2 ms·
Do note that I'm not talking about asking questions on IRC; but rather, I'm talking about asking questions of people who I already know to be experts in the spe
by derefr 7y ago
Do note that I'm not talking about asking questions on IRC; but rather, I'm talking about asking questions of people who I already know to be experts in the specific field I'm asking about. (The "specialized contractors" you're talking about, but more like e.g. university professors.) Like, if I have a concrete graph-theory problem, I'm asking a graph-theory expert about it.
The problem doesn't come because the population I'm asking doesn't know graph theory; it's because someone who's an expert on graph theory can't be expected to also know e.g. DSP design, and the higher-level problem is a DSP design problem, and once they find that out, they say they don't know DSP design and refuse to help. Even though the concrete problem is a graph theory problem!
This is, IMHO, one of the key psychological problems hindering interdisciplinary fields of study: everyone thinks that, because a problem is A&B, and they only know things about A, that they can't make a contribution. Even though everyone only knows either A or B, and the whole point is to get the people who know A talking to the people who know B, rather than to create some sort of A&B paragons.
- ska 7y agoOften a key problem with interdisciplinary study, as you described it, is that the people who know A and the people who know B are often both bad at communicating outside of their expertise. Sometimes terrible. Even worse sometimes when they teach A or B, because they incorrectly believe they are good communicators due to having some success as lecturers, but don't realize how narrow that is. So getting them to talk to each other often isn't nearly enough - you need a translator in the conversation, or you need to teach them to be more effective communicators.