, CBP agents have a shocking amount of discretion to detain. My comment you replied to wasn't about ability to detain or the definitions of "probable cause" in immigration law, it was about the specific policy at issue which is demanding social media IDs so they can issue a warrant to facebook or whoever. And specifically that it was being likened to a surveillance program, when it clearly is not. All I'm saying is that if you want people to take your anger seriously (and I do! I'm on your side here!) you need to argue specifics and not just mash vote buttons based on your tribal affiliation. This policy is not just like China's social credit system. There are other policies that are bad. Those aren't arguments against that point.
- leetrout 7y ago> BUT IT IS ABSOLUTELY NOT LIKE THE PRC'S SOCIAL CREDIT SYSTEM. Stop it. Agree. But it is worth comparing because, while we do not live in a country that has extreme government over-reach, we are (and have been) headed down that path. You said "know who you are, so they know where to target that warrant request" which is, to me, in-line with the ideas of the social credit system. The idea that some group, some where, is collecting this information to use against someone or someones. To think they aren't / won't is naive. If it doesn't turn toward citizens then I'm happy to be wrong and admit it. We'll see... It's like a version of systematic desensitization where we continue to normalize giving up vast amounts of personal information on our own (to sites like Facebook) and asking tourists to point government agencies to that trove of information. I did not intend to hyperbolize nor conflate as another person said. I said this "may or may not be as bad" and it will depend entirely on what is done with the information and how much it's use "expands" (or doesn't). When I asked in school in the late 90's "how do we know the CIA doesn't just spy on us" the answer was "there are laws that prevent it". Now we know how that really works (or at least some of it) so I believe I'm entitled to my skepticism (and you're entitled to disagree).