6 ms·
CPU design and RF stuff are both very difficult; I wouldn't assume one way or the other. I wonder if knowledge of CPU design is more widely dispersed (e.g. you
by wmf 7y ago
CPU design and RF stuff are both very difficult; I wouldn't assume one way or the other. I wonder if knowledge of CPU design is more widely dispersed (e.g. you can hire ex-Intel, ex-AMD, ex-IBM people) than cellular radios where the only (working) ones seem to be made by Qualcomm.
- derefr 7y ago> cellular radios where the only (working) ones seem to be made by Qualcomm. Seems strange, given that plenty of manufacturers are making the radios on the other side of the cellular connection. Can't, say, Ericsson take the radios in their cell towers or picocells, redo their tape-outs for phone scale, and end up with a workable mobile radio?
- bradstewart 7y agoWhat does "redo their tape-outs for phone scale" mean exactly? Can Intel redo their tape-outs to make a Xeon work in a phone? I suspect those high-power radios are not doing the majority of the RF in silicon.
- guardiangod 7y agoHeh, there are various levels of 'working'. Think Windows 9x kernel vs NT kernel. Both kernels 'work'.
- mschuster91 7y ago> Can't, say, Ericsson take the radios in their cell towers or picocells, redo their tape-outs for phone scale, and end up with a workable mobile radio? Workable maybe but not power efficient, which is crucial in mobile. That takes years to figure out and is the reason why ARM is so utterly dominant on mobile - there simply is not any Intel x86 offering even close to the power envelope of ARM, even after years of ARM dominance Intel hasn't managed to get anything meaningful.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoIntel could probably do it if they had the luxury of redesigning their instruction set. They're stuck with supporting an overly CISC-based instruction set whose roots date back to the early 1970s. ARM didn't have that problem and designed a much more modern RISC-like instruction set which requires a lot less power.
- acdha 7y agoThis argument has held progressively less weight since 1995, when Intel released the Pentium Pro and started the precedent of deciding x86 CISC instructions into the micro-ops which are actually executed. ARM is a respectable architecture and Apple has shipped some very competitive chips but it’s not like Intel’s engineers have been in a coma for forty years.
- umanwizard 7y agoAll the moving pieces in Intel x86-to-RISC decoding (instruction decoder, μop cache, Microcode Sequencer ROM...) use up a non-trivial amount of silicon and power.
- makapuf 7y agoI'm not sure. If that were the case why wouldn't intel expose a native, better fit to uops instruction set in addition to the legacy, difficult to decode one and let the apps use the newer ones (or the subset of existing ones which do map well)?
- umanwizard 7y agoMy guess is (1) inertia, and (2) not wanting to commit to a specific instruction set because they tweak the internal μop set with every release. And (3), this would add complexity, because, even though one is much simpler, now you need two completely separate decoding pipelines and mechanisms for switching between them.
- ansible 7y ago> Can't, say, Ericsson take the radios in their cell towers or picocells, redo their tape-outs for phone scale, and end up with a workable mobile radio? Generally speaking, no. Sometimes in the base stations, you'll find FPGA and such, which are super expensive. The even bigger issue is that you're implementing the other side of the over-the-air protocol, and a whole bunch more stuff too (signaling in the carrier's network). Whereas the modem in a phone is designed to talk to just a single system. Also, the protocols are designed to be asymmetric. The cell station is fixed, but has relatively unlimited size and power constraints compared to the phone. They also have to talk to multiple phones simultaneously, and manage their access to the network.
- wl 7y ago> Ericsson take the radios in their cell towers or picocells, redo their tape-outs for phone scale, and end up with a workable mobile radio? Ericsson used to make cellular chips for mobile devices. They decided to leave that industry rather abruptly, leaving us high and dry on one product I worked on.
- xorcist 7y ago> Can't, say, Ericsson take the radios in their cell towers or picocells, redo their tape-outs for phone scale, and end up with a workable mobile radio? They can, and they did. Not exactly of course, the two products are fundamentally different, but the organization owns enough IP and good engineers to make a viable product. From a technology standpoint it seems reasonable. The problem is that the competition is tough and you need to stay on your toes with much more rapid iteration than on the "other leg" where you sell expensive stuff to telcos. And the margins on the consumer side are smaller. So, historically, it has proven very difficult to host the same two "legs" in the same organization. The one with bigger more reliable business tends to push the other out. It's been the same with much of the computer industry too.
- bradstewart 7y agoYou can license the primary CPU cores from ARM. There is no equivalent in the modem space (that I'm aware of).
- Gibbon1 7y agoOne difference is there is a hella lot more engineers that know how to design and tape out digital designs than mixed signal RF ones. Qualcomm and a few other companies employ most of them.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd you can also buy the company that designed PowerPC chips better than IBM and Motorola could back in the day and have them kickstart designing custom ARM chips. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exponential_Technology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exponential_Technology
- em500 7y agoSamsung, Huawei and Intel all make working 4G modems. They work fine outside the US, which suggests that there is some US-specific problem at work.
- LASR 7y agoCDMA.