4 ms·
The thing is that both viewpoints are basically worthwhile [0]. But this "algorithmic" optimization based around being ahead of individuals needs to choose one
by mindslight 7y ago
The thing is that both viewpoints are basically worthwhile [0]. But this "algorithmic" optimization based around being ahead of individuals needs to choose one uniform "correct" framework for everybody, forcing these disagreements front and center. It used to be that people could go their own ways with live and let live, with change happening at a gristly organic boundary - eg an older generation pressuring a newer generation to conform to their biases / newer generation individually choosing to defy or follow. Now we've got these centralized companies putting themselves in the position of "knowing best", and given that the thing they're really optimizing for is their own bottom line, we know they're going to get it wrong.
[0] I've only read the abstract of the article, so I can't tell if its authors step over the line into unreasonableness. But I am willing to give them the benefit of the doubt, as there is a novel issue here.
edit: Oh jeeze. It seems my "benefit of the doubt" was wholly undeserved. I still stand by my general point, but in relation to some imaginary article where the authors explored users' mild preferences being extrapolated into much stricter "filter bubbles". These stakes of choosing "one true answer" are really bringing the tripe out, as well as fueling the reactions to it.