14 ms·
Former reporter creates ‘Rate my Professor’ for newsrooms
- Veen 7y agoI'd like anyone who is tempted to launch a product like this to read a couple of books on the subject of anonymous denunciations and their consequences throughout history, or even just a couple of Wikipedia articles.
- treme 7y agoAny in particular? Thanks
- monksy 7y agoSo you've been publically Shamed. Trust Me I'm Lying - Ryan Holiday
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- duxup 7y agoI think they know, it's the power of such things they want to control for their own purposes (even if just to sell) that draws them to it. I know some folks who work on "reputation" type services that try to evaluate people based on a litany of factors and data points and then try to sell that data to others as sort of alternative background checks. They're so desperate for data points they'll just scrape basic google searches, any social media, etc. It's all opaque, I suspect very random, they know and do not care as they know the value of possibly being in a dominant position for such things.
- darepublic 7y agoYou are anonymously denunciating these services that are innocently trying to anonymously denunciate.
- duxup 7y agoI guess there is a connection there although I feel like my importance as "random dude on the internet saying something about non specific company or companies" here probabbly has little risk / impact compared to what these companies could do.
- aaron695 7y agoPretty sure the people yelling witch ended up on top.
- whatshisface 7y agoIt sounds like the website she started was closer to glassdoor.com than ratemyprofessor. It was for rating TV stations.
- laughinghan 7y ago> Sistrunk reads all reviews before they are published and verifies each author’s email address to make sure it’s not being reused to submit reviews for the same station more than once. Sounds like they're partially vetted, to at least prevent sockpuppeting and Sybil attacks and the like.
- mises 7y agoLook at what happened with Rotten Tomatoes recently and Captain Marvel. Depending on your perspective, the site either erased ratings to erase a viewpoint or stopped a bunch of trolling brigaders. This happens over and over. I don't trust the opinion of the mob any more than I trust the opinion of a news outlet.
- SolaceQuantum 7y agoActual question and not sarcasm: Where, in your opinion, should one acquire knowledge of current events?
- xfitm3 7y agoAP News.
- empath75 7y agoThe difficult truth that no one wants to acknowledge is that determining the truth when confronted with contradictory sources requires intelligence, critical thinking and education. The reason the us was so vulnerable to fake news is that we’ve spent the last several generations educating our children to be compliant consumers that don’t question authority or use critical thinking skills. The funny thing about this thread is I bet that half of the people think of very different things that the other half when they think of fake news.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoWhat's the difference between using your "intelligence, critical thinking and education" and using your bias?
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIntelligence, critical thinking and education are debiasing tools.
- 7y ago
- noctrine 7y agoThis seems more like 'Glassdoor' targeted at newsrooms more than 'Rate my Professor'. The reviews and blog content seem targeted more at career professionals in the industry than people aiming to consume channel content.
- mola 7y agoThere's an actual solution, it's called a workers union
- yitchelle 7y agoI really hate these types of sites. It is a platform that has plenty of room for fake news and significant of damage for innocent. Unless the rating can be verified and be trusting, please don't do this.
- magic_beans 7y agoAbusive newsrooms with no recourse aren't exactly innocent parties. There are still thousands of people desperate to be reporters. The newsrooms certainly aren't being damaged by this sort of site.
- manfredo 7y agoI agree that abusive newsrooms are bad. But the question remains: how do you discriminate between genuine anonymous allegations and false anonymous allegations? People, regardless of their positions in society, can be shitty. Heck, for all we know, the only people writing on this site are the abusive newsrooms themselves trying to smear their competitors - thus funneling more people towards the abusive newsrooms.
- tastygreenapple 7y agoWe could say the same thing about news sites themselves. If we allow our news to be unverified, surely we can allow unverified opinions of the news makers themselves to stand.
- laughinghan 7y ago> Sistrunk reads all reviews before they are published and verifies each author’s email address to make sure it’s not being reused to submit reviews for the same station more than once. Sounds like they're partially verified. Does that change you how you feel about this at all?
- yitchelle 7y agoNot really sure how that is considered as verification. Sistrunk is spending effort that does not give confidence that the reviews are based on factual events and reviewers are accountable, but that is a tough ask even for established new sites.
- tptacek 7y agoThe woman Sistrunk had come to interview was immobile, and could only intervene by shouting at the cat: “Pickles, now, we don’t bite!” Sistrunk got the interview, then got tested for rabies. Can you test a living person for rabies?
- noctrine 7y agoApparently, there are several tests that can be used but no single test is sufficient. Source: CDC - https://www.cdc.gov/rabies/diagnosis/animals-humans.html https://www.cdc.gov/rabies/diagnosis/animals-humans.html
- Fomite 7y agoI suspect what they actual got was post-exposure prophylaxis.
- Fomite 7y agoGiven RmP is largely regarded in the field as easy to manipulate garbage that shouldn't be used in evaluation and is profoundly biased in it's ratings, I don't think I'd be happy for my product to be called "RmP for X".
- teej 7y agoRate my professor isn’t for people “in the field” though? The primary audience is students, not other teachers. That’s kinda like saying folks in the movie industry think Rotten Tomatoes is garbage. Who cares what they think?
- Fomite 7y agoProbably for the same reason that if my restaurant rating site kept spitting up "Taco Bell" as the best mexican restaurant in town, I probably wouldn't be pleased.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Tycho 7y agoSomeone should make a press transparency database/site. Keep it factual: list of a reporter’s previous articles and institutions; other affiliations; topics they have covered repeatedly; stakeholders/owners of the institutions; co-occurrence of the same phrases in contemporary articles by other reporters; timing of articles compared with others on the same story; etc.
- dopylitty 7y agoThe problem is bootstrapping trust. Why would I trust this proposed site more than any random journalist? In fact I might trust it less because of how easy it is for any shady organization to set up a defamatory site masquerading as trustworthy and impartial.
- hhs 7y agoI also wonder about this scenario. You write: "because of how easy it is for any shady organization to set up a defamatory site masquerading as trustworthy and impartial." I can see emotions, confirmation bias and backfire effect playing a role by, as you note, "a defamatory site". I'm curious if there are options or solutions to counter this?
- Tycho 7y agoBecause it will use the incredible technology known as hyperlinks. The point is to collate publically available information into an accessible single location that will allow easy discovery of hidden agendas and conflicts of interest. You don’t have to trust the site for anything, it’s simply a jumping off point.
- mlb_hn 7y agoI'm doing my graduate work on that. It's hard. MIT has a cool project looking at how individual terms are covered though: https://www.media.mit.edu/projects/media-cloud/overview/ https://www.media.mit.edu/projects/media-cloud/overview/ The relationships when modeling from the author/publication get really big really quick. I suspect as NLP gets better it'll get easier to model though.
- rendall 7y agoI was excited when I thought this was an opportunity to rate news sources. The site's methods for preserving anonymity while ensuring first-hand knowledge could be useful in other similar sites.