3 ms·
I think one of the main issues with the F&P experiment was that the Nobel committee was too quick to award them the Nobel Prize If they had waited a year or tw
by raverbashing 7y ago
I think one of the main issues with the F&P experiment was that the Nobel committee was too quick to award them the Nobel Prize
If they had waited a year or two then everything would have calmed down by then (and no award, of course) and less hype about the experiments.
> We should not too quickly judge, and thereby alienate, scientists who make controversial claims. The ridicule that was sometimes directed at Fleischmann and Pons was bound to make them double down. When researchers turn out to have been mistaken, they must be allowed a way back without disgrace.
Great quote
- simonh 7y agoI don't believe a Nobel Prize was awarded for that research, and can't find any mention of it. Which award are you referring to?
- raverbashing 7y agoI stand corrected! I think it was some kind of Mandela effect of my part Nevertheless, the hype was very high at the time.
- scottlocklin 7y agoPons, Fleischman and their university were responsible for creating a bunch of media hype and releasing the information to the press before publishing (Jones too). The author of the nature article kinda forgot to mention that somehow; that should be the real lesson of this -the media sucks at reporting anything relevant in the sciences (and everything else). People in our physics department had tested it and dismissed the claims almost immediately. It wasn't rocket science.
- kbutler 7y agoPons, Fleischman and the university blew it, on both the science (didn't measure neutrons, which are the signature of fusion) and the press (pumped the hype without the science). Jones was much more reserved, and discussed with the press only as a result of the media attention https://www.deseretnews.com/article/40134/FUSION---BYU-PHYSICS-RESEARCHER-BREAKS-SILENCE-ON-A-SIMILAR-NUCLEAR-BREAKTHROUGH.html https://www.deseretnews.com/article/40134/FUSION---BYU-PHYSI... """ But Jones downplays any comparison to his work with such historical breakthroughs as the invention of the light bulb or the hydrogen bomb. "We have a lot more work ahead of us," he said. "We need to have some patience and do the scientific groundwork before we jump to too many conclusions." """