3 ms·
Because despite what everyone thinks again and again, music is not hierarchical, as a file system is. Does my album go under the composer, the conductor, the or
by chrisseaton 7y ago
Because despite what everyone thinks again and again, music is not hierarchical, as a file system is. Does my album go under the composer, the conductor, the orchestra or the soloist?
- ken 7y agoSame as any other document on my disk: it doesn't matter. Just dump everything in there and let Spotlight index it. (That's basically what iTunes does now, except the exact behavior is hidden behind a mysterious "Keep iTunes Media folder organized" checkbox, and the index is stored in big opaque XML files rather than Spotlight.) My email has hierarchical folders, too, but I don't know anyone who worries about the folder structure of their email. All messages are indexed, and search is quick, so there's not much point.
- jjdjr0odo7 7y agoWhy can’t it read what’s what and generate a map without all the mv’ing? The answer is probably in the realm of “That’s how we wrote desktop apps back then.” Files are not real things. Just identifiers for an organization of bits that sound like a Neil Young sing when played through the correct decoder.
- dwaite 7y agoIt seems many people also under the misunderstanding that iTunes has to control the location of your music - that was just the default
- benj111 7y agoHow do I organise my album collection? Alphabetically? By genre? Year? Record label? You can organise your collection how you like. There is no right answer (although its obviously by genre). If you're indecisive then just dump everything into one huge flat file, or just add links.
- scrooched_moose 7y agoI'm still annoyed how long it took to get "featuring" to be a common tag. An album like 2.0 by Big Data would create 10 different distinct "artists" in most music players: Big Data and White Sea Big Data and Joywave Big Data and Jamie Lidell Big Data and Kimbra Big Data and Rivers Cuomo Big Data Big Data and Jenn Wasner Big Data and Dragonette Big Data and Bear Hands Big Data and Twin Shadow Even Amazon Music had this problem up until 2018 or so, when my library collapsed from nearly 2000 "artists" to ~300 actual.
- ErikAugust 7y agoIt goes under Albums, no?
- chrisseaton 7y agoThat was my point... you're not really using the filesystem. It's just a big pile of files if you stick it all in Albums. iTunes organises that because the filesystem can't.
- klodolph 7y agoThe question is how you organize the albums, hierarchically. The easy case is when you have artist/album/track, like: Music > Buckethead > Enter The Chicken > Funbus But how do you file, say, classical music? Do I file this album under Wilhelm Furtwängler, the conductor? Do I file this under Bach and Beethoven, the conductors of various tracks? Do I file this under Wiener Philharmoniker? In iTunes it’s irrelevant, because I can find the album by looking for Composer=Bach, Composer=Beethoven, artist=Wilhelm Furtwaengler, or artist=Wiener Philharmoniker. With a filesystem I would… use symlinks or something?
- mynameishere 7y agoBeethoven goes under Beethoven. No one groups stuff by orchestra. And just because a media player respects your filesystem doesn't mean you can't search by the metadata in the Mp3s. This is extra-helpful when you realize not all Mp3s have metadata. In that case, such search routines will just pass it by.
- klodolph 7y agoBut filing it under Beethoven means that the album is split apart. This doesn’t make sense to me.
- brians 7y agoHard links are going to blow your mind. https://www.gnu.org/software/libc/manual/html_node/Hard-Links.html https://www.gnu.org/software/libc/manual/html_node/Hard-Link... Seriously, I had my MP3s organized this way pre-iTunes. I get why that can’t scale to the general public, but I still think a tool could approximate it.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Hard links are going to blow your mind. I know what hard links are. > I get why that can’t scale to the general public So why suggest it as a solution? > pre-iTunes So even you gave up on it?
- mixmastamyk 7y agoImagine... a program that could automate this for you. We could call it an "Application."
- jaredklewis 7y agoFor one thing, even if this was a good idea, you would still need a tool to covert the meta information from the ID3 tags that come with your music from amazon, iTunes Store, or wherever into a myriad of hard links. Further, it's hard to imagine how the hard link system could ever be as flexible as even an average music library program, where you can trivially find songs released between 1990 and 1995, with at least one play count, and then have them sorted by beats per minute. Music libraries act as relational databases, which are a far more powerful data modeling tool than the file system.
- reaperducer 7y agoDoes my album go under the composer, the conductor, the orchestra or the soloist? This is one of my peeves with the 40's channel on Sirius. There could be the wonderful voice of a woman singing a song, but the display will only read "Benny Goodman Orchestra."