3 ms·
I apologise in advance that this comment has nothing to do with the posted article, and is instead to do with the use of HN. After dang's comment on the latest
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
I apologise in advance that this comment has nothing to do with the posted
article, and is instead to do with the use of HN.
After dang's comment on the latest Assange thread to make the first page on
HN, I am trying to decide whether the posted article is one that stimulates
intellectual curiosity, or indignation and repetition.
I think the answer is - probably the latter. We're not likely to learn much
new knowledge from it and it's more likely to generate forceful arguments than
productive conversation.
Are postings like this welcome on HN or merely tolerated? I assumed, because
politically controversial posts frequently make it to the first page, that
they are acceptable and welcome. I am not so sure anymore.
I believe that an active mind is a politically engaged mind - but perhaps HN
is just not the right place for political conversation. I enjoy the civility
and dignity of the best threads on HN- and I have to admit that the majority
of them are not political. It's hard to have a level-headed, sober discussion
on political matters, when everyone who has political views tends to have
_strong_ political views (I sure do).
So I don't know. Maybe posting stuff like this on HN is not such a good idea
after all?
(With apologies to jerry2 who posted this article)
- fzeroracer 7y agoI'm more concerned that conspiratorial content and clickbait bullshit is becoming king on HN. This site and the general writing/editorial style fires off massive warning sirens and when I tried to look up the site further, most of the links that followed were similar conspiracy sites. Now don't get me wrong, this is separate from the issue of privacy and ensuring that the government doesn't overstep its bounds. We shouldn't be lured in by people using that as a wedge to spread FUD. Just read the comments on the article by the same writer to understand why.
- norswap 7y agoI'm genuinely curious: do you believe this post in particular to be controversial? I can't picture many people (I can picture some) who would think be in favor of what is described here.
- grenoire 7y agoWith any sentence that contains a "can't think of people who X" structure, you should realise that people you know and talk to are people who think like you. Exceptions don't break the rule, as always – if you do make a statement like that think first if your sample is representative of the population.
- Waterluvian 7y agoI think a simple rule is this: if the topic has to do with the balance of liberty and security, it's going to be controversial. But not necessarily because there's true dissenters in the simplified binary "you're with us or against us" way. But because it's a topic with no objectively right choice. Liberty is genuinely important. Security is too. Society and Government is largely about the balance of those two.
- dustfinger 7y agoThe issue is not about whether people "favor" the opion of the author or not, it is about whether the article meets the HN guidelines [1]. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoYes, I do. I think the fact that there is a very strong opinion for or against a political opinion makes it controversial, by definition. In effect, it means that any discussion on the subject is going to be charged and unbalanced. The more people are on one side of the debate, the more so. This is perhaps why articles on, say, vaccine denialism or climate denialism and other strongly politicised subjects like that are not well received on HN. On the one hand there are very strong views around them, on the other hand it's very clear what those views are and where they come from after years of these "debates" raging online and there's really nothing to see there anymore. Scientific controversy of course is another matter. That comes down to robust debate between experts from which everyone has a lot to learn. That sort of article is also commonly flagged on HN, which I think is unfortunate. Anyway, I've contributed plenty of politically controversial articles myself in the past, and contributed to such discussions. Maybe I was wrong to do that. I don't know if there is a place on the internet where I would feel more comfortable than on HN to have such discussions- but maybe HN is still, just, not the right place for them. Edit: maybe, if we keep having more and more of those conversations on HN it will stop being the place where I feel comfortable having them.
- dustfinger 7y agoI agree. If an article doesn't meet the guidelines [1], then please don't upvote it. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- iliketosleep 7y agoThe topic of the article is interesting, as it highlights a particular trend in technology and raises a lot of stimulating questions. But upon reading the article itself, I find that it's very political in nature and uses emotive kind of speech. It provides very little actual information beyond the title. Personally, I think the article is a waste of time and I'm actually shocked that it received so many upvotes.
- robbyt 7y agoNot everyone has the luxury to ignore news and politics. Sometimes these events touch our lives in ways that a new release of the Rust compiler could never. (Not to pick on Rust, I love the language, but just an example) I agree this site should not turn into Reddit, or Digg. What keeps HN great is the highly technical discussion around these topics. On mainstream articles like this I often skip reading the article, and go right to the HN comments to learn real info about the topic. We have a community of some extremely smart people, let's not filter the articles posted, but instead harbor the intellectual conversation around the articles, because I think that's the real value of this site.
- acct1771 7y agoI agree with this, and will add: Not everyone will see every thread on a topic. Some may only see a TSA thread on HN once a month or quarter, if they're a light user. The repetition is indicative of the community's feeling a topic is important. And that's what people come here for. To see what this community thinks is important.
- keiru 7y agoI don't like it, and maybe HN is not best suited, but it is relevant. Sharing such news is the only way of taking the pulse of how authorities perceive technology. Police using AI and visual recognition, investigations of social media accounts, drones starting to be used in cities. The only reason this feels like "repetition" is because we don't seem to be able to do anything about it, but discuss it as it unravels.