3 ms·
Wrong. Most wholesalers don't get charged entitlements by the stores. Damaged items are not entitlements, they're straight contractual issues and especially wi
by gamblor956 7y ago
Wrong.
Most wholesalers don't get charged entitlements by the stores. Damaged items are not entitlements, they're straight contractual issues and especially with foodstuffs, wholesale contracts may specify that up to a % of goods may arrive damaged and in unsaleable condition.
Marketing support is negotiated by brands seeking premium shelf space, or end-of-aisle placements or in-store marketing.
Liability is not an entitlement. Ever. It's something you work out between legal departments if you get sued under product liability laws.
My sources? My clients include about a dozen clothing retailers, 20ish restaurant chains, 3 big box stores, and a number of smaller grocery chains.
It's pretty clear you have zero understanding of retail business logistics and you should consider revising your comments to reflect that.
EDIT: After reading your other comments, it's pretty clear that you think that a manufacturer, i.e., Alpha Cola, sells to a Walmart shopper and pays Walmart for this opportunity. That's not how retail works. Walmart pays Alpha for a bunch of soda, and as part of this Alpha may negotiate an offset (what you've been calling an entitlement) for marketing support like in-store displays and premium shelf space alongside Code.
BUT BUT BUT in many situations, this is actually reversed: for example, for beer and convenience stores, the store agrees to give the beer premium space and in-store displays and may even agree to cover the costs. And in my example above, Coke usually wouldn't pay a store anything for marketing support--instead, the store would agree to provide unpaid marketing support to Coke for the privilege of carrying Coke's products. The store then uses Coke as a loss-leader to get people into the store.
- themagician 7y agoOh man, the cringe. Most do. You can’t sell to Amazon or Walmart retail without entitlements. They are literally called entitlements. Try to establish a relationship with a big box store without agreeing to entitlements—it’s damn near impossible. Maybe massive brands like Nike can do it, I don’t know. Damage is typically an entitlement. It’s usually called “DA” or “Damage Allocation”. It’s around 2-6%, depending on category. It’s usually deducted from each payment, or sometimes aggregated and deducted separately. Many companies will take a marketing entitlement. Amazon Retail does this at 10%. It is negotiable, but depends on category. Most but e-commerce retailers now have an entitlement like this. Marketing support for product/campaign specific needs is separate. “Liability” will sometimes take the form of an entitlement for high risk goods. For example, gift cards, fragile goods, and jewelry. It’s never called liability explicitly, but will have a variety of names depending on industry or category. I don’t doubt your clients, but I’m guessing you work at a level that would not expose you to this stuff. Ask your clients about their entitlements, if they are willing to share that information with you. It might be eye opening for you.
- gamblor956 7y agoI'm looking at a recent contract that was signed by a large national brand and a large national retailer right now and literally none of what you said is in there. You keep using the wrong terms for standardized language (for example, you keep referring to breakage as "liability" even though both have very different meanings and keep referring to a number of very different things as "entitlements"), so I'm pretty certain I also have a better exposure to the legal and practical underpinnings of the retail market than you do. I think I'll stick with my comments.
- themagician 7y agoThat’s pretty unusual. Also, you seem to be having trouble reading. Nowhere to I refer to breakage as liability. Take Amazon for example. On the platform side them call them “referral fees”. For risky items, where fraud and returns are higher, the fee that you pay Amazon for the privilege of selling to their customers is higher. Sometimes a lot higher. It’s going to be referred to as either an allowance or entitlement on the retail side. Allowances are specific allocations. Entitlements generally refer to all of the payments which a retailer is "entitled to" for the privilege of doing business with you, including allowances.
- dang 7y agoYou went way overboard into incivility in your comments in this thread. In fact, although I'm sure you didn't mean to be, you were repeatedly a jerk. That's sad, because you obviously know some things. We ban accounts that do that. Would you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here? That means being scrupulously respectful others, no matter how ignorant they are or you feel they are. If you know more, the thing to do is not to put down those who know less, but to explain some of what you know, so we can all learn.
- themagician 7y ago“EDIT: After reading your other comments, it's pretty clear that you think that a product maker, i.e., Alpha Cola, sells to a Walmart shopper and pays Walmart for this opportunity. That's not how retail works. Walmart pays Alpha for a bunch of soda, and as part of this Alpha may negotiate an offset (what you've been calling an entitlement) for marketing support like in-store displays and premium shelf space alongside Code.” It depends. With Walmart specifically It depends if it’s owned, dsv, or platform. Sometimes a manufacturer (that’s what we call them, not “product makers”) does sell to a Walmart shopper and pay Walmart for the opportunity. That’s what the Walmart Marketplace is. Same as the Amazon Marketplace. Even DSV contracts are now changing, as e-commerce retailers will have you ship items from your warehouse in their box with their tape. Walmart literally calls these either entitlements or allowances, it depends where (and when) you signed a contract with them.
- gamblor956 7y agoAh, the cringe. I just realized that you are conflating Walmart's retail operations with its online operations. They are two separate things, and are governed by different sets of practices and contracts. Walmart's physical/retail contracts don't have anything similar to what you've been calling entitlements except in the rare case. Everything else you've called an entitlement is simply decades of standard legal terms, generally straight of the Uniform Commercial Code, none of which are called entitlements. Bigger retailers like Walmart and Target do have "allowances" which are negotiated on a per-contract basis and thus their terms and scope vary by contract. Note: from what I've been able to determine, "entitlements" in the way you've been using them is a CRM term, it's not a term of general use in the law or retail industries.
- themagician 7y agoReally mate, you should take care to read more carefully. What you realize, what you are able to determine, whatever ideas you have of what’s normal and what’s not. I hope you at least learned something.