3 ms·
There are so many technical and non-technical problems with this, I don't even know where to start. What's a hash of the work? Lyrics? Original score sheet (if
by dmitriid 7y ago
There are so many technical and non-technical problems with this, I don't even know where to start.
What's a hash of the work? Lyrics? Original score sheet (if there is any)? Any combination of the two? The first studio recording? Some songs may list a dozen collaborators, how's that attribution gonna work?
What's a hash? A hash of the resulting wav? mp3? flac? alac? any combination of the above? hashes of individual instrument tracks?
At which point does a song stop being derivative and becomes an original song (or music in general, see "Dies Irae" for example [1] or even Star Wars [2]). Who and how keeps track of attributions when lyrics are written by one person (or people), music by another, and performed by dozens of different performers over the years? How are collections tracked and attributed (an opera is a collection of musical performances viewed as a single work)?
These are just some of the problems people that try to track and attribute music face today. And they are not going to be magically solved by a "publicly auditable, immutable data store".
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dies_irae#Musical_quotations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dies_irae#Musical_quotations
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/14/arts/music/star-wars-soundtrack-classical-music-new-york-philharmonic.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/14/arts/music/star-wars-soun...
- drpyser 7y agoNobody's claiming a magic bullet. Nothing you mention invalidates the idea, I think. For the first part(the nature of the "hash"), there should obviously be standards to address these questions. An official recording could be identified by a hash of the actual recording in some standard format(e.g. raw wave files). For distribution of score sheet and lyrics, those can be treated separately and have their own hash identifier according to their own standard. The rest are philosophical and legal questions that are orthogonal to the technical problem. The point of the suggestion, is to address the technical side of the problem. Having an open platform where authors/copyright owners can hold public records of their copyrighted works and their distribution, and point to it as legal evidence, would certainly be useful, don't you think?
- dmitriid 7y ago> The rest are philosophical and legal questions that are orthogonal to the technical problem. The point of the suggestion, is to address the technical side of the problem. That's the problem: you're addressing the most boring and the least important part of the problem that has already been solved. No one in this world has any trouble tracking and attributing songs once a song's metadata is correct. And providing correct metadata is the entirety of the problem which you just glossed over as "philosophical and legal questions that are orthogonal to the technical problem". They are not.