9 ms·
They still didn't address Spotify's main complaint: That Apple Music can charge less because they don't have to pay a 30% commission to Apple. So they have an
by jedberg 7y ago
They still didn't address Spotify's main complaint: That Apple Music can charge less because they don't have to pay a 30% commission to Apple. So they have an unfair advantage of being able to charge 30% less even if their costs are identical.
Also Apple's use of private APIs gives them an unfair advantage. So sure, there are competing apps in each category, but they can't ever be as good as the Apple app.
- themagician 7y agoSpotify’s main complaint is pretty stupid because everyone has this problem in retail. It’s not unique to Spotify. If I sell paper cups to Walmart they will take a 12-17% cut for “entitlements”. I can’t compete with the white label house brand on price that doesn’t have those entitlements. The house brand can also operate on a razor thin margin because that product isn’t critical to their business. This is why when you go into pretty much any grocery, electronics, automotive or whatever store the house brand is always at least a dollar cheaper.
- jedberg 7y agoBut in retail I can choose a different store. For Apple, there is exactly one store.
- themagician 7y agoYou can choose android. Or use the browser. If you want to sell in the Apple store, to Apple customers, you play by Apple’s rules. Same for Walmart or Amazon. The house always has the upper hand. If you don’t want to sell to Apple customers, you can sell direct. There is really nothing unique about this. Anyone who has a business in retail is familiar with this problem. Want to sell on Amazon to Amazon customers? 8-20%. Want to sell in Walmart to Walmart customers? 12-17%. I wish it weren’t so, I really do. I’d be 15% richer overnight (probably more, as I’d be more cost competitive). If we decide that these sort of platform fees are illegal that would actually be HUGE and redistribute massive amounts of wealth from gatekeepers to smaller businesses.
- jedberg 7y ago> You can choose android. That's a false choice. That's like saying "don't like Walmart? Then leave the US and move to Europe!" The choices aren't equivalent. Each have their pluses and minuses, but the choice of Android or Apple should not dictate which retail outlet you get to use. In the real world, the consumer can chose the easy retail outlet (Walmart, Amazon) or they can choose a harder to use/access outlet, but at least they get the choice. With Apple, you can't choose your retail outlet, and that is by Apple's design.
- themagician 7y agoThere is really no consumer issue here. If you want to use Spotify you can. You can download it and use it all you want on your Apple device. You can use it on the web, and you can even download an app. If you want to buy Spotify premium, you can! You can buy it directly from Spotify. If you want to buy it from the App Store you can! But Spotify has decided they don’t want to sell it on the App Store because Apple’s entitlements/platform fee/referral fee/whatever you want to call it is too high.
- jedberg 7y ago> If you want to buy Spotify premium, you can! You can buy it directly from Spotify. Only if you independently know that it exists. They can't link out to their web store. Apple can though.
- themagician 7y agoThey can let people know it exists through any number of ways. They just can’t bundle that advertisement explicitly into product they sell on the App Store. But they actually do (in the radio spots). They just can’t do it in plain text. Again, this is can be true in other places in retail as well. Walmart may not be happy if I slap a giant sticker on my box that says, “Buy direct from us for less!” Sometimes the stores don’t care. Sometimes they do. If they don’t like it they reserve the right to kick you off the shelf or ask you to remove it.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> If I sell paper cups to Walmart they will take a 12-17% cut for “entitlements”. I can’t compete with the white label house brand on price that doesn’t have those entitlements. The store is obviously going to make a margin to pay for the costs of operating the store. The store brand can't avoid those costs by being in-house because it still needs shelf space and stock clerks etc. This is different than with Apple because it's actually plausible that it costs "12-17%" to have a physical store with physical goods in it, but a 30% margin for online distribution is just blatant monopoly rent. Which comes from the fact that other stores compete with Walmart in retailing paper cups but Apple prohibits anybody from competing with them in retailing iOS apps. > This is why when you go into pretty much any grocery, electronics, automotive or whatever store the house brand is always at least a dollar cheaper. The house brand is cheaper because it has less brand recognition, which in turn is because it has less expense in building a brand through advertising and long-term quality control. This is why, despite the products often being completely identical, many people will pay more for the one they're familiar with and not have to take the chance that the store brand isn't as good (even if it usually is).
- themagician 7y agoWrong. The retail store makes its margin based on the spread between wholesale and retail price. They mark it up. Typically, 50%. Entitlements sit on top of that. They are usually broken out between logistics, damage, marketing support, liability, referral, platform, etc..They average around 15%, but it depends on category. Amazon.com calls it a “referral fee” for marketplace sellers. No physical store there. This is strictly a fee you pay to access their customers. Same as Apple. It’s the fee you pay to access their customer base, with credit card and billing info, and have them handle the transaction and associated liability. It’s pretty clear you have zero understanding of retail business logistics.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Entitlements sit on top of that. They are usually broken out between logistics, damage, marketing support, liability, referral, platform, etc. "Entitlements" are just a component of overall margins. Breaking them out separately doesn't win you anything because the store brand still needs to pay its pro rata share of the cost to cover those things. > Amazon.com calls it a “referral fee” for marketplace sellers. No physical store there. These is strictly a fee you pay to access their customers. Yet notice that their fees are typically something like 13% rather than 30%, and they're still dealing in physical goods and then have to contend with the sellers who send an empty box rather than a product etc.
- gamblor956 7y agoIf I sell paper cups to Walmart they will take a 12-17% cut for “entitlements”. I can’t compete with the white label house brand on price that doesn’t have those entitlements. The house brand can also operate on a razor thin margin because that product isn’t critical to their business. This is why when you go into pretty much any grocery, electronics, automotive or whatever store the house brand is always at least a dollar cheaper. This argument is so much FUD. A paper cup company sells their cups to Walmart at wholesale prices. Walmart buys all the cups they sell in their stores, including the "Walmart brand" generic cups, and so "resells" them to the end customer. Because Walmart is "reselling" the cups, it can charge whatever it wants on whatever products it wants. Not even remotely the same thing to what Apple does: Apple just claims to be a transaction processor facilitating a direct sale between an app-maker and a customer. Except that Apple charges its competition 30% and itself nothing. They use to use this sort of scenario as the textbook example of antitrust violations. Antitrust enforcement fell out of favor in the West following the actions against Microsoft, but it looks like the EU is girding up to start enforcing it again.
- themagician 7y agoSomewhat fair if we are talking about Walmart stores. But Walmart.com still charges fees just to sell on there, and they don’t (necessarily) buy anything. Same for Amazon.com. If Apple’s policies are an antitrust violation then it will likely extend to Amazon, Walmart, and any other retailer that also sells their own product. It would also impact Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo. I’m not actually again inst that. I just find the Spotify case to be particularly weak.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 7y agoIf Apple’s policies are an antitrust violation then it will likely extend to Amazon, Walmart, and any other retailer that also sells their own product. It would also impact Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo. Amazon, Walmart.Com Marketplace...no. Because if you want to sell Physical Product X, you can sell on Amazon and Walmart.com. Or Ebay. Or your own website. You can't sell an iPhone app through the Google Store. Amazon has raised antitrust concerns, but they are very different from the ones facing Apple. Walmart.com hasn't raised any...because they aren't attempting to use their existing market position in physical retail to reduce competition in online retail. Microsoft, Sony, and Nintendo. No, because you can buy games for each console in physical stores, you don't have the same issue--none of these company's stores is the sole way to sell your game to a owner of that console. The Spotify case is may not be the strongest case, but it's just one of hundreds or thousands. And worse for Apple, Spotify is an EU company, and the EU is still very much in favor of enforcing antitrust laws. (I assume your reference to Shopify was a typo. Not sure what their beef with Apple is, if any.)
- pgm8705 7y agoYes. The fact that I still cannot listen to Spotify directly from my Apple Watch is so frustrating. I don't want to give in and switch to Apple Music, but it gets more tempting every day.
- saagarjha 7y ago> The fact that I still cannot listen to Spotify directly from my Apple Watch is so frustrating. I don’t see how this is Apple’s fault, though: Spotify should be able to write an app for watchOS.
- pgm8705 7y agoAccording to Spotify, they were not able to start developing an app until recently. They've finally released an app, but all it does is control the music playing from your phone. Source: https://www.timetoplayfair.com/timeline/ https://www.timetoplayfair.com/timeline/
- threeseed 7y agoOvercast managed to do this back in September last year. Hardly recently: https://9to5mac.com/2018/09/17/overcast-apple-watch-redesign-siri-shortcuts/ https://9to5mac.com/2018/09/17/overcast-apple-watch-redesign...
- treis 7y agoAnd when did Spotify release their app?
- chipotle_coyote 7y agoThe Overcast app can either control your phone or play podcasts that are "synced" to it, i.e., loaded onto the phone. At least from my reading of the WatchKit documentation, audio files playing from the watch must still be stored locally.
- saagarjha 7y ago
- ihuman 7y ago> That Apple Music can charge less because they don't have to pay a 30% commission to Apple I know this sounds stupid, but how do we know that Apple isn't taking a 30% cut and attributing it to app store revenue like the other 30% cuts everyone else gets?
- themagician 7y agoIt’s possible they are but also irrelevant. Apple can operate Apple Music at a razor thin, zero, or negative margin. It’s not critical to their business. Spotify can’t. This is true for any retail operation with its own house brand products. It’s why they are always cheaper, even if internally they treat the accounting the same as they would with an external vendor.
- toasterlovin 7y agoSpotify's problem is that they're a feature trying to be a product.
- ihuman 7y agoWhy can't a feature be a product if the implementation is good enough to stand on its own?
- themagician 7y agoClearly, it can’t.
- anoncake 7y agoThat is not a valid answer to a question starting with "why".
- toasterlovin 7y agoWhy weren't independent butchers and bakers able to compete with supermarkets? I'm not sure, exactly. I suspect the answer has a lot to do with people having limited bandwidth for vendors in their life and that they derive a lot of value from being able to make one buying decision that covers as many of their needs as possible.
- scarface74 7y agoSeeing that Spotify hasn’t been allowing new subscriptions in the App Store for years, they aren’t paying the 30% fee. That was actually called out in the article.