3 ms·
there are overhead elevated train tracks, and they work just fine No, they don't. They add a massive amount of noise and other pollution to the city, and bloc
by reaperducer 7y ago
there are overhead elevated train tracks, and they work just fine
No, they don't. They add a massive amount of noise and other pollution to the city, and block light and air, turning normal city streets into seedy alleys. (Ex: Wabash before the recent renovation)
They seem a lot cheaper to build and maintain than tunnels
Build, probably. Maintain, no. The elevated structures require a ton of maintenance that is ongoing constantly because they're exposed to weather, vandals, and other external forces.
- rayiner 7y agoThese are electric trains—what pollution? Noise isn’t much higher once you’re even a block away. And light and air is a matter of setbacks. Lake and Wells are hardly seedy alleys. There is more light standing right under an L track than in NYC.
- reaperducer 7y agoThese are electric trains—what pollution I suspect you've never been in a subway tunnel and noticed all the grime and dirt spewed all over the walls and ceiling by electric trains. Noise isn’t much higher once you’re even a block away Now I know you've never been in a city with an elevated train system. I once lived nine blocks away from an elevated train, and I could hear it all day and all night. And light and air is a matter of setbacks You can't set back a building that's already built, and you can't take away air rights from a property owner without massive compensation. There is more light standing right under an L track than in NYC More is not the same as optimal. Why should any of the public's light and air be removed if it's not necessary?
- rayiner 7y agoI lived in Chicago for four years. I’ve walked under the L hundreds of times. It’s fine. And it is necessary. The alternative to a cheaper above-ground line isn’t a subway. Usually, it’s no rail at all.
- reaperducer 7y agoI lived in Chicago more than twice as long, and directly in the Loop for 90% of that time, not out in the neighborhoods. I lived for a year directly next to the Lake/Wells junction. I know about L noise.
- Touche 7y agoIn like 3 replies you've went from "elevated trains are as good as subways" to "elevated trains are better than nothing". The noise is the thing. In New York you can stand directly over a subway station and not even know it, in Chicago you always know when you're with in a few blocks of a line.
- jcranmer 7y ago> Now I know you've never been in a city with an elevated train system. I once lived nine blocks away from an elevated train, and I could hear it all day and all night. It is possible to build elevated rail that is much quieter than Chicago's and NYC's systems, so Chicago shouldn't be held up as an example of how noisy elevated systems have to be.
- djsumdog 7y agoPlus Chicago's is super old. Use the newer Orange Line and it's much quieter. The high speed intercity/commuter rails in The Netherlands are also super quiet (and massive!). They move a lot of people too!