6 ms·
I've been a technical editor on a few programming titles. I don't think the average developer realizes that for the authors writing a book is a passion project
by rmason 7y ago
I've been a technical editor on a few programming titles. I don't think the average developer realizes that for the authors writing a book is a passion project.
Not only won't you get rich, you will be extremely lucky to make minimum wage. Most if not all the marketing is on your shoulders. Even though it's a hits driven business the publishers do all right though.
- Silhouette 7y agoWhat puzzles me is why most people writing book-length technical work in 2019 should use a traditional publisher at all. The premise that a publisher deserves to keep the vast majority of sales revenue because of the value they add seems like it belongs in another time. In the modern digital and online market, the idea of publisher as some sort of gatekeeper with established channels through distribution networks and into bricks and mortar bookstores is largely obsolete. And what publisher today provides a new author with enough technical editing resources or marketing power or administrative support to justify taking the rights and keeping most of the revenue? Maybe someone has already done this, but it seems to me there's an obvious opportunity for some sort of small-scale broker service that connects authors with independent professionals who can offer the necessary skills in editing, design, illustration, ecommerce, printing and distribution if physical copies are wanted, and so on.
- ghaff 7y agoBecause the money involved is often not much and there’s still some cred associated with traditional publishers.
- drongoking 7y agoSpeaking as another O'Reilly author, I'd agree with this and add that for tech books the publisher is even less necessary. If you've written papers with Latex/MD/asciidoc, and drawn figures and tables, you're already doing most of what you'd do with your publisher's toolchain anyway. Hook up with Amazon's on-demand publishing service and (except for the nice cover) you've got it almost end-to-end. [I assume you can write and organize thoughts decently well, and have some people who can proofread for you. If not, a publisher really won't help too much with that anyway.] So what does a publisher provide? Marketing, promotion, distribution, reputation. No matter how good of a book you write, having a name publisher like O'Reilly gives you substantial credibility that nothing else will. They can arrange promotions through conferences and email distribution that you probably can't. I wouldn't underestimate this, but I also wouldn't necessarily think it's worth their 80%-90% cut either.
- Silhouette 7y agoNo matter how good of a book you write, having a name publisher like O'Reilly gives you substantial credibility that nothing else will. Perhaps, but as they say, credibility doesn't pay the rent. What matters in commercial terms of how much money the book ends up putting in your pocket. If a publisher is keeping 90% of the revenue, the services they offer had better generate at least an order of magnitude more sales to break even, less anything it would have cost you to obtain any other relevant services they provided directly instead. Does anyone here believe that this is in fact the case with the level of marketing that a typical tech publisher will do for a new work from a previously unknown author?
- wtracy 7y agoFor a lot of the authors of technical books, credibility is the whole point. The goal is not to write a book that directly makes money. The goal is to write a book that gets the author hired or promoted, or to land consulting gigs, or to get VC backing. So, yes, credibility does pay the rent.
- sytelus 7y agoI have heard authors making as little as $500 and very rarely someone making more than $5000 from technical/programming books (outside of top 1% books). Given you easily put 500 hours of work in a book, the best possible outcome for vast majority of authors is literally minimum wage payment. Most authors are competent enough to make 5X more on their regular jobs so they are certainly not writing book for money.
- zwischenzug 7y agoI've made more than $5000 (each) from three books (two self-published, one '1st tier'). I don't think it's that rare, or maybe I"m lucky. Agree on the minimum wage comment, though. I did it for career progression, personal life goals, and passive income.
- cerberusss 7y ago
- coliveira 7y agoI wrote technical books through traditional publishers, and one reason I can tell is that they do some of the difficult parts of the process, which I consider extremely boring: proofreading, formatting, book cover, indexing. All of these are activities that can be better done by specialized people and are boring as hell. Even if you have the patience to do this part, most probably the book design will look amateurish. On the other hand, self publishing will only be financially rewarding if you are willing to do the marketing, in other words, if you want to make this a full-time gig, which is not the case for most technical writers. As for your last remark, most technical publishers are already nimble operations that connect professionals and designers. It just happens that these small companies are owned by large corporations in order to benefit from the access to market channels. So, unless you're willing to make this a full time job, I don't think it is such a great deal to self-publish your technical books.
- coldtea 7y ago>I wrote technical books through traditional publishers, and one reason I can tell is that they do some of the difficult parts of the process, which I consider extremely boring: proofreading, formatting, book cover, indexing. You can hire people to do all that -- if you expect to sell your self-published book, and still make more profits than with a publisher.
- mgkimsal 7y agoyou can, but then need to know how to vet them, and ideally they can work together well (professionally, on time, etc). you're taking on more risks and/or more managerial work by doing it. certainly possible, but not without cost.
- coldtea 7y ago>you can, but then need to know how to vet them Or you just ask someone who know, and whose books you like, which ones they use...
- coliveira 7y ago
- rmason 7y agoThere were a few publishing startups that only published electronically and let the author keep 60% of the title's price. I can't find them anymore so perhaps the experiment failed.
- marvindanig 7y agoUp to 85% of the title's price. Meet Bubblin @ https://bubblin.io https://bubblin.io Discl.: founder here.
- Silhouette 7y agoInteresting idea. FYI, the layout of your home page breaks if your browser default font size isn't 16px, leaving most of the important text unreadable.
- marvindanig 7y agoCan you send a screenshot what you see/inspected to my mail? marvin@bubblin.io Edit: I understand the issue now. Thanks!
- Silhouette 7y agoSorry, I'm commenting pseudonymously, so not really. But if you just change your browser default font size to say 20px you can't miss it.
- peterarmstrong 7y agoAt Leanpub, authors keep 80% of the title's price. We've paid over $7.5M in royalties to authors, and we're alive and well :) Write in Markdown, click a button, get a book (PDF, EPUB, MOBI). Click a different button and your book is for sale with an attractive landing page, etc. You can even create a MOOC with one click, again based on Markdown... (disclosure: cofounder)
- sytelus 7y ago
- buckminster 7y agoBy the time you've paid these professionals the typical book is making a loss. A publisher profits from the hits. This is much more of a gamble for a lone author.
- Silhouette 7y agoThis is a reasonable argument, but an unfortunate corollary is that the author of a really successful book is losing out because they're subsidising all the commercial failures that the publisher took a punt on. The bookie always wins, but no-one else is guaranteed to.
- dmje 7y agoIn my experience (author of "technical" book about digital strategy), you need publishers for two things: 1) there's still some kudos in having something commissioned, edited and published by a known entity and 2) the imposition of a hard deadline. If you can cope on your own without either of these, sure, self publish. It is a hard slog, and as others say here, it's unlikely to earn you a reasonable wage - but it's hugely satisfying to see it through knowing how much discipline it takes.
- drongoking 7y agoAmen to this. In fact, I tell people that if they're interested in writing a book they shouldn't be asking themselves "Should I write a book?", they should be thinking: "I have 18 months of free time. What could I do with it?" That's a lot of free time. You could: - Learn a musical instrument pretty well. - Learn a sport and get pretty good at it. - Become a major committer on a large open source project. - Pick up a foreign language and achieve proficiency. - Make a lot of money on the side. - Go back to school and get a degree. - Concentrate on your social life. - Write a book. If after considering these, you decide that writing a book is the best use of your time, go for it. Think of the money as a nice bonus.
- hahamrfunnyguy 7y agoEvery time I start to think about writing a technical book, this is what stops me. The sheer amount of time you'd need to spend writing it is staggering. On the flip side, once you've published the book being a noted author may present you with certain kinds of opportunities that may not have been available before. That perhaps is more valuable than the revenue generated from the book.