4 ms·
I see these stats all the time. What's the carbon footprint for a similar sized bank or stock exchange? How many people are employed? How much carbon do they em
by onlyrealcuzzo 7y ago
I see these stats all the time. What's the carbon footprint for a similar sized bank or stock exchange? How many people are employed? How much carbon do they emit traveling to work? How much money does it cost to employ all those people?
It might be worth comparing a transaction cost of 220.7 kg of CO2 to the average American's carbon footprint per year -- which is 16400 kg CO2. That's basically what the average American emits in 5 days. That DOES seem like a lot. I really doubt transferring similar amounts of money is anywhere near that. But I don't know.
- drawnwren 7y agoIf you want to get into travel and carbon emissions, it would be disingenuous to not include crypto's. I can't imagine a single bank's carbon emissions get close to the commute of even one crypto conference. I'd further venture that the coordination cost of crypto (conferences and travel between individuals) far exceeds that of a single bank, and might rival that of the entire financial industry. This is probably a benefit of extreme centralization.
- nosuchthing 7y agoBitcoin doesn't offer the protection and services provided by banks and stock exchanges, let alone the transaction volume. Employment is a good point, as financial companies employ millions of people but then you would need to add in the additional metrics from companies and OPEX/electrical/hardware related to blockchain startups. All of that is mostly irrelevant though, because the principle design of "Proof of Work" software is to maximize the inefficiency and operational waste of transactions as the network gains users and as time goes on, without any increase in network capacity. The other curious design choice is to decrease the economic output (production) as more work enters the network, which seems quite malicious, but few people have bothered to read and comprehend the design choices in "Satoshi's white paper".
- benj111 7y agoIf you're going to include employees, you need to do the same for bitcoin also, someone has to shepherd the miners. I have no idea how many people might be 'employed' in the bitcoin 'industry' though.
- femto113 7y agoEven without the exact figures it should be obvious that the inefficiency in Bitcoin is astounding. Consider e.g. that the Bitcoin network performs about 400K transactions per day while the Visa network performs about 150MM transactions per day. That works out to 375x. Coincidentally Switzerland consumes about 1/375 of the world's electricity. If the Visa network used the same amount of electricity per transaction as Bitcoin it would require all of the electricity used by the entire world.
- viklove 7y agoDoes the amount of electricity used by the Bitcoin network scale with the quantity of transactions?
- femto113 7y agoBitcoin can't easily increase the quantity of transactions, so it's hard to answer that directly. Bitcoin transaction rates are currently limited by the time to mine a block and the number of transactions per block. Technical and political barriers exist to changing either of those numbers. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_scalability_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_scalability_problem for more details.