3 ms·
Sample size of 1. That's like the smokers who tell stories of centenarian smokers to prove that tobacco is not all that dangerous.
by adrianN 7y ago
Sample size of 1. That's like the smokers who tell stories of centenarian smokers to prove that tobacco is not all that dangerous.
- dfsegoat 7y agoNo. It's a case study that shows that a worst case exposure to radioactive material is not a death sentence. Are you familiar with the term "Case study" or "Case report"? It it is a medical/other study that follows a single individual over time. These are published daily in many medical journals.
- neuronic 7y agoWorst case? What? Those were alpha particles. You're lucky to get them through a postcard.
- rndmio 7y agoWhich is precisely why you don't want them inside your body, every alpha particle emitted by the delay will hit and be absorbed inside you, it is the worst. That's why the Russian chose Polonium to kill Litvinenko.
- baybal2 7y agoThere are alpha particles of different energies, and products of decay of emitters may well not be good for your health either. Polonium besides being acutely toxic itself, decays into lead for example.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoAlpha particles cannot penetrate intact human skin. But they're extremely dangerous if they're already inside your skin.
- adrianN 7y agoI am familiar with case studies. A single case study is often a curiosity that might motivate someone to do a proper study, but not something from which you can conclude that having Americium in your body is not as dangerous as commonly claimed.
- codewritinfool 7y agoI don't know how you can classify that as "worst case exposure".
- option 7y agofor more samples go to the villages in the 30 km zone around Chernobyl- few people refused to evacuate and still live there at the very old age. Though I doubt they were ever exposed to such high levels of radiation as mentioned in the parent.
- jellicle 7y agoThe guy lived for ten years after the accident. He spent the first four or five years undergoing chelation therapy daily to remove the radioisotopes from his body tissues. At the time of his death, the dose model suggested he would have about a 12% chance of not having cancer. He didn't have cancer. So, he rolled a 1 on an 8-sided die and didn't get cancer in that time. If he had lived longer, cancer would be a near certainty, though it still might not have been what killed him.
- DataWorker 7y agoCancer is caused by longevity. If you live long enough you will probably have cancer too.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoCancer is not caused by longevity. It's statistically more likely the longer you live. So your second sentence is true, but your first sentence is false.