3 ms·
I think it will be clear that DNS based adblocking may be the only viable adblocking solution for a while.
by xwdv 7y ago
I think it will be clear that DNS based adblocking may be the only viable adblocking solution for a while.
- woodrowbarlow 7y agoor maybe just don't use the browser built by an advertising company
- jmkni 7y agoI remember years ago using Peerblock, is that still a thing? When browsers starting adblockers, it became less useful/neccessary.
- gruez 7y agoDNS based adblocking is a last resort because it's so much worse than extension based adblockers, even worse than the manifest v3 that's being proposed. They can't block first party ads, so Google would be fine if you switched to it.
- xwdv 7y agoThird party ads are usually the worst.
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoI genuinely don't mind first party ads, FWIW.
- galangalalgol 7y agoIt is a good idea anyway but, chrome can probably figure out a way to resolve dns over http anyway. It will be sold as decreasing the risk o dns poisoning.
- stirfrykitty 7y agoWhat about Pi-hole as a service? Surely someone could set up Pi-hole or similar as a service. $5 a month or something similar. You could point your home network and mobile device to the service.
- xwdv 7y agoSome VPNs do this already.
- stirfrykitty 7y agoThanks for the option. I know some VPNs do this, but what about having something like Pi-hole as a paid service. Being that hosting and bandwidth for said hosting is dirt cheap, how difficult and/or legal would it be to set up a service for this? Some web hosting companies tout "unlimited" bandwidth. Would this fall afoul of their notions. A friend tried this with a DO Droplet, but the Google Pixel does not allow changing of the DNS servers. Thoughts? * Editing to say I found this. Some nice gentleman is allowing this for anyone who would like to use it. I cannot vouch for the safety of said link, but here it is: https://freek.ws/public-pi-hole/ https://freek.ws/public-pi-hole/
- cr0sh 7y agoCheck the comments on that public pi-hole link; the guy gives a few "tips" (in the form of a paste of shell commands and apache config changes - so you'll have to understand all of that) on how to begin to set up your own "public pi-hole" if you don't trust his. The greatest issue seems to be whether your hosting service will allow you set a server up (droplet or raspi host) to be a DNS server; his changes in the paste seem to be to mitigate the issues that could come from allowing it. While I've done my fair share of apache config editing and other sysadmin tasks (for my own hobbyist purposes mainly), I'd still do a ton of research on the changes listed to figure out whether they will do what they're supposed to, and whether there are any other things to apply as well. Lastly - I wonder if you could set this up (on a raspi of course) and let it be public facing on your home network? That is - would say comcast or cox allow it (technically, they don't allow any servers, but I've heard that at least cox tends to "look the other way" for low-bandwidth home-based stuff; I would think a home-based DNS pi-hole server that only you and maybe trusted family/friends use would fall in that category - ymmv)?
- stirfrykitty 7y ago
- wtf_is_up 7y agoI believe DNS based adblocking performs poorly with respect to blocking YouTube ads. I ran into this issue when I setup a pihole on my vps and noticed the ads seemed to be served from the same domain as the video. Digging into it, others had the same issue and the solution seemed to be extension based adblocking.
- xwdv 7y agoPersonally I’ve had Youtube Premium for a long time and find it to be the best way to deal with Youtube ads.