6 ms·
I'm not a huge fan of "only the government gets weapons". It's technologies like this that are bothersome because of both 2nd and 4th amendment reasons.
by exabrial 7y ago
I'm not a huge fan of "only the government gets weapons". It's technologies like this that are bothersome because of both 2nd and 4th amendment reasons.
- late2part 7y agoWhy aren’t you willing to give up liberties for temporary safety, said every dictator ever...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- llukas 7y agoProblem is that government can always buy bigger weapons. Militarization of police in USA is good example. They will always outgun you.
- armenarmen 7y agoYeah, but illiterate shepherds with decades outdated weapons have held off the US in afghan for however many years now
- ben_w 7y agoThe USA won that war — it’s the peace which they’re struggling with, and that’s a very different thing. Doubly so when you’re trying to install a friendly democratic government and the only reason your troops are still there is to support that new government — what would have happened (politically) if the French had kept troops in the USA after the war of independence? Police and soldiers (should) have different goals and tools.
- wongarsu 7y agoIt's semantics, but I don't think "there are people actively attacking our military, and we are struggling with peace" really counts as "winning the war". But I agree that military is probably not the most effective way to achieve progress at this stage.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Asooka 7y agoThey may outgun a single person but they won't outgun a large scale uprising. You're also assuming the police and military will always obey orders, which hasn't always been the case, especially when government goes dictatorial. We haven't (thank god) had a situation in the USA where actually shooting at law enforcement is a good idea. That is, where you're literally at war with the government and trying to replace it with another one, which will in turn recognise your actions as not against the law. On the other hand, things like home invasions happen daily.
- SturgeonsLaw 7y agoCorrect, and they also have a multitude of soft power ways to destroy someone as well (freeze bank accounts, push a narrative in the media, imprisonment), as well as define their target as an "enemy combatant", after which all bets are off on lawful treatment. Anyone who thinks that firearms purchased through their local gun store will do anything to stop a truly tyrannical government is living in a fantasy.
- dmos62 7y agoTo outgun a military is probably not a practical ambition for a civilian, simply because stockpiling this stuff would be nuts economically. Very ironically this is something where having a black market helps. The live-round 2014 Kiev battles might be an example of a realistic scenario where different gun regulations could have had a strong impact. There are some definite no-nos, like assault-weapons. And if you want to regulate, instead of prohibit, you have to invest into a good gun culture, which we really don't know anything about. That would be a big social engineering challenge. There are some advantages, like lone-shooter type events becoming much less insidious, which don't cost as many lives as say sedentary life-styles, but being powerless in those (improbable) situations makes us very insecure. That insecurity is very erosive and tiring; but on the other hand, if gun-carry was implemented, and we didn't have a good enough culture, you'd get "casual" shootings, where what would have been a fist fight turned into a gun fight. There's also the argument about whether or not to treat adults as inherently competent. Prohibition, i.e. complete deregulation, all in all seems to me like a quick hack; of course, the other side of the coin is that good regulation is really hard. I'm somewhat torn, but leaning towards regulation. To me it seems like one of those decisions that isn't easy, because it's not win-win-win across the board, but it's worse if you don't do it. Of course this is mostly fantasy. I don't think we'll see gun-carry in the West any time soon. We're used to complete delegation of personal-security and the shift, at this point, would be counter-cultural.
- scottlocklin 7y ago> Of course this is mostly fantasy. I don't think we'll see gun-carry in the West any time soon. ... What part of the West are you talking about? It's super common in vast swathes of the US.
- dmos62 7y agoThe Occident. Yeah, I guess those swathes of the US are the popular exception.
- scottlocklin 7y agoGot it. Though it was pretty common in big parts of The West (as in The Occident) in the first half of the 20th century as well. At least via my understanding of things.
- endymi0n 7y agoWhile I respect your personal taste and a wish for additional perceived safety there, the data says it‘s probably a bad idea. Just carrying a gun will make you 4.46 times as likely to get shot [1] and increase the likelyhood of all loved ones around you to get hurt as well. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2759797/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2759797/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- icelancer 7y agoNo one was bitten by a shark who never entered the water either. There is more to the gun control debates than single-input statistics like the one you cited.
- omegabravo 7y agoI'm not sure I follow this analogy, unless you're supporting their position?
- dmos62 7y agoI too found the analogy interesting. I think the idea is whether or not to "outlaw" the water where the shark swims.
- endymi0n 7y agoActually, no, study after study shows that the amount of guns in a society is strongly correlated to its homicide rate, both directly as well as indirectly (i.e. more violent police raids because they assume residents to be armed). Taking your shark tank metaphor, some people believe it‘s simply not possible to remove guns from a society, which is untrue as well, as the recent example of Australia shows. Heck, lots of people in Germany used to have a gun in WW2, while in 2011, German police shot a whole of 85 bullets in total. Which, incidentally, is exactly one bullet less than Texan police emptied into a single, unarmed suspect after a car chase in the same year. Well, you get what you vote for.