3 ms·
The Supreme Court should, and probably will, deny cert. Read the CAFC's opinion. Pretty cut and dry in favor of Oracle. APIs are not an abstract idea, but a co
by bitwize 7y ago
The Supreme Court should, and probably will, deny cert.
Read the CAFC's opinion. Pretty cut and dry in favor of Oracle. APIs are not an abstract idea, but a concrete expression of an idea, thus protected by copyright. Google could have chosen its own expression, but decided to copy Oracle, which is against the law.
- nailer 7y agoSo does that mean Word, which implemented WordPerfect APIs, is illegal? And Lunacy and Figma shouldn't be able to open Sketch files? Edit: if it's unclear, making APIs patentable would prevent all of the above. API compatibility is essential to compete with big players.
- monocasa 7y agoOr Oracle when they implemented SQL?
- e1ven 7y agoUnder that interpretation, I'm curious what you view as different than IBM vs Compaq about the original PC bios?
- bitwize 7y agoThe law is the law. Wishing it were different doesn't make it so. Which means that yes, Compaq and other PC clone makers may have broken the law by reimplementing the PC BIOS. The BIOS API does not depend on named functions but rather on specific values appearing in CPU registers, so I'm not sure how copyright applies to that. Maybe a "structure, sequence, and organization" argument à la Whelan v. Jaslow.
- wtallis 7y ago> The BIOS API does not depend on named functions but rather on specific values appearing in CPU registers, so I'm not sure how copyright applies to that Do you have any reasoning for treating magic numbers different from English-like names for the purpose of determining copyright eligibility?
- bitwize 7y agoNo, I don't. Which only supports the copyrightability of the BIOS API, and the illegality of BIOS clones (and hence, early PC clones).
- icebraining 7y agoThe SCOTUS already denied cert on the question of copyrightability. The question now is whether it's fair use.
- bitwize 7y agoIt isn't fair use. Fair use under U.S. law refers to excerpting a copyrighted work for certain purposes including news reporting, research, scholarship, criticism, and parody. If Google copied the APIs without any of these uses in mind (almost a certainty in the case of Android), they infringed on Oracle's copyright. Period.
- icebraining 7y agoThe test doesn't include any such list of purposes. That said, yeah, it's probably not fair use.
- bitwize 7y ago17 U.S.C. §107 does include a list of purposes which, while not exhaustive, is intended to show the sort of things which constitute fair use -- things which Android's use of Java code is far removed from.
- wtallis 7y agoThat isn't too surprising, given that functional compatibility really isn't the kind of thing you would expect a copyright law to discuss. If copyright is being stretched to cover this new realm, then it also needs to be assessed for what should qualify as fair use in this realm.