3 ms·
> Providing a single mother with a cash payment to fend for herself in an inflated housing market is not as effective as providing quality public housing. Givin
by legitster 7y ago
> Providing a single mother with a cash payment to fend for herself in an inflated housing market is not as effective as providing quality public housing. Giving people more money to fill up their cars is not as progressive as offering free public transport.
To me, this is actually an argument for UBI. A poor single mother deserves access to the same market of housing as everyone else! And public transit is great, but your living and employment options are super limited if that is your only choice.
Absolutely, we need to study how much social services would actually need to be offset. Perhaps free housing and buses are still valuable even with UBI. But having dual-class public and private options is not true progress.
It seems that in this author's view, a UBI is only a means to an end for tackling inequality, and doesn't believe the actual poverty alleviation aspects are of value. While I respect the point being made, I would argue that this in itself is a pretty privileged position.
- Mediterraneo10 7y ago> Public transit is great, but your living and employment options are super limited if that is your only choice. In most countries where UBI is even remotely a realistic possibility politically, public transit is just fine and how most people get to work. Indeed, for a single mother a personal car may well cost far more than the actual utility it provides. The USA is an odd one out in this respect.
- legitster 7y agoTrue, this is a US example (although I was surprised by how many European cities have competing private transit systems). But I stand by my point that prescribing people's needs robs them of important choices.
- Mediterraneo10 7y agoA car likely wouldn't be even a choice for a single mother without the state subsidizing car ownership indirectly
- TeMPOraL 7y agoWe should s/public transit/mass transit/ in these discussions. It's the efficiencies that matter, not who is providing the service for the city.
- cwkoss 7y agoAuthor is defending the pork that funded this article.