5 ms·
Oh, the Mastodon community is going to be ticked about this... Purism said Librem One's server wasn't going to police speech, and they were upset about it. Gab
by ocdtrekkie 7y ago
Oh, the Mastodon community is going to be ticked about this... Purism said Librem One's server wasn't going to police speech, and they were upset about it. Gab is a whole different level.
I think ActivityPub has huge potential to be a way for communities of disparate views and perspectives to exist out there, and two distinct and very opposing groups have grasped onto it: People who want space spaces who don't think mainstream platforms moderate enough, and the alt-right and free speech crowd.
In the long run, I think you'll see a lot of ActivityPub servers, but two distinct federations, with very few links between them: One radically liberal and one radically conservative.
- davexunit 7y agoNice job equivocating nazis and the people that don't like nazis.
- Dirlewanger 7y agoHe did nothing of the sort. And his assessment is correct. Mastodon, and federated social networks, are the wrong direction for social media. I don't understand how more people don't see this; open-source or not, walled gardens only worsen polarization and demonization of the "other side".
- davexunit 7y agoI like my feed to not be flooded with racist/sexist replies. Mastodon has been a huge step in the right direction in this regard. "Free speech" doesn't mean "no moderation allowed".
- Dirlewanger 7y agoYour "feed" (at least in the context of Facebook's/Twitter's) is comprised of people/groups that you follow. If your feed is garbage, then that means you follow people/groups that post garbage. Mastodon will be a more amplified version of that.
- davexunit 7y agoAll posts on twitter are public, which means anyone is susceptible to abuse from any other user, and twitter does next to nothing about it. This isn't the case on the fediverse.
- pgeorgi 7y ago> federated social networks, are the wrong direction > walled gardens only worsen polarization So walled gardens worsen polarization but federated social networks (that provide a way out of walled gardens) are the wrong direction?
- antepodius 7y agoIt's a way to make your very own extra-walled-in garden, for those who want that- just block every instance you don't like, or disagree with, and every instance that doesn't block those you don't like, or disagree with.
- pgeorgi 7y agoYou don't need federated systems for an "extra-walled-in garden". Install some forum software (phpbb, discourse, ...), disable self-registration, done.
- vorpalhex 7y agoFederation is the opposite of walls. If I want an uncensored social network, knowing that I will see objectionable content, then I can have that. Likewise, if someone wants their safe space where gender pronouns are banned, then they can have that, and neither of us interfere with each other - I can even still consume their content if I so wish.
- 0815test 7y agoHistorically, the nazis were neither liberal (favoring liberty and broadly-shared social/economic development) nor conservative (favoring the preservation of existing social arrangements). What they were was radically authoritarian, totalitarian, irrationalistic (the one key feature that might license us comparing recent political developments worldwide to naziism!), and engaged in the pursuit of war, militant politics, violence and State-managed, systematic violence - generally associated with extreme and utter demonization of all sorts of 'unwanted' social outgroups. (We nowadays see such demonization and routine violence being practiced by e.g. non-State actors such as ISIL, but not so much in mainstream politics, thankfully!)
- anon12345690 7y agonice job missing the point that free speech is good even if you dont like it.
- Fins 7y agoEven if this were what was originally said... both groups as so large that at the edges there really is no much difference. Antifa may not5 like nazis, but only because both are competing for the same ecological niche.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post snarky one-liners to HN, least of all on divisive topics, where the guidelines ask you to be more thoughtful and substantive, not less. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- kristianc 7y ago> People who want space spaces who don't think mainstream platforms moderate enough, and the alt-right and free speech crowd. I've never really understood the 'safe spaces' line of argument. I'm a 30 year old white male, and whenever I log onto YouTube I see nothing but recommendations trying to force me down the alt-right rabbit hole. Sure, Twitter has booted off a few high profile people on the alt right but I don't think I've ever seen anyone argue that the debate on Twitter isn't pretty robust. Where's the censorship? And how attractive is a community of people only for people who have been kicked off larger platforms?
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoI tried Diaspora a while ago, and found the lack of "the center" very unappealing in discussions, and see some of the same today on Mastodon: People who end up on these alternate networks tend to be people who were either banned from mainstream or bullied off of them, so they tend to be the very far ends of the political spectrum on both sides. I remember when Wil Wheaton tried to join Mastodon, and some transgression he had against one gender identity or another led to him getting bullied off the network, despite him being... fairly bloody liberal. He just wasn't liberal enough for the crowd.
- r3bl 7y agoNot quite. He shared some blocklists that had a disproportionate amount of trans women during Gamergate. The grudge remained, his Mastodon account received a lot of reports, and the admin of the instance he chose decided that he doesn't want to deal with that drama. Wil fully acknowledged that, and decided to stop using social media altogether. Also, there's no such thing as "not liberal enough". People on the far left aren't liberal — they don't believe in capitalism in the first place. Liberals are more center-left according to US standards, and center-right according to European standards. Further to the left are socialists, communists, and anarchists, not "super-liberals".
- WorldMaker 7y agoFrom what I recall, Wil created two accounts on two different instances without vetting either of them. The first account was on an instance run by a member of the same blocklist "friend group" that caused the Gamergate problems, so it wasn't just an old grudge, but an old wound reopened. The second instance was a non-US-based instance that looked like mastodon.social but was not (IIRC, the instance was Japanese run and moderated?), and the instance moderators had moderation trouble exacerbated by English not being their first language and moderation not being their full time jobs. I feel like Wil could have been successful on Mastodon had he found (or founded) an instance better aligned with his interests and moderation needs in mind (maybe even mastodon.social). Part of the problem of the whole debacle was that learning that any way but the hard way was likely next to impossible for someone like Wil, because Federation is complicated and hard enough to explain to technical people, much less someone with so many complicated moderation/community needs by nature of being a "celebrity" to begin with. (I still sometimes hope that someone like Wil would make the right technical connections to learn everything they need to know in order to thrive in the Fediverse and have joked that I would be happy to be such a guide if I were asked.)
- egypturnash 7y agoI run a Mastodon instance. This morning I blocked Purism's server for openly declaring that they plan to be free-speech absolutists who will not bother with any kind of moderation at all, which my years on the net has made me feel is akin to founding a city and declaring you will not have a sewer. This afternoon I preemptively blocked a couple guesses at what Gab's instance will be named. If and when I hear that Gab's instance is actually running and is using a name that doesn't match my guesses, I'll block that one too. It's really not a big thing to me. I've been blocking Pleromas run by people with anime girl avatars who like to post swastikas for the entire time I've been running an instance. This is just a bigger one. Your theory about how this will sort out in terms of federation topology matches mine.