I don't want to argue about the specifics with you. You asked us what we think, and based on the brief information you gave us, I told you my first impression.

I don't want to argue about the specifics with you. You asked us what we think, and based on the brief information you gave us, I told you my first impression. I am sure you will discuss the whole plot in much more detail with your future collaborators, and perhaps with other friends and acquaintances too - see what feedback they give you. I wish you all the best for the project!