4 ms·
Derek Lowe just had a blog post out today which is quite skeptical of the mice study: https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2019/05/31/autism-mouse-mod
by jcranmer 7y ago
Derek Lowe just had a blog post out today which is quite skeptical of the mice study: https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2019/05/31/autism-mouse-models-for-the-microbiome https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2019/05/31/au....
The salient points are:
* Very small N.
* Behavioral studies of mice can be very subjective in their own right, so you can definitely get bias, particularly with small N.
* There's no generally accepted model of autism in mice. In other words, mice might not even be capable of getting autism in the first place, so saying that "these behaviors in mice correlate with autism in humans" is a bit of a limb.
* No measurement of the microbiome in the descendants-of-the-implanted-microbiome (the ones that were actually tested) was demonstrated.
So you can come away from the paper with the feeling that they set out to test a hypothesis, interpreted subjective results in the way that best matches the hypothesis, and failed to (or perhaps even purposefully excluded) test for alternate hypotheses that might explain the evidence better.
- ljiljana 7y ago_sigh_ this feeling again when you read about some great "paradigm-shift" advancement and then go to HN comments and find out the study has bunch of holes. :(
- OldSchoolJohnny 7y agoNo the research is getting pretty definitive in this area, don't count it out and the article also specifically talks about another study not the mouse one where they had real world success (over 50%) treating autism in people via bacteria transplant.
- ljiljana 7y agothe very small N part still applies here though, the study was done on 18 children only, given the prevalence of ASD and the complexity of it I think we just need more proof. I won't count it out but I think the conclusions should've just been: this looks promising but we need to study it more. (tbf, i think i'm complaining more about the tone of the article.)
- beenBoutIT 7y agoThe sad thing is that in America today you can't get access to the two big 'miracle cures' (fecal transplants or MDMA) for any reason outside of clinical trials. Anyone with a non-verbal loved one should be able to legally try the fecal transplant and anyone with PTSD should be allowed to legally try MDMA. Scientifically proving that treatments work isn't nearly as important as proving that treatments are safe.
- Semiapies 7y agoI'm just grimly amused that this is the third completely different "real cause of autism" post on the front page in about the last week.
- sytelus 7y agoThis is the side effect calling "surveys" as "studies" and then confusing them with science.
- StavrosK 7y agoI was half-amused, half-horrified at the remote possibility that vaccines might alter the gut microbiota and actually cause autism. I couldn't bear hearing "I told you so" from my antivaxxer friend.
- jaylaal 7y agoWhy do you focus on the mice, when the article talks about two studies, one of which was longer term and done on humans? "Crucially, these changes in gut bacteria have translated into behavioural changes. Even 18 weeks after treatment started the children had begun showing reduced symptoms of autism. After two years, only three of them still rated as severe, while eight fell below the diagnostic cut-off point for asd altogether. These eight thus now count as neurotypical."
- martincmartin 7y agoBecause he knows something relevant about the mouse study, but not the human study. He's not objecting to the conclusions or tone of the Economist article, just the mouse study. Seems legit to me.
- panarky 7y agon = 18 What is the probability that 8 ASD kids out of 18 would be neurotypical after 2 years even without the treatment?
- leoh 7y agoCorrect, but this is COMPLETELY missing the bigger picture. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-42183-0 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-42183-0