3 ms·
"Due process" is a legal standard that is present in US Constitutional amendments for a reason. Now obviously Uber is a private company and is currently legall
by crazygringo 7y ago
"Due process" is a legal standard that is present in US Constitutional amendments for a reason.
Now obviously Uber is a private company and is currently legally allowed to discriminate against customers with low ratings provided they are not discriminating along protected categories like race or gender.
BUT, ride-sharing apps tend to turn into natural monopolies or duopolies simply because of natural network effects, and effectively become part of a city's transportation system. I would argue that, with this, they should carry additional responsibilities to customers that a normal private company doesn't.
And one of them is that banning customers should involve "due process", e.g. standards for investigation, burden of proof, opportunity to contest, and resulting actions, e.g. a temporary suspension. A permanent ban should be reserved for only the most serious cases, e.g. where a customer has been convicted in a court of law for threatening violence and gone to prison. (And a temporary ban can be put in place while a court case in pending.)
A crowdsourced star rating is not due process. And with Uber and Lyft essentially part of public transport, this is a scary and deeply undemocratic path to go down.
In NYC it's illegal for a taxi not to pick someone up, because this can be the source of tremendous racial discrimination (and continues to be, despite its illegality). We don't want to let Uber do the same type of thing to another class of people.
- pageandrew 7y agoI agree with you on this. I find it difficult to imagine a scenario where this could reasonably be enforced, but I agree with the sentiment. I would also extend it to social media. Like Uber and Lyft have more or less become forms of public transport, Twitter, Facebook, etc have become the new "public square". Private companies being able to ban someone from the public square without due process seems to be a scary precedent as well.
- jtbayly 7y ago>A crowdsourced star rating is not due process. And with Uber and Lyft essentially part of public transport, this is a scary and deeply undemocratic path to go down. Actually, crowdsourcing is quite democratic. That's the problem. Due process protects against the ultimate form of democracy—a lynching.
- the_watcher 7y agoGiven that Uber already uses a pretty similar version of this system for drivers (it's based on star ratings as well), and riders are just as potentially biased as drivers, unless you have a problem with using ratings for eligibility on both the supply and demand side, this isn't a strong argument. The comparison with the taxi law is apples and oranges: a single taxi driver can make the unilateral decision to discriminate, while in Uber's system, it would require systemic discrimination across all of the drivers in a given city. While I'll grant that it's possible, if it reaches that point, there should be grounds for a lawsuit alleging disparate impact (which I believe is an established concept when applied to private businesses that was incorporated in the Warren Court years, although there's more gray area here, so I may be off the mark).
- crazygringo 7y agoIf Uber were considered an actual employer, and the US had stronger protections for employment (instead of at-will) then that would make sense -- there's a good argument it should be illegal to fire you merely because customers rate you badly because they don't like your hairstyle or where you come from. But I'm particularly basing my original argument on the fact that dispatch car services easily become a natural monopoly or duopoly, so customers don't have choice and they need to get around the city. Whereas driving is a relatively low-skill and low-paying job, of which there are many many others in our service economy -- tons and tons of service jobs. My point is that if you lose your job driving for Uber, you can find another decent-enough substitute job because there are literally thousands of companies hiring. If you get banned from riding Uber, there may be no good substitute because there are only a handful of public transportation options at most, and at a given time/place Uber might be the only one.
- ssambros 7y ago> Now obviously Uber is a private company No, they are not. Uber went public this month. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1543151/000119312519103850/d647752ds1.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1543151/000119312519...
- crazygringo 7y ago"Private" in the sense of "not government-owned". As opposed to public agencies such as the Post Office, or a quasi-public corporation such as Amtrak.
- bsder 7y ago> In NYC it's illegal for a taxi not to pick someone up, because this can be the source of tremendous racial discrimination (and continues to be, despite its illegality). We don't want to let Uber do the same type of thing to another class of people. Why do you believe this isn't in play already? I strongly suspect that passenger ratings strongly correlate to race. We already have LOTS of evidence in this thread that good ratings correlate to being female.