3 ms·
I probably wouldn’t be so cavalier about writing off and calling BS the legacy of legal definitions that are successfully protecting citizens. It has taken a lo
by dahart 7y ago
I probably wouldn’t be so cavalier about writing off and calling BS the legacy of legal definitions that are successfully protecting citizens. It has taken a long time and a lot of smart people to get to where we are with expectation of privacy, and while it might not be perfect, it has been battle tested in court, so it’s presumptuous to assume your untested opinions are clearly better.
The problem I see with your suggestion is then society must pro-actively make some sort of decision for each and every domain in advance, which isn’t possible. The goal of expectation of privacy is as a test to determine when privacy would be or has been violated on a case by case basis. In that sense it’s already somewhat doing what you’re talking about; it is a way to determine whether society deems privacy beneficial in a given domain.
Whether privacy is achievable does not make a good criteria at all, because it’s always possible to compromise privacy. The entire point of the “expectation of privacy” test is to determine whether someone who did violate another’s privacy should be allowed to, it’s a pre-cursor to determining right to privacy.
- coldtea 7y ago>The problem I see with your suggestion is then society must pro-actively make some sort of decision for each and every domain in advance, which isn’t possible. First, why not? It's very much possible, we have all kinds of systems in place, even electronic voting. Second, privacy is a serious matter, of which there aren't tons, so it's not like "each and every domain" is equally important. Third, it's not like a decision for all domains has to be taken simultaneously and right now. We could vote for one domain per year, and we'd have covered 10 most important domains in a decade... >The goal of expectation of privacy is as a test to determine when privacy would be or has been violated on a case by case basis. It's also used to mean "you wouldn't expect it in X domain, so you don't get to have it there". And, as lots of domains where privacy is important are new, what's "expected" can go either way, like FB trying to argue that "people don't expect privacy in social media". If we instead change it to whether people want privacy in social media, that's more clear cut, regardless to whatever someone can argue we "expect" or "not". In fact, even if we keep it to "expect" (as the deciding factor), why shouldn't we vote on whether we do expect it or not? Why expect should be speculation? Ask us (the people) to vote directly whether we expect it or not, don't decide for us, with some BS medieval-style theological syllogisms...
- dahart 7y agoI suspect your strong negative reaction to expectation of privacy is because you’re mixing up expectation of privacy with right to privacy, which are two different legal concepts. I think what you’re proposing is right to privacy laws rather than expectation of privacy. Laws establishing right to privacy already exist as a declaration of what domains society deems privacy necessary in. Expectation of privacy is there as a legal test to help make determinations in cases where the right to privacy hasn’t been already established. We can and do already vote on it, and laws establishing the right to privacy online already exist and more are in the process of being established, since historically speaking online domains have only just barely been invented. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_privacy#Privacy_laws_in_different_countries https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_privacy#Privacy_law... For example, you already have no right to privacy from being photographed while outside in public in the US. You already do have an established right to privacy in your bedroom. Neither of those cases is subject to expectation of privacy tests, because the right to privacy has already been determined. Personally it seems quite useful for expectation of privacy to always exist as a way to help sort out domains that have not yet been covered by law, and it would be silly to think that we understand all the future permutations and implications of online privacy mixed with big data well enough to cover it legally today. Facebook’s defense here is using “expectation of privacy” in a subversive and sneaky way. The problem is Facebook has both kinds of data, public and private. It’s wrong to suggest that people don’t have an expectation of privacy for their hidden profile data just because they’re using social media. It’s probably right to suggest that anything I post publicly can’t be considered private, even if people want that. But that’s complicated when you data-mine all public data at once and draw potentially private implications using AI. It looks like their defense is about to be tested in court, so hopefully the court will see through Facebook’s defense. One of the outcomes of Facebook using “expectation of privacy” as their defense is that whatever happens here in court starts to become the law by precedent.