4 ms·
Thank you for writing that, totally agree. One thing is unclear to me, though: > He's arguing that we should install glass more closely resembling the original
by crazygringo 7y ago
Thank you for writing that, totally agree. One thing is unclear to me, though:
> He's arguing that we should install glass more closely resembling the original medieval glass, which would allow more light into the structure.
I did a little research, and as far as I can tell, the windows were originally stained glass, then many were replaced with clear glass in the 17-18th century, then re-replaced with stained glass again after that.
So there's nothing "original" about clear glass, and I fail to see any evidence that the original stained glass was particularly lighter (the author calls the newest glass "gaudy bubblegum 19th-century stuff" but bubblegum doesn't mean "darker", and he calls the original glass "delicate and jewel-like" but that merely describes surface texture, not how deep the colors were). Stained glass keeps an interior pretty dark no matter what. So his suggestion to:
> let the sunlight continue to fall across these stones and get the endless Parnassian passages of Victorian-Era glass out to let the clerestory do what it’s supposed to do – be a clear story
Doesn't make any sense. I just don't think you can have all the clear sunlight (like it is right now, as beautiful as it may be) and stained glass. You just have to pick one or the other.
- chadash 7y agoThanks. I probably misread that and I edited my comment above accordingly.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> he calls the original glass "delicate and jewel-like" but that merely describes surface texture, not how deep the colors were Really? I interpret "delicate and jewel-like" as applied to stained glass as a comment on color and size. It's hard for me to imagine it as a comment on a physical property like texture -- historically, jewels were valuable first for their color and then for their resistance to damage. The color part is less true today -- we can cheaply make almost any color of glass -- but the "precious" stones are one and all a lot harder than glass is. Even when amethyst was very expensive... quartz is a lot harder than glass. If "texture" refers to clarity, glass is a big improvement over natural jewels.
- tomatotomato37 7y agoIt's most likely that modern techniques are too "perfect"; the horribly impure coloration and janky glass composition (the texture of the glass chunk in the literal sense) as a result of technological limitations; in contrast to the "new" glass of the 19th century, which was already experiencing the first industrial revolution and thus could produce quality glass a lot more consistently. At least that's the impression I got from googling "medieval stained glass vs modern"