4 ms·
“With hindsight, we can say the evacuation was a mistake,” said Philip Thomas, a professor of risk management who led a recent research project on nuclear accid
by mpweiher 7y ago
“With hindsight, we can say the evacuation was a mistake,” said Philip Thomas, a professor of risk management who led a recent research project on nuclear accidents. “We would have recommended that nobody be evacuated.”
- whatshisface 7y agoAccording to Wikipedia, >At present, radiation levels have dropped considerably, compared to the fatal levels of April 1986 Which says that yes, Pripyat should have been evacuated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pripyat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pripyat
- Tharkun 7y agoNot to mention the whole groundwater incident...which, had it not been for (suicidal?) miners digging a tunnel, the water supply of FIFTY MILLION people would have been contaminated.
- CyanBird 7y agoWhen it comes to the miners, they actually weren't necessary, the corium lava didn't breach the lower levels of concrete, it solidified before that, so all those miners were exposed to all that radiation and risk of cancer needlessly, of course at the time it wasn't known that would be the situation so they made the right call anyways
- pdkl95 7y agoThe people that were very unfortunately necessary that deserve to be remembered are the 3828 "liquidators" that cleaned up the radioactive graphite (mixed with bits of reactor fuel/waste) that covered the roof above the reactor. In their own words[1]: > [the remote control bulldozer] has overridden a graphite block with it's right caterpillar track, and now was sitting on 12,000 Roentgen fragment. [...] Starodumov was already thinking about something else... what all of us have already known: robots failed, and the extra radioactive zones will have to be cleaned by men. > The shift lasted only two minutes. [...] Here, the unthinkable background radiation of nearly 8000 Roentgens. 20 meters away from us is the naked muzzle of the destroyed reactor. [...] With each succeeding group, with each fragment removed, the background radiation will reduce. This means the risk for the next group will already be lower. [1] (this includes footage of the cleanup) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FfDa8tR25dk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FfDa8tR25dk
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoEven that is misleading though. The consequence of that isn't that fifty million people have to drink contaminated groundwater forever, it's that you have to build a fancy water filtration plant not unlike the ones in Silicon Valley where the water supply was polluted by 20th century semiconductor manufacturing.
- Tharkun 7y agoI'm sure that would have been very practical in 1980s Soviet Russia. After all, they were know for really caring about human lives. You know what would have happened? 50 million people drinking contaminated water and dying from it.
- option 7y agoI grew up in a city (Slavutich) ~ 35 miles from Prioyat where it was evacuated. Radiation levels there two times smaller than in Manhattan ( which is still within the norm). Interestingly, some people refused to evacuate from nearby villages and still live there (within evacuated 30km zone) at the very old age.
- mpweiher 7y agoInterestingly, the source given for the "fatal levels" (footnote 20) appears to be the book "Bugging In and Bugging Out", which is a survivalist guide: https://www.amazon.com/Bugging-Out-David-Crossley/dp/1291390103 https://www.amazon.com/Bugging-Out-David-Crossley/dp/1291390... Whether such a book is a reliable source for that kind of claim is certainly debatable, but even more interestingly, the cited page does not even say anything about "fatal" levels of radiation: "Although radiation levels in Pripyat have now dropped sufficiently for tourists to be allowed to visit the city, ..." https://books.google.de/books?id=9NlCCwAAQBAJ&pg=PA59&lpg=PA59&dq=radiation+levels+of+pripyat+dropped&source=bl&ots=azZyCRfT8p&sig=D-P-vzl31rHLoC-lFyAxB2c5PrM&sa=X&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=radiation%20levels%20of%20pripyat%20dropped&f=false https://books.google.de/books?id=9NlCCwAAQBAJ&pg=PA59&lpg=PA...
- mrspuratic 7y agoThe parent comment has had its context stripped: it was about the Fukushima evacuation which resulted, directly or indirectly, in an estimated 2100 fatalities (or "premature deaths" to be precise). Mass panic, evacuation and long-term displacement have predictable consequences.
- beat 7y agoTalking about risk mitigation in hindsight as unnecessary is a very bad view of risk management, especially for someone who is supposedly an expert at it. You don't do risk mitigation because things will go badly, you do it because it could go badly. Or alternately, you could use "password" for all your passwords, after all, if no one ever breaks into your accounts, there's no reason to have bothered with difficult passwords.