4 ms·
TBH I don't see much of a bubble by these metrics. My indicators for "not in a bubble" are: 1. New grads are more interested in getting a job at a big company
by nostrademons 7y ago
TBH I don't see much of a bubble by these metrics. My indicators for "not in a bubble" are:
1. New grads are more interested in getting a job at a big company than in getting a job at a hot startup.
2. Fundraising requires revenue.
3. There is a constant negative press cycle around the industry.
4. People are moving out of Silicon Valley.
5. CEOs from the last bubble are getting indicted.
All of these are present today. Meanwhile, out of the article's list, the only bubble indicator I see is that Apple, Facebook, Google, and Amazon have all built shiny new headquarters. Tech P/Es are incredibly low compared to the general market (Apple is at 14 vs. the market's 25 or so), and the market P/E is not out of line with interest rates (P/E of 25 implies a real rate of return of about 4%, vs. about 2% for Treasuries. Mark Zuckerburg and Larry Page are too busy raising kids to either attend to their companies or be celebrities, Tim Cook is busy running his company, and Jeff Bezos is busy getting divorced. Haven't noticed any particular CEO fashion. People are looking to grey-haired figures for leadership, not young people. Six-figure tech salaries are just inflation: there's money (real money, not bubble-money) in tech, and intense competition for employees, and so that filters down to wages.
If anything, the real tech bubble burst in 2015 with the unraveling of Theranos, Zenefits, and Uber, and we've been in tech recession since. 2015 also seemed to be peak Silicon Valley rent increases, and the last time you could raise capital on just an idea. There was a mini-bubble in crypto in 2017, but that also popped, and the dominant zeitgeist today is complaints about how shitty life is, how there's no growth anywhere, and how we're on the precipice of a revolution, civil war, environmental catastrophe, dictatorship, or all 4.
- ummonk 7y agoYup. There are plenty of signs for a general economic recession in the US, but tech specifically doesn't seem overvalued in comparison, and we're in a state of anything but irrational exuberance in terms of attitudes towards the tech industry and unprofitable startups.
- m0zg 7y ago>> There are plenty of signs for a general economic recession in the US Out of curiosity, what "signs" are you referring to?
- coldtea 7y agoEconomists have warned the recent slowdown experienced by the U.S. economy carries with it "the unmistakable whiff of a recession." https://www.newsweek.com/economic-recession-2019-us-economy-gdp-trade-war-china-donald-trump-1437258 https://www.newsweek.com/economic-recession-2019-us-economy-... "US recession risk rises as trade tensions with China remain unresolved" https://www.foxbusiness.com/economy/us-recession-risk-rises-with-trade-tensions-uncertainty https://www.foxbusiness.com/economy/us-recession-risk-rises-... "Morgan Stanley says economy is on ‘recession watch’ as bond market flashes warning" https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/28/morgan-stanley-says-economy-on-recession-watch-amid-bond-warning.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/28/morgan-stanley-says-economy-...
- ccffph 7y agoPeople have been saying this since 2010.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ummonk 7y agoInverted yield curve, corporate profit margins starting to shrink, cost of hiring going up due to wages hitting rock bottom, and the likelihood of a quick resolution to the trade war becoming less and less likely. On the flip side, housing prices look strong (though that might have more to do with undersupply than strong demand) and consumer confidence is still high. If one or both of these start dropping, that would be an even bigger indicator that we are close to recession.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- benj111 7y agoWhile Apple is often deemed to be a 'tech' company, theres tech companies and tech companies. Whilst it might share many similarities with Uber for example, there are important differences and I think in this context saying there isn't a bubble because Apple is sensibly priced is missing the point. Apple isn't high growth, its making a profit, its business model doesn't depend on a non existent or unproven concept. Also I don't think Ubers valuation peaked in 2015 either? They seem to have been raising funds on a $50/60bn valuation in 2015, v $85bn when they floated.
- mrosett 7y agoUber’s share price hasn’t increased since 2016 (or maybe 2015? On mobile.) The increase in valuation is essentially equal to the cash they’ve raised since then - 30 billion or so including a big chunk in the IPO.
- benj111 7y agoI'm still not sure lack of growth == crash. I'm trying to reason whether what you say is actually correct. I mean if I have (loss making) company worth $1, with $1 in the bank, then raise $10 spend that on 'growth', 1 year later I have a (loss making) company worth $11, with $1 in the bank. It has increased in 'value', non of the shareholders are seeing the benefit though. I definitely don't think you could say there was a crash though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]