5 ms·
A few years ago, I wondered if my electrically-heated office could instead be heated with bitcoin mining hardware. It would effectively be free electricity, rig
by michaelt 7y ago
A few years ago, I wondered if my electrically-heated office could instead be heated with bitcoin mining hardware. It would effectively be free electricity, right?
What I found out from sources like [1] was, because the bitcoin mining difficulty is constantly increasing, the BTC a bitcoin miner produces reduces exponentially. So even with free electricity, a miner that makes BTC worth a total of $361 in 24 months, will only make $10 more if run for 99 months.
And if you only need to heat your office 25% of the year? Well, the mining difficulty will keep on rising even when your hardware is turned off, so it'll be obsolete after 24 months anyway. But it'll only have produced 25% the BTC in its fixed useful life.
So if buying retail mining hardware is already questionably profitable† even with free electricity, buying it and only running it a fraction of the time is even moreso.
This company must be getting a great price on mining hardware if it's profitable to install and run it only a fraction of the time.
[1] https://calc.randomcrypto.org/?h=bitmain-s9j-14.5&hr=14500000000000&hc=625&hp=1350&er=8736.77&sd=19-05-30&d=36 https://calc.randomcrypto.org/?h=bitmain-s9j-14.5&hr=1450000...
† Which seemed to be the case when I researched this, although bitcoin prices can vary a lot of course.
- sandworm101 7y ago>> buying it and only running it a fraction of the time is even moreso. If you have an intermittent power supply, slap a battery on the system and turn it into a continuous power supply. Over a period of time the next amount of mining done will be the same. My point is whether you mine intermittently or continuously you will average out to the same amount of mining at the end of the day/month/year. The only issue is how you tune your battery/mining rig ratios to optimize the hardware investment.
- wmf 7y agoThere's nothing to optimize; the battery costs far more than the value of Bitcoin mined.
- DonHopkins 7y agoBut what if you steal the batteries? Hell, steal the electricity, too! We're talking Bitcoin here! The real money making opportunity is running the security firm that guards all those remote expensive rigs and batteries from being stolen.
- projectramo 7y agoYes! I keep seeing these projects (solar -> BTC, excess energy -> BTC) and I keep running the numbers and running into the same issue. difficulty inflation And I never understood why others don't see it too. Glad you found the same issue because I thought I was missing something. Note: Solar has the same issue you pointed here which is that it only runs part of the time but the difficulty clock is still running. Also: add in the halving of the reward! That happens in 1 year or so. edit: updated reward halving estimate
- knocte 7y ago> the mining difficulty will keep on rising even when your hardware is turned off This is not accurate. I mean, this is generally the case, yes. But technically speaking, difficulty only increases if there needs to be an adjustment in the block-generation time. If in the last two weeks, the average block has been generated faster than 10 minutes, then it means that miners have become faster (either because of better technology or because of more of them entering the market), so difficulty increases. But it could happen also that blocks get slower and difficulty goes down. What I'm getting at is that constant raising of difficulty levels is not an artificially decided, it's a consequence of the market.
- oarsinsync 7y agoIndeed. As value of BTC goes up, number of miners goes up, hashrate goes up, difficulty goes up. As value of BTC goes down, the opposite occurs. This happened following the last crash.
- keymone 7y agoAll of these affect one another but there isn’t clear and strict causal relationship or ordering. Value follows difficulty but also difficulty follows value.
- gridlockd 7y agoValue doesn't follow difficulty. That's the "labor theory of value" fallacy. On the average, higher difficulty doesn't lower new Bitcoin supply, because difficulty adjusts to maintain steady supply. Difficulty is affected by price of Bitcoin and cost of production. Difficulty can still rise if Bitcoin price development is steady or negative, due to newer mining hardware that is more efficient, or due to new sources of energy that are cheaper.
- keymone 7y agoValue follows difficulty because difficulty is valuable in itself - it is a measure of security of bitcoin ledger.
- chrismorgan 7y agoYour Bitcoin-mining heater will only approach 100% efficiency. Reverse-cycle air conditioners, while not feasible everywhere (my Australian one guarantees operation down to −10°C or −15°C, not completely clear which), are typically more like 300–400% efficient, possible because they’re moving, rather than generating, heat. So if we assume you need 35kW of heating for a given space, a reverse-cycle air conditioner may be able to consume only 10kW, while your Bitcoin heater will need to consume 35kW to generate as much heat. So it’s not free electricity even then.
- colechristensen 7y agoYou have to be careful thinking about what efficiency you are talking about. At least while the hardware is new, you are getting paid to have your heat on with a mining rig. Regardless of how efficient your heat pump is (that is Heat output divided by electrical input) you are always paying for the electricity to run it. Even if it has perfect thermodynamic efficiency, even if it is magical and has impossible perpetual-motion efficiency, you are still _paying_ to run it. In the magical scenario the cost goes to zero, but that is still not better than getting paid to run. You can't compare thermo efficiency between something which generates money and heat and something which consumes money and generates heat until a crossover point when the hardware gets old and starts consuming more electricity than it can pay for. If you have a 400% efficient heat pump you would have to wait until your mining equipment generated 75% of the money it took to power, after that the heat pump becomes preferable. Or you have to do money efficiency and talk about the capital cost and operating cost/profit of running each system
- lostmsu 7y agoIf you look at ASIC-resistant currencies (like ETH), their difficulty does not change that much over time.
- EthanHeilman 7y agoAt some point Bitcoin mining difficulty either: 1. must hit a ceiling and the rate of increase will significantly slow, 2. or Bitcoin mining will break SHA-256 and render it insecure. I find 1 to be a the most likely outcome however the most plausible path for 2 would be a novel cryptanalytic attack on SHA-256 which could be exploited to increase mining power. It seems very unlikely that 2 would occur because mining power approaches the brute force limits of SHA-256.
- lftl 7y ago> It seems very unlikely that 2 would occur because mining power approaches the brute force limits of SHA-256. Can you elaborate on this a bit more? I'm not following what you mean by the "mining power approaches the brute force limits of SHA-256."
- EthanHeilman 7y agoIf Bitcoin mining power continues to increase exponentially, it will eventually get to the point that it will brute force the output space of the SHA-256. This won't actually happen because 2^256 is a very^256 big number.
- sunsu 7y agoNo. There is no way for Bitcoin mining to "break SHA-256 and render it insecure". There isn't enough energy in the whole SUN to do that.
- EthanHeilman 7y agoWell Bitcoin mining could "break SHA-256 and render it insecure" by: 1. exploiting cryptanalytic weaknesses in SHA-256, 2. successes in new computing paradigms such as a large scale quantum computer using Grover's algorithm. 3. or turning the local galactic cluster into computronium for SHA-256 miners. Although at that point we have bigger problems. =) If you think SHA-256 will not be broken anytime soon then that suggests that you believe that mining difficulty increases will slow down.
- agumonkey 7y agosomeone tried a basic version of this https://www.engadget.com/2018/03/09/qarnot-qc1-cryptocurrency-heater-rig/?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly9kdWNrZHVja2dvLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAAL2A2AcW0bOZQYprugtZPIh_oVXvMmyzk6bDrPPgAvpT2otUyi-V4JAf8l3ivRss-o73TPnnMpDnxhz-bXgCJE-73tzV_Ue_1uxJ5TRR2DLsj2rWogjVdhgc1fmIyrJpN06xxobFovi8Z5mD2Xs5UCqgcsc1Kr37I3TgOYNp9_c https://www.engadget.com/2018/03/09/qarnot-qc1-cryptocurrenc...