7 ms·
> If I sell paper cups to Walmart they will take a 12-17% cut for “entitlements”. I can’t compete with the white label house brand on price that doesn’t have th
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> If I sell paper cups to Walmart they will take a 12-17% cut for “entitlements”. I can’t compete with the white label house brand on price that doesn’t have those entitlements.
The store is obviously going to make a margin to pay for the costs of operating the store. The store brand can't avoid those costs by being in-house because it still needs shelf space and stock clerks etc.
This is different than with Apple because it's actually plausible that it costs "12-17%" to have a physical store with physical goods in it, but a 30% margin for online distribution is just blatant monopoly rent. Which comes from the fact that other stores compete with Walmart in retailing paper cups but Apple prohibits anybody from competing with them in retailing iOS apps.
> This is why when you go into pretty much any grocery, electronics, automotive or whatever store the house brand is always at least a dollar cheaper.
The house brand is cheaper because it has less brand recognition, which in turn is because it has less expense in building a brand through advertising and long-term quality control. This is why, despite the products often being completely identical, many people will pay more for the one they're familiar with and not have to take the chance that the store brand isn't as good (even if it usually is).
- themagician 7y agoWrong. The retail store makes its margin based on the spread between wholesale and retail price. They mark it up. Typically, 50%. Entitlements sit on top of that. They are usually broken out between logistics, damage, marketing support, liability, referral, platform, etc..They average around 15%, but it depends on category. Amazon.com calls it a “referral fee” for marketplace sellers. No physical store there. This is strictly a fee you pay to access their customers. Same as Apple. It’s the fee you pay to access their customer base, with credit card and billing info, and have them handle the transaction and associated liability. It’s pretty clear you have zero understanding of retail business logistics.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Entitlements sit on top of that. They are usually broken out between logistics, damage, marketing support, liability, referral, platform, etc. "Entitlements" are just a component of overall margins. Breaking them out separately doesn't win you anything because the store brand still needs to pay its pro rata share of the cost to cover those things. > Amazon.com calls it a “referral fee” for marketplace sellers. No physical store there. These is strictly a fee you pay to access their customers. Yet notice that their fees are typically something like 13% rather than 30%, and they're still dealing in physical goods and then have to contend with the sellers who send an empty box rather than a product etc.
- themagician 7y agoNo, they aren’t and no they don’t. Again you really don’t know what you’re talking about. Save yourself the embarrassment and delete your comments. The Apple fee also drops to 15% after a year. It’s 30% for the first year because of the amount of fraud and chargebacks. Same is true for other high-risk categories everywhere else, like jewelry and gift cards.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> No, they aren’t and no they don’t. "No" is not an argument. > The Apple fee also drops to 15% after a year. It’s 30% for the first year because of the amount of fraud and chargebacks You're referring to subscriptions, but at that point it's still outrageously high precisely because they no longer have to worry about that stuff and it's only a matter of transaction processing for which a 15% fee is still completely unreasonable.
- themagician 7y agoThere's no argument. You are just wrong. And 15% isn't that high. 15% is what Amazon charges for selling physical books on Amazon.com. That doesn't include shipping, handling, or returns. That's literally just the "transaction processing" fee as you call it and the ability to exist on their store.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> There's no argument. You are just wrong. "You are just wrong" is not an argument. > And 15% isn't that high. 15% is what Amazon charges for selling physical books on Amazon.com. Physical books are not digital subscriptions. 15% is very high for long-term subscriptions because, as you point out, they don't have a high chargeback rate etc. By comparison, for example, Stripe charges 3.3% to process recurring subscriptions.
- gamblor956 7y agoWrong. Most wholesalers don't get charged entitlements by the stores. Damaged items are not entitlements, they're straight contractual issues and especially with foodstuffs, wholesale contracts may specify that up to a % of goods may arrive damaged and in unsaleable condition. Marketing support is negotiated by brands seeking premium shelf space, or end-of-aisle placements or in-store marketing. Liability is not an entitlement. Ever. It's something you work out between legal departments if you get sued under product liability laws. My sources? My clients include about a dozen clothing retailers, 20ish restaurant chains, 3 big box stores, and a number of smaller grocery chains. It's pretty clear you have zero understanding of retail business logistics and you should consider revising your comments to reflect that. EDIT: After reading your other comments, it's pretty clear that you think that a manufacturer, i.e., Alpha Cola, sells to a Walmart shopper and pays Walmart for this opportunity. That's not how retail works. Walmart pays Alpha for a bunch of soda, and as part of this Alpha may negotiate an offset (what you've been calling an entitlement) for marketing support like in-store displays and premium shelf space alongside Code. BUT BUT BUT in many situations, this is actually reversed: for example, for beer and convenience stores, the store agrees to give the beer premium space and in-store displays and may even agree to cover the costs. And in my example above, Coke usually wouldn't pay a store anything for marketing support--instead, the store would agree to provide unpaid marketing support to Coke for the privilege of carrying Coke's products. The store then uses Coke as a loss-leader to get people into the store.
- themagician 7y agoOh man, the cringe. Most do. You can’t sell to Amazon or Walmart retail without entitlements. They are literally called entitlements. Try to establish a relationship with a big box store without agreeing to entitlements—it’s damn near impossible. Maybe massive brands like Nike can do it, I don’t know. Damage is typically an entitlement. It’s usually called “DA” or “Damage Allocation”. It’s around 2-6%, depending on category. It’s usually deducted from each payment, or sometimes aggregated and deducted separately. Many companies will take a marketing entitlement. Amazon Retail does this at 10%. It is negotiable, but depends on category. Most but e-commerce retailers now have an entitlement like this. Marketing support for product/campaign specific needs is separate. “Liability” will sometimes take the form of an entitlement for high risk goods. For example, gift cards, fragile goods, and jewelry. It’s never called liability explicitly, but will have a variety of names depending on industry or category. I don’t doubt your clients, but I’m guessing you work at a level that would not expose you to this stuff. Ask your clients about their entitlements, if they are willing to share that information with you. It might be eye opening for you.
- threeseed 7y agoI don't think you understand house brands. They exist because they have great brand recognition far better than most third party products. And the reason they are cheaper is because they sign bigger, low margin deals with suppliers who would be scared of undercutting their existing products.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> They exist because they have great brand recognition far better than most third party products. Your claim is that Athletic Works (a Walmart brand for athletic apparel) has better brand recognition than Nike and Great Value cola has better brand recognition than Coca-Cola? > And the reason they are cheaper is because they sign bigger, low margin deals with suppliers who would be scared of undercutting their existing products. Again, your claim is that Great Value brand sells more cola than Coca-Cola? What's your explanation for why many people nonetheless buy the more expensive non-store brand?
- gamblor956 7y agoI don't think you understand house brands. A house brand is just a white-label product sold with minimal marketing other than shelf space in a store. The difference between a house brand and a branded products is marketing spend. General Mills, for example, supplies most of the store-branded cereal products alongside its own, more-expensive/heavily marketed brands. Most US liquor is supplied by the same handful of distilleries, and most "craft" liquor is actually just the same stuff with a different label. Amazon, for example, has more than 100 house brands. But you wouldn't know what they are...since Amazon doesn't advertise them anywhere except on their own website. And they definitely don't have better recognition or outsell their branded counterparts. (Raise your hand if you've purchased a Nike product in the last few years. Now raise your hand if you've ever purchased a Peak Velocity product?)
- xvector 7y ago> > If I sell paper cups to Walmart they will take a 12-17% cut for “entitlements”. I can’t compete with the white label house brand on price that doesn’t have those entitlements. > The store is obviously going to make a margin to pay for the costs of operating the store. The store brand can't avoid those costs by being in-house because it still needs shelf space and stock clerks etc. Your implication here is that Walmart's 12-17% charge is fine because that covers the costs of operating the store. Ignoring the fact that 12-17% are in massive excess of the operational costs, your implication is then that storefronts should not make a profit. Which is frankly a ridiculous notion. Storefronts should make a profit, or there is little point to their existence. The App Store is not a public service. It is a privately-owned storefront. As long as we live in a capitalist society, demanding that the App Store cede its profits is absurd.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> your implication is then that storefronts should not make a profit. No it isn't. It's that they should operate in a competitive environment so that the profits are the ones produced by a free market without unreasonable barriers to entry rather than being monopoly rents.
- xvector 7y ago> It's that they should operate in a competitive environment Apple operates in a competitive environment. There are hundreds of other options to choose from. Unless you mean the App Store should be competitive within the iPhone. Why? How many layers deep do we need to ensure a perfectly competitive and open environment? If I put an app (say, a VM) on the App Store that has its own operating system and contained app store, am I now obligated to allow people to put their own app store in my app? > without unreasonable barriers to entry In what world is 30% "unreasonable?" Companies have the option of going to the App Store. There is no obligation for a company to use the App Store. They are not being cut out of the smartphone industry if they don't use the App Store. Apple is not a monopoly here - there are other options than the iPhone for you to sell your service on.
- 7y ago