4 ms·
Is Qualcomm a ruthless monopolist? Yep. But what people forget is that EVERYBODY was knifing one another in that space when CDMA originally came out. The onl
by bsder 7y ago
Is Qualcomm a ruthless monopolist? Yep. But what people forget is that EVERYBODY was knifing one another in that space when CDMA originally came out. The only difference is that Qualcomm is the ruthless monopolist that won.
In addition, while I have no love lost for Qualcomm, what you do have to remember is that CDMA was a "bet the farm" moment. If CDMA could be delivered, it was significantly better than what existed at the time.
However, there was no promise that a power amplifier could be delivered with the specifications demanded by CDMA--Qualcomm bet that they could. Rockwell had a worldwide monopoly on CDMA power amplifiers for years because they were delivering that amp, and the yield was abysmal.
The original Qualcomm stuff was a significant engineering achievement, and, while they probably don't deserve to continue to abuse their position at this point, they certainly deserved some time to profit from their work.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tareqak 7y agoWhat other corporation requires paying to license their patent portfolio in order to be allowed buy their products? I don't have to pay for a license from McDonald's to eat their burger. I'm not an expert in this domain, so there might be more relevant example. Update: fixed up my wording.
- aspenmayer 7y agoYou do have to agree to the McDonald's app terms and conditions so you can get its benefits, like skipping the line. You pay twice: first, with money; then, with data.
- tareqak 7y agoYou're paying to skip the line using data, but you're not paying for the meal with data. If you could only purchase the meal using the app, then you could make the argument that some part of the meal price could be paid from the data itself. I don't know if there are vending machines that will only sell if you have the relevant app installed first, but I think those come closer. However, unless the terms of service of any of those approaches penalized me for buying a meal at Burger King, then we aren't quite at the same level of scrutiny as opposed to what was reported to have happened in this article.
- bsder 7y agoUm, wasn't that the case for MP3 until the patents ran out? You basically couldn't buy MP3 encoding hardware because nobody could negotiate a rate that didn't suck.
- newnewpdro 7y ago> and the yield was abysmal. Nit: abysmal means very great/limitless... I suspect you meant dismal here.
- bsder 7y agoYou might want to go check a dictionary. "abysmal" can mean very great or limitless DOWNWARD (a la "abyssal")--but that's a secondary definition. However, the primary definition appears to be: "immeasurably low or wretched : extremely poor or bad"--which is the sense in which I used the word.
- newnewpdro 7y agoI did, but apparently my local WordNet definitions in 'dict' failed me: abysmal adj 1: very great; limitless; "abysmal misery"; "abysmal stupidity" 2: resembling an abyss in depth; so deep as to be unmeasurable; "the abyssal depths of the ocean" [syn: {abysmal}, {abyssal}, {unfathomable}]
- brokenmachine 7y agoabysmal adjective 1. extremely bad; appalling. "the quality of her work is abysmal" synonyms: very bad, dreadful, awful, terrible, frightful, atrocious, disgraceful, deplorable, shameful, woeful, hopeless, lamentable, laughable, substandard, poor, inadequate, inferior, unsatisfactory