4 ms·
> You can choose android. That's a false choice. That's like saying "don't like Walmart? Then leave the US and move to Europe!" The choices aren't equivalen
by jedberg 7y ago
> You can choose android.
That's a false choice. That's like saying "don't like Walmart? Then leave the US and move to Europe!" The choices aren't equivalent. Each have their pluses and minuses, but the choice of Android or Apple should not dictate which retail outlet you get to use.
In the real world, the consumer can chose the easy retail outlet (Walmart, Amazon) or they can choose a harder to use/access outlet, but at least they get the choice. With Apple, you can't choose your retail outlet, and that is by Apple's design.
- themagician 7y agoThere is really no consumer issue here. If you want to use Spotify you can. You can download it and use it all you want on your Apple device. You can use it on the web, and you can even download an app. If you want to buy Spotify premium, you can! You can buy it directly from Spotify. If you want to buy it from the App Store you can! But Spotify has decided they don’t want to sell it on the App Store because Apple’s entitlements/platform fee/referral fee/whatever you want to call it is too high.
- jedberg 7y ago> If you want to buy Spotify premium, you can! You can buy it directly from Spotify. Only if you independently know that it exists. They can't link out to their web store. Apple can though.
- themagician 7y agoThey can let people know it exists through any number of ways. They just can’t bundle that advertisement explicitly into product they sell on the App Store. But they actually do (in the radio spots). They just can’t do it in plain text. Again, this is can be true in other places in retail as well. Walmart may not be happy if I slap a giant sticker on my box that says, “Buy direct from us for less!” Sometimes the stores don’t care. Sometimes they do. If they don’t like it they reserve the right to kick you off the shelf or ask you to remove it.
- jedberg 7y agoYou keep conflating Apple's store with Apple's hardware. All of Apple's policies would be fine if they allowed any store on their hardware, because then other stores could have other policies. But since Apple doesn't allow other stores, it's not the same as regular retail, because the consumer can't choose another store with better policies.
- snowwrestler 7y agoNo, you're conflating "Apple has a monopoly on app stores in general" with "Apple has a monopoly on what they sell to their customers." The former is an anti-trust concern; the latter is just the basics of how a retail operation works. Which themagician has been patiently trying to explain. I understand that a lot of people really want to use Apple phones, because they feel that they are superior to Android phones. But this is not a monopoly, it's literally how the market is supposed to work. You can't walk into a Walmart physical store and ask to see their embedded Target store. Hardware, software, and inventory are bundled into an experience by every retailer in existence.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jedberg 7y agoBut there isn't a duopoly of retailers. There are many to choose from.
- snowwrestler 7y agoAs far as I know, duopolies are only illegal if the two companies collude to distort the market.
- treis 7y ago>No, you're conflating "Apple has a monopoly on app stores in general" with "Apple has a monopoly on what they sell to their customers." The former is an anti-trust concern; the latter is just the basics of how a retail operation works. Which themagician has been patiently trying to explain. Apple is using its position in one market (phone hardware sales) to exclude competition in another (app sales). It's a text book example of an antitrust violation. >Hardware, software, and inventory are bundled into an experience by every retailer in existence. No, they aren't. You don't have to buy software to run on a Mac exclusively from Apple, for example.
- threeseed 7y agoThe retail store analogy is really unhelpful and makes no sense. There are significant security and privacy concerns in allowing third party App Stores and it opens Apple up to significant legal risk. For example if the other stores weren't as vigilant then you could have rampant piracy, apps with illegal content or apps that siphon user data.
- jedberg 7y agoHow would Apple be open to any liability? They don't have any liability when they allow you to download whatever you want to your Mac laptop. It would be exactly the same.
- tpush 7y ago> [...] you could have rampant piracy, apps with illegal content or apps that siphon user data. That's already the case today in form of the Web, yet obviously Apple is not restricting which websites a user can browse to. In general, this whole 'third-party stores are a security risk etc.' doesn't hold any water under inspection. Security and privacy come from the sandboxed nature of apps running on iOS, and of course Apple themselves determine what APIs are available and under what circumstances an app can access what data about a device or user. This is all independent from wherever a user installs an app.
- scarface74 7y agoWell, how did sideloading FortNite work on Android. It exposed users to a vulnerability. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/08/fortnites-android-vulnerability-leads-to-googleepic-games-spat/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/08/fortnites-android-vu...
- xvector 7y ago> That's a false choice. That's like saying "don't like Walmart? Then leave the US and move to Europe!" No, it's like saying "don't like Walmart? Feel free to leave the store and look for a Costco."
- jedberg 7y agoExcept that's where it breaks down, because your Apple hardware is the "country" you live in. There are no other stores in your "country".
- xvector 7y agoAbsolutely not. It is not nearly so restrictive as moving to a different country. Apple and the App Store is just one option in the massive free market - and a minority option at that. Drawing a line between the hardware of the iPhone and the software of the App Store is arbitrary. From Apple's point of view, they are one. And there are other options out there if you do not want an iPhone with the App Store. Complaining that an alternative App Store should be implemented is like complaining that iOS should also be optional. Why is Apple required to implement additional features and give up market share when the are not a monopoly in the first place?
- scarface74 7y agoSo people choose which game console they want all of the time based on the available features and software. Each console maker also tightly controls what can be distributed either online or physically. I fail to see how choosing Android is a false choice when 80%+ of smart phone users do exactly that.