5 ms·
This seems like a generational thing but I have never met someone my age or younger that thinks that 3/5 or a 'C' is average. How people like me give ratings.
by Spivak 7y ago
This seems like a generational thing but I have never met someone my age or younger that thinks that 3/5 or a 'C' is average.
How people like me give ratings.
5/5 - No problems
4/5 - Minor problems
3/5 - Major problems satisfied
2/5 - Major problems unsatisfied
1/5 - Horrible
How average ratings are interpreted:
4-5: Excellent
3.5-4: Okay
<3.5:Terrible
This pretty much mirrors how my grades were given in school.
But how I actually give ratings is 5/5 regardless of problems as long as the service was delivered and 4/5 if not because I have anxiety. I couldn't bare to get a bad rating at my job after a mistake so I don't do it to others.
- stordoff 7y agoAlso _regional_. Mirroring how my grades were given as school would be >40% - pass, > 80% - exceptional. Example grade boundaries[1]: 71/180, or 39.4% - pass; 88/180, or 48.9% - a strong pass[2]. Top grade is 147/180, or 81.7%. [1] https://qualifications.pearson.com/content/dam/pdf/Support/Grade-boundaries/GCSE/1806-GCSE-9-1-Subject-Grade-Boundaries.pdf https://qualifications.pearson.com/content/dam/pdf/Support/G... [2] https://www.aqa.org.uk/about-us/what-we-do/policy/gcse-and-a-level-changes/9-to-1 https://www.aqa.org.uk/about-us/what-we-do/policy/gcse-and-a...
- Jach 7y agoI must be like you too for 5-point ratings. However on Uber I changed my system to: "A ride happened." -- 5 stars "I don't think this driver should be driving anyone anymore." -- 1 star. I've also reluctantly started giving minor tips in the app depending on whether my own rating is trending down or not, since drivers can and do rate riders lower for not tipping. (They have to rate before they take another ride, but they can retroactively rerate.)
- walterbell 7y agoUX pattern-driven tipping pressure is gradually normalizing a "voluntary" (but not really since you are extorted via ratings) layer of non-progressive consumption taxes. There are now apps and other point-of-sale interfaces which default to 20% for "tips". Nice way to lower labor costs by outsourcing a voluntary fee to your customers, but this mostly destroys the signal/feedback value of the tip and rating. Do the nudge crowd know they are engaging in semantic pollution, e.g. diluting the value of the data they are spending millions to collect, process and analyze.
- JohnFen 7y ago> Do the nudge crowd know they are engaging in semantic pollution Perhaps more importantly, do they care?
- leetcrew 7y ago> This seems like a generational thing but I have never met someone my age or younger that thinks that 3/5 or a 'C' is average. I think it's related to school grading systems. anything less than an 'A' means you did something wrong. I remember when I had my first professional performance review, my manager asked us all to fill out the form ourselves and then discuss the difference between our ratings and his rating of us during the review itself. fresh out of undergrad, I gave myself mostly 5/5s and a couple 4/5s where I thought I needed improvement. I was momentarily shocked when I saw he had given me mostly 3s and a few 4s. he chuckled and explained that the company had very high expectations for software devs and that I wouldn't be getting any 5/5s in my first six months on the job unless I happened to be steve wozniak in the body of a 22 year old.
- Slartie 7y agoBut isn't school grading the exact opposite? Of course anything less than A means you did something wrong. But the test expects you to do something wrong! Failing to complete some of the tasks correctly is normal, expected and exactly what almost all students end up doing, at least semi-regularly. We are imperfect humans after all, not robots. It's the same with services like Uber driving. There's always room for improvement, I expect the driver to make some "mistakes". Not the kind of life-threatening mistakes, of course, but more like "he could have been 30 seconds faster if he hadn't driven so sluggish" or "she may have treated my luggage with a little more care". And stuff like that is perfectly acceptable, at least as long as it doesn't all happen in the same ride. But a perfect, 5/5 ride must not contain any aspect at all that could have been improved by the driver in order to justify it's rating, and I haven't seen many of those.
- leetcrew 7y agoeveryone has different experiences in school of course, but at the two undergrad institutions I attended it was pretty much always the case that aptitude for the subject combined with a reasonable effort (ie, turning in completed homework and some studying for exams) would result in an A for the class. only the kids who totally slacked off or were in the wrong major would get Cs or worse.
- 7y ago
- JohnFen 7y ago> 5/5 - No problems 4/5 - Minor problems 3/5 - Major problems satisfied 2/5 - Major problems unsatisfied 1/5 - Horrible But that makes it impossible to indicate when something is great.
- thsbsgvd 7y agoIt's a fucking Uber ride. I just want to be taken from point A to point B with no problems. Not have my dick sucked along the way. For what passes as acceptable customer service these days, having something go smoothly without an issue is a damn miracle.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]