41 ms·
What does real-time surveillance mean to you? You're asking a loaded question. Of course they have access to some real-time data re users.
by cblades 7y ago
What does real-time surveillance mean to you?
You're asking a loaded question. Of course they have access to some real-time data re users.
- vokep 7y agoThis. No matter what they actually do, they'd be idiots to reply to this, which is why we won't see a reply from them. Doesn't really say anything meaningful.
- chmars 7y agoMy own definition does not matter. Swiss law matters: 'The order may require real-time surveillance to be carried out and the handover of the retained secondary data of telecommunications from past communications (retroactive surveillance).' https://www.admin.ch/opc/en/classified-compilation/20122728/index.html#a26 https://www.admin.ch/opc/en/classified-compilation/20122728/... The question is not whether ProtonMail has access to user data. (They have, you are absolutely right.) They question is if they perform real-time surveillance, i.e., lawful surveillance (whether voluntarily or not).
- cblades 7y agoSo you're asking if they'll comply with legal court orders? They've already said they will.